Iv been trading with pat his vip gold iv got more wins than losses I'll keep it for another month then once I'm making above the price I'll stay. He also trades live and is very helpful.
Response from Forex Robot NationJan 4, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback.
We appreciate you sharing your experience and are glad to hear you’ve seen more wins than losses and found the live trading and support helpful. We understand the importance of results justifying the cost, which is why we continue to make ongoing updates and strategy refinements as market conditions evolve.
We appreciate you giving it another month and welcome any feedback along the way.
JC
John C.
Results are mixed but very misleading reporting overall
I really wanted this to work and I rarely leave reviews, but after giving this service a genuine shot, I feel it’s important others know what they’re getting into. I manually backtested their signals from April through September 2025, following their rules and take-profit structure. If a trader always takes TP1, they would finish this 6-month period up around 10%, which isn’t bad at all. However, if they aim for TP2, the result over the same period would be roughly a 10% loss.
For me, the more concerning part isn’t the performance itself. It’s the way results are presented in their VIP group. Wins are posted very consistently (almost never fails), even when only TP1 is hit with a 0.5–1 R:R. But many times when trades reverse and hit stop loss afterward, those losing outcomes are not posted or updated. Yes, losses appear sometimes, but based on my observation, around half of them simply aren’t mentioned once things turn negative. This creates a very misleading expectation.
There’s also something that stood out: they use two take profits. When TP1 hits then price reverses and hits SL, they count the trade as a win (TP1 taken). But when TP1 and TP2 both hit, they assume TP2 was taken and count the larger win. Most traders either take one TP or split positions 50/50. Their reporting method inflates results in a way normal subscribers likely won’t experience.
I’ve tried many forex signal services over the years, and I can handle mixed returns. What pushed me to write this review is how unreliable and selective the performance reporting feels. Transparency matters, especially in trading.
That said, I am more than happy to be proven wrong. If someone from their team or community can show that I misunderstood the process or that this was simply a statistically unlucky period, I would gladly listen. But six months is not a short period of time, and based on the data I saw, the reporting style makes the service difficult to trust.
Response from Forex Robot NationJan 4, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to leave such a detailed and thoughtful review.
We genuinely appreciate you outlining your experience and the effort you put into reviewing the signals over an extended period. You’re correct that results can vary depending on execution style, take-profit selection, and risk management choices, and we understand how that can affect individual outcomes.
Regarding reporting, we acknowledge the importance of clear and consistent communication. Our intent is never to mislead, and feedback like this helps us identify areas where transparency and clarity can continue to improve. We’ve been actively refining both our strategy execution and how updates are communicated to members to better reflect different trade management approaches.
We respect your perspective and appreciate you raising these concerns in a constructive way. As always, we remain open to feedback and discussion, and we wish you the best in your trading moving forward.
AT
Aces T.
Trade With Pat's VIP Fx worst
I tried Trade With Pat's VIP Fx this September and it is WORST!. SL pips are bigger than TP pips. As of today, the total pips called out is -6pips. NO PROFIT AT ALL!
Response from Forex Robot NationJan 4, 2026
Thank you for sharing your feedback.
We understand your frustration and appreciate you taking the time to leave a review. Risk-to-reward ratios and stop-loss sizing can vary depending on market conditions and the specific setup being traded, and short timeframes can sometimes produce mixed or flat results.
We continue to make ongoing adjustments to our strategies and execution as conditions change, and we always encourage members to follow the full trade plan and risk guidelines shared within the group.
We appreciate the feedback and wish you the best moving forward.
PK
Patryk K.
Do not buy these signals - scam
Do not buy these signals – total scam.
I strongly advise against buying signals from this person. What you see on YouTube or during live sessions is completely different from what you actually receive. Trades are executed using market orders, so you can’t catch them in time.
He brags about a high win rate and a 5:1 risk-reward ratio, but in reality, it’s more like 5 losses to 1 win. TP2 is just 1:1 RR, and it rarely hits – that’s if you even manage to enter the trade at all.
These signals used to be of better quality, but lately, it’s nothing but a scam and a waste of money. Strongly not recommended.
Nie kupujcie tych sygnałów – to oszustwo.
Nie polecam zakupu sygnałów od tej osoby. To, co pokazuje na YouTube czy podczas transmisji na żywo, zupełnie nie pokrywa się z tym, co wysyła w rzeczywistości. Trade’y są otwierane z market orderów, więc nie da się ich złapać na czas.
Chwali się wysokim win rate’em i RR 5:1, ale w praktyce wygląda to jak 5 strat do 1 wygranej. TP2 to jedynie 1:1 RR, do którego rzadko dochodzi – o ile w ogóle zdążysz wejść w pozycję.
Kiedyś te sygnały miały lepszą jakość, ale obecnie to czysta ściema i strata pieniędzy. Zdecydowanie odradzam.
Response from Forex Robot NationAug 6, 2025
HI Patryk, just because July was a difficult month for us doesn't mean this is a scam. July is historically a month we struggle.
If you have issues with the analysis, email us, tell us why. Even good analysis will result in losses at times, that's trading.
In August we are already starting to bounce back, and for the year, over a LONGER sample size, we are doing great.
As for missing trades, there is a free trade copier that can be used to avoid this.
PP
P P.
Amazing work
If you’re serious about improving your trading, go watch Pat’s livestreams. He teaches trading concepts that actually work in real market conditions — no fluff, no gimmicks. Since following him over the past few months, I’ve genuinely improved in every aspect of my trading. I’m now more consistent, more confident, and much more structured in how I approach the markets.
Pat emphasizes simple but powerful concepts: support and resistance, supply and demand zones, trendline breaks, liquidity sweeps, and the core idea of buying low and selling high. He focuses heavily on stacking confluences, which has completely changed the way I look at entries and trade setups.
It’s not about overcomplicating — it’s about doing the basics right with clarity and discipline. Being part of his community has made me a better trader, period.
JW
Japie W.
Their EA didnt execute as promised and…
Their EA didnt execute as promised and no response after emailing them on their website and email address
waste of time
Response from Forex Robot NationJul 18, 2025
The copier is a free addition to the room. It is working on over 1000 machines.
The original email was in our spam, I apologize for missing it.
I don't feel this warrants 1 star, but I wish you all the best.
MC
Martins C.
It is a scam
It is a scam, especially the investment part of this is a total scam. The signals are also scummy since they get sent in and the chart is already 30 pips ahead. DO NOT GIVE THEM MONEY!
Response from Forex Robot NationJun 30, 2025
Martins, you are in a fake telegram channel that is not run by Pat. It is an impersonator.
Only go to links provided in video descriptions, or from the links in Pat's bio in social media.
There is no investment, and there has never been a signal in the official twp group 30 pips ahead. Please be careful, and I hope you will remove your review as it has nothing to do with Pat.
AA
Abdulrahman A.
I have subscribed to his group and This…
I have subscribed to his group and This guy trades on 1 min bases so it’s impossible to catch on with him. Also and this is my biggest problem is that I CANT UNSUBSCRIBE I keep getting charged even when I tried to get in touch with the customer service department I received NO RESPONSE
Response from Forex Robot NationMay 20, 2025
We did respond to your email.
Canceling is very easy, we explain how to cancel before and after purchase. If you go into the telegram bot anytime you can cancel.
You can easily use our scalping trades by using the copy trader, which is active on over 1000 accounts right now.
Please remove this review, it's false.