Saqib J.
Silent on Losing Trades and Win Trades get promotion
I started following Trade With Pat on YouTube and have been in his free Telegram group for six months. He may be a good trader, but my biggest concern is transparency. Winning trades are regularly highlighted, while losing or breakeven trades often receive no final updates. For example, the NZD/USD trade on September 14, 2026, appeared to hit SL, but no loss was acknowledged. I've noticed several similar cases and have screenshots from the original channel. Overall, the signals appear profitable, but **losing trades deserve the same transparency as winning ones.** To clarify, my review is based entirely on my experience with the free Telegram group, not the VIP service, which I haven't tested. **Trading losses are normal. Failing to provide consistent updates on them is what concerns me.**
Response from Forex Robot NationOct 23, 2026
Thanks for the feedback. I completely agree that losses are a normal part of trading. Our free Telegram channel is not maintained as a complete trade journal, and we don’t post a follow-up update on every single free trade, whether it wins or loses. The free room is primarily there to share setups, education, and occasional signals with the community. Our VIP rooms are completely different. Every trade is tracked from entry through to the final result, and in over 5 years of running our VIP service, we have never intentionally omitted a losing trade from our results. I understand how seeing winning trades promoted more often in the free channel could create that impression, though, and that’s fair feedback. We can definitely do a better job making the distinction between the free community and our fully tracked VIP results clearer. We have no problem showing losses. They’re part of trading, and transparency in the service people are actually paying for is extremely important to us.



