Katie
No help for missing items valued at $1,000
Edit: Rachel from Everlane reached out after I wrote this review and was able to ship the missing items. I received them yesterday and all is well. It's still upsetting that it took so much effort and frustration to find a real person to address my concerns, but it all worked out in the end. Thank you Rachel! I have been shopping at Everlane for a long time, but this experience has tainted the brand for me. I ordered 12 items online and received one tracking number. According to the shipping confirmation email, all items should have been in that package. But when it arrived, only 4 items were inside. The package was not tampered with in any way, and was clearly not large enough to hold my full order. I have cameras in front of my house, so I can see that only one package was delivered and nothing was stolen. I can only assume the other items were sent in a different package, or not sent at all. I reached out to Everlane to see if there was an additional tracking number for the other items, and they told me to file a claim with Onward PackageProtect. I did that, and Onward told me I have to file a police report in order to get a refund or replacement. I do not feel comfortable filing a report with my local police for a theft that didn't happen, as it is a crime to file a false report. I've pushed back several times on this with Onward and Everlane, but no one will acknowledge my concerns. It's been nearly impossible to talk to an actual human. The entire burden has been placed on me to correct the issue, even though the problem is clearly on their end with their warehouse or logistics system. It seems they are more concerned with getting money from insurance for the missing items than actually helping me, their customer, get the items I already paid for. I am furious and heartbroken. The 8 missing items are valued at almost $1,000, which is a lot of money for someone like me. I recently got a new job and wanted to dress the part, but this has really set me back. I am trying to work with my bank to reverse the charge, but am extremely disappointed in the lack of customer care throughout this process.
Response from EverlaneApr 23, 2026
Hi Katie! Rachel here from the Everlane Customer Experience team. I'm so sorry for the frustration with your order! I've reached out via email with the hopes of making things right. I look forward to hearing back from you! Rachel Everlane CX


