Catherine G.
Artsy does not do what they say....
Artsy states that they will provide a certificate of authenticity for the works represented on their sites. In my interaction with them, they failed to provide a Certificate of Authenticity, and when I pushed them on it and withheld payment, they ceased to work to provide an industry accepted certificate of authenticity and stated that an opinion letter is as good as a COA. I am fighting this now. The actual gallery who presented the piece indicated that they would obtain a COA and provide that to me. Artsy stopped them from doing so... stating that there was no requirement. I do not trust Artsy. I do not recommend. Go through your normal gallery connections to ensure that you can have a good experience and get the documentation that you need to support your pieces.
Response from ArtsyJan 23, 2026
Hi Catherine, we’re sorry to hear this experience was frustrating. In this case, the artwork was fulfilled as described, and no evidence of authenticity concerns was identified or presented. Artsy worked closely with the gallery and took steps beyond standard policy requirements to support you and work toward a resolution. Once a chargeback was initiated on your side, the matter was required to proceed through this formal dispute process. Both the gallery and our team had actively assisted prior to that point. If you have any further questions, you’re welcome to follow up via the existing email thread.




