Evernest Property ManagementReviews of evernest.co

The communication and assistance when needed make my experience great. Staff responded really quickly to emails.

I engaged Evernest Management , to manage three properties in the greater Orlando area. Almost from day one red flags appeared. They wanted to be listed on my insurance as a beneficiary should anything happened to my properties. I refused and we muturally agreed to part ways in august 2026. However they sent out notices to two of my tenants requesting September rents be paid to them. One of my tenats mistakingly paid his rent for $3,050.00. This was unquestionable fraud, as they ceased to be my agent since August 2026. What is even worse, the rents collected from my tenants for august , to date, has not been deposited to my account. I WARN YOU BE VERY CAREFUL WITH THIS COMPANY they are not operating like a normal professional management company. I WOULD NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THIS COMPANY

Moved in 2 months ago now my air isn't working in the dead of summer and can't get anyone from management to get an havoc company to resolve this problem some so renter beware

Nobody should ever rent from Evernest or list their property with them. This company is the epitome of incompetence and has predatory practices regarding the return of security deposits. I left my rental spotless (I have photos to prove this) and they withheld over $500 from my security deposit for "cleaning" because the small tray in the fridge water dispenser was "stained". It's not stained, it's plastic and over the years the minerals in the water discolor it. It's not something that can be cleaned off. Absolutely criminal to charge over $500 and have this as their only reason. If you read other reviews online as well as the multiple lawsuits they have against them, you'll see this is a common practice. While living in this property, I was charged for a tiny water spot that occurred in the basement (where there had been water seeping into the house from bad insulation, hvac, WHATEVER it was that they never were able to remedy) This was a documented ongoing issue with this property for years, and they just decided one day to charge me for the maintenance guy spray painting over it, saying the moisture was my fault somehow. I followed up MANY times trying to get the charge removed, and they just stopped responding and then threatened to charge me a late fee if the charge wasn't paid. Again, criminal. I also spent 2 weeks without a functioning kitchen faucet. It was old and just stopped running/was clogged. I tried to call, email, to see when someone would come replace the faucet. At 2 weeks, I was frustrated enough that I went to Home Depot, bought a faucet and installed it myself. It was totally fine, solved the issue. But I literally had to go out and buy a faucet for my RENTAL. I followed up to tell them, and of course, nobody responded. I was thankful to finally move out of this dump, and I see that the listing photos they are currently using are from 10+ years ago. It doesn't represent in any way what the property looks like now. I don't understand how this company even exists, except that they make money by preying upon tenants and swindling home owners, knowing that most people don't have the resources to persue legal action against them. DO NOT EVER RENT FROM THIS COMPANY!

Excellent service—professional and friendly. Mari is a wonderful, highly professional person who helps with whatever is needed.

I can say so much but TLDR, I've been renting a property in GA with an broken AC unit. I mistakenly signed a 2 year lease and have been stuck in a home for over 1.5 years now with a house that is 80° due to broken AC. It has not been fixed as of today and I doubt it ever will. Worst experience of my life.

Absolutely horrible property management company. They care very little about about their tenants and ignore maintenance requests for weeks and even months. Communication is non-existent. Staff is oblivious and could care less about the tenants. We will never lease another Evernest property. Gross negligence is the only term for it. Hopefully they find themselves in a lawsuit soon enough. Their negligence is going to lead them down that path sooner or later. I'll be cheering for the plaintiff. I like how they are leaving their own positive reviews trying to make themselves look better too. Nice try.

Currently renting a property through Evernest and we've had nothing but problems with the house and maintenance. A leak from our bathroom to the kitchen ceiling was just patched up and now we have soft spots in our tub and probably a ton of mold that still has yet to be addressed even though they came by weeks ago to look at it. We had a whole section of our fence down for over a month before they decided to replace it. And now our air conditioning has been out since Saturday (5 days now) and our house is 84 degrees and nothing is being done about it. My wife and I have been sleeping on the couch in our living room with 6 fans running because we can't even exist in our bedroom for more than a few minutes with how hot it is upstairs. I'm starting to genuinely feel sick from how much heat exposure and exhaustion I've been dealing with. We can't even use our kitchen because it would make the house get to 90+ degrees. This is unacceptable and a blatant disregard for the wellbeing of their residents. I'm disgusted at how much back and forth I've had to fight for just some kind of vague communication. I will not be renewing my lease when the time comes.