Valerie M.
Management Let Us Down. The Movers Worked Hard.
We have moved many times and this move from LA to Nashville went sour because of management team. There were good parts of our experience, which makes what happened afterward even more disappointing. We paid approximately $12,215 to move across country. I had already packed and meticulously organized most of our home myself. The five-person LA team was incredible. Their focus was disassembling and wrapping furniture, and they had the entire house finished by around 1 PM starting at 7am. There was an unexpected additional charge because of where their truck could park in our LA neighborhood, something I felt could have been identified beforehand if the property and logistics team had been properly assessed as I requested. The move fell apart in the handling of our belongings across country and the manager of the subcontracted moving company in Nashville that American Van Lines hired. Everything I personally packed arrived safely. The significant damage was to furniture and other items handled/wrapped by the movers. Before the move, I specifically raised concerns about the steep driveway at our Nashville rental, which I had never seen in person, and asked that the local team assess it in person to determine the right truck and approach. That didn't happen. The truck(s) assigned couldn't access the house. Only two movers were initially assigned, and they had to manually carry our belongings up the hill and bring in additional help. The move-in lasted all day and into the night. I felt terrible for the guys and bought them a late lunch and kept snacks available because they worked incredibly hard. My issue isn't with those workers. My issue is with the planning that put both them and our belongings in that situation. Comparable and even larger trucks have since successfully driven up the same driveway, which we documented. American Van Lines did send a repair team, and some items were fixed. I personally repaired others rather than claiming everything that was damaged. For the remaining items, our documented losses totaled approximately $2,175. American Van Lines offered us $275. Consumer warning: understand exactly what valuation coverage you're signing. We didn't purchase the more expensive full-value protection, so their offer is based largely on item weight rather than actual replacement cost. One dining chair alone cost $299 to replace. I went above and beyond preparing the claim, researching purchase information, replacement costs and weights and providing photos. We weren't asking for an enormous payout. Our entire claim was less than 20% of what we paid for the move and didn't include items we repaired ourselves. What has ultimately made this an experience the worst is the lack of accountability afterward. Our claim was acknowledged in April and we were told it would be completed by June 8. It is now September. We've exchanged 20+ emails, made multiple phone calls, rejected the $275 offer in writing, been promised management follow-up that never happened, and most recently sent the entire history and documentation directly to an adjuster and manager. Still no response. Mistakes happen during moves. What defines a company is what happens after something goes wrong. We've been patient, reasonable and thorough, yet somehow we're still the ones doing all the work. My advice: read the valuation fine print, INSIST unusual access issues at BOTH properties are assessed before moving day, and document everything. At this point, I cannot recommend American Van Lines for a major interstate move. If they finally take ownership and resolve our claim fairly, I will gladly update this review. I hope they give me a reason to do so.




