Prepare for the unexpected - a journey that will ignite your taste buds, reward your curiosity and turn any visit into so much more than your typical night out.
Bonefish Grill (bonefishgrill.com) has 96 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.6 out of 5.
Also known as
bonefishgrill.com
Website
bonefishgrill.com
Category
General Restaurants
Location
Tampa, Florida
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company has not replied to any reviews yet.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
The food wasn't what I was told it was. My nephew girlfriend ordered the steak dinner medium rare and it came back to her rear and she had to send it back to the kitchen and then they re-cooked it and then they overcooked it.
I ordered the shrimp mignon with french fries and coleslaw now that dish was okay but it was to sweet and then I ordered the fish and chip which I did not know it was not whities instead it was cod fish which I don't eat!!
Their variety of dishes are limited.
We also ordered my daughter a virgin margarita and my daughter was bought a lemon water with lettuce in the glass.
I guess that's how they do it but that's not what we ordered for my daughter!!😠😠
MM
Mary M.
Everything
Everything! From entering to seating! Staff was prompt and polite. My waiter was/is the best! My food was excellent and seasoned perfectly for me! Didn’t have to add anything. And not overly portioned. Was a great experience for me. Will definitely be back!
JS
Joel S.
Very Impressed!
Visited the Bothell, WA location with friends and the staff was over-the-top friendly and the customer service was excellent as was the food.
VS
Vernon S.
Visited the location in Elmo
Visited the location in Elmo, SC for Mother's Day. We were in Columbia visiting our son. The music was so loud, we mentioned it to the waitress because we could not hear her and she said yes, it is loud. I understand trying to attract a younger clientele, but the loudness of the music made customers talk louder and led to an unenjoyable dining experience. If not my son and wife there, I would have gone elsewhere. The prices for the amount of food is too high. I ordered the shrimp/pasta/scallop dinner. Three small shrimp and about 15 miniature scallop. My wife had the scallop/mignon, with asparagus. Three spears of asparagus, very small mignon and again, miniature scallop. Although tasty, it was not worth the high price. I wanted to say something to the manager was politely asked not to. I
ML
Mark L.
Had a great dinner this evening
Had a great dinner this evening! Lynn B was awesome! 5 STARS for sure! BoneFish Grill, 5025 N 12th Ave, Pensacola, Florida
RS
Rich S.
It's not like it used to be
In the past, Bonefish Grill has been a restaurant that I had considered somewhat upscale with outstanding service and food. This past Monday evening, 1/9/23, I was at dinner with 8 other people at the Bonefish on McMullen Booth Rd. Our experience was far from what was expected. Timing was not an issue since we were there to celebrate a birthday for a friend. Although there were very few people in the restaurant, it took a considerable time to first take our drink orders and bring water to the table. The server appeared to have little experience as she seemed to be somewhat confused while taking our orders, but we were patient. As the food came out, 4 of the people present received their food, while the remaining 5 people sat and waited. The wait had been about 10 minutes until eventually, the entire table was served. A member of our group ordered fish and when it had come out, it had a real fishy smell which indicates that the fish was not fresh. She had subsequently gotten ill afterward. I ordered a filet mignon medium rare. As I cut into the meat, although it was more done than desired, I reluctantly ate it. This was the toughest filet mignon I have ever had. Along with a relatively small scoop of mashed potatoes, this was one of the worst dinner experiences I have ever had. My wife had a dish served with rice, however, the rice was cold. The manner in which the food was served and the table service lacking, we opted to not complain and to just enjoy visiting with friends.
Although it was a Monday evening during dinner hour, the restaurant was virtually empty. The shopping center is undergoing renovations; however, this is not an excuse for poor service and low quality of food.
Overall, I am very disappointed that this meal was far from what would be expected at any restaurant, and specifically a restaurant with the reputation as a destination location for high quality food and service. Neither my wife or I had any alcohol drinks with our dinner and with tip, this was a $65.00 disappointment.
DM
david M.
fish and chips was the worst i have…
fish and chips was the worst i have ever had,the tempura was super thick with a tiny bit of fish and if you peeled off the tempura the fish was so overcooked and was tough,bottom of the platter had pooled grease,which yhe chips were soaked in,will not be back as 16 dollars is outrageous fot this.
TS
Tony S.
Bonefish - terrible fish and chips
We were in the Bonefish, Littleton, Colorado on November 5. It took 15 minutes before anyone came to service us. They apologized and comped our soup. I have the fish and chips and it was terrible. the breading was hard, thick, and greasy. The taste was greasy and it was hard to even taste the fish. Years ago I had the fish and chips at Bonefish and it was light and flaky.