CR
Faulty design lead to product failure
Received a chandelier and unfortunately did not try to install it until after the return period. I believe this unit is designed with a structural flaw, as it comes in two wide pieces intended to be held together with a 2mm long set screw. Inevitably, this put far too much pressure at the fulcrum point where the set screw was situated, causing the metal support to deform, and the chandelier to split in half at the middle. While the company - at first - was very responsive, and even sent replacement parts, all of the parts failed in exactly the same way. They repeatedly deleted my reviews of the product where I tried to disclose this flaw on the product, in which I included pictures to demo strate the flaw. This is biggest red flag to me - blocking negative, but honest reviews. Also note: the FAQ on their page states the products have a warranty, but when asked for details on the warranty, I received the response that it is just the 30 day return window; no actual warranty exists. They do get one star back for having attempted to be helpful despite being outside the return window. I acknowledge it's my fault for not assembling it within the period of the return window. But it certainly still stings to spend over $800 on something that's destined for the dump because of shoddy construction. As always, buyer beware. UPDATE IN RESPONSE TO THE SELLER: I did not ask for a refund, I simply asked for installation instructions and a clarification of warranty procedure. The light, which comes with over 40 separate, individual pieces comes with a single image for installation, which regards wiring only. When asked how to assemble the fixture itself, not the wiring, I received a YouTube link that only showed installation of the first step. Following this step is what led to the faulty component failing each time I tried. When asked if I had done something wrong, and what is supposed to be done with the other 40+ pieces not in the video, I was met with the response "it is simple. If you can't figure it out, hire an electrician." I had had an electrician come out to assess the installation cost, which is when I finally realized what a mess this product was, and was intending to hire them to manage the installation. But I don't think an electrician will generally handle IKEA-esque assembly as part of their duties, especially when no instructions are included. The electrician also noted the oddity that the product did not use US standard wiring. As mentioned above, I give the company a second star for being willing to try to help, even outside the return window. But the product is a one star, plastic, unstable, and (for me) unusable $900 mistake. The company's unwillingness to allow me to disclose my experience, with pictures. I was asking for warranty details not to get a refund from my CC, but to exercise their extended warranty program. I made this explicitly clear because, again, I knew I would not be able to cancel the charge since I was in the wrong being outside the return window. I have never disputed this charge and have not had my CC company take any action against ATY. The response they are providing here with regards to warranty differs from the response I received. I was told, direct quote "We didn't not advertise or offer any kind of warranty on this product, not in product description or in our promotional materials." When I sent a screenshot of their FAQ highlighting the section that noted products came with a warranty and asking them to elaborate, I never heard from the company again until they responded above, here. Again, I recognize I have fault here as well for not operating within the return window. That is why I do not, and did not, expect a refund. I was only hoping to get to a point where the light was hanging in my dining room, not sitting like a disassembled erector set in my closet.
Response from ATY Home DecorFeb 22, 2023
Hello, We always strive to provide each of our customers the best experience buying on ATY Home Decor and this is exactly what we did for this customer, the customer placed his order June 2022 and emailed us claiming the product was defective on November 22, 2022 which is 5 months later his purchase time and asked for a refund, there is no company in this world will offer a return after this period of time and we declined the return request and offered a replacement. The customer is not an electrician and he has a very basic knowledge, we shipped another replacement by express fast shipping with lot of extra tools and new ceiling base and asked the customer to hire an electriction to do the installation to avoid damaging the parts but the customer refused and installed the chandelier in the same wrong way he did in the first time. We explained to the customer that the warranty does not cover damage happens due to the wrong installation method, even with that we still filled our committment and shipped a replacement but the customer inssisted to receive a refund through his CC company. We have sold hundreds of this chandelier and the product received 5 stars review from several interiors and professionals who really value the product design and never reported any issues to us related to the design or the product installation.

