Addie G.
Overall a better site with more seller…
Overall a better site with more seller friendly practices than etsy by far. It's sometimes a bit annoying to hear about a new feature only to find out that it isn't available with the page design you chose, especially when there are so few designs to pick from. For the price, it feels like you should get more options. Needing to code a whole page for a feature like a gallery on half of the options feels pretty silly. The shipping is pretty faulty too no matter how precise you are with your weights and measurements, I wish it was more integrated with the shipping sites like shippo or pirate ship that always get the costs right versus using the numbers from the shipping companies directly which means you over charge or under charge consistently. Still somehow the best site I've used so far.
Response from Big CartelJul 21, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to leave such thoughtful feedback. We're really glad to hear Big Cartel has been your favorite platform overall, and we appreciate your kind words, specifics around pain points, and your constructive suggestions. Feedback like this is incredibly helpful, and I'll be sure to share it with our team as we continue improving the platform. Thanks again for sticking with us and for being part of the Big Cartel community!💫