Afternic, a GoDaddy brand, is the world’s premiere domain marketplace, listing more than 20 million premium domain names available for sale and receiving more than 75 million domain searches each month—more than any other domain marketplace.Whether you are a domain buyer or a domain seller, Afternic is the most trusted name in domains.
Afternic (afternic.com) has 413 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.9 out of 5.
Also known as
afternic.com
Website
afternic.com
Category
Malls & Marketplaces
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 75% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
bad service i sold domain 10 days ago and don't get payment
Response from AfternicMar 26, 2025
Hello Rachid,
Thank you for your feedback. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot requesting additional information.
My thanks,
JM
DL
Daniel L.
Sold my domain without approval and…
Sold my domain without approval and refused to recover it despite promises on the phone - TOTAL SCAM DO NOT TRUST
Response from AfternicMar 25, 2025
Hello Daniel,
Thank you for your feedback. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot requesting additional information.
My thanks,
JM
Hello Uri ,
I would like to thank you for your feedback and for the opportunity to clarify that we are a legitimate Domain Aftermarket that has been established since 1999. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot for more information.
My thanks,
JM
RB
Robert B.
Afternic tried to rob me-I just read these reviews and feel the…
UPDATE:CLICK MY USER PHOTO FOR INVOICE OF THIS TRANSACTION
After numerous calls and one to the complaint department at Godaddy (who advised they can’t do anything and I must call Afternic) My money hit my bank account at 11 pm at night last night! It wasn’t worth it especially after they took 30%! I am glad to report I did not get robbed but they surely were working the same plan as many here have experienced! I had enough time on hold with go daddy to buy some domain names to create a few websites and publish so the world knows to beware of Afternic! AfternicReviews.com and AvoidGodaddy.com are in the works and will go live soon. No matter the outcome, taking 30% and then putting the customer (me) through hoops of fire is a joke. This service is worth no more than 10% of at all . My life’s goal at this moment is to MAKE ALL DOMAINERS both buyer and seller aware of what’s to come for them when dealing with Afternic and Godaddy as they are the parent company. Afternic needs a person like me to run it so they can regain their image which they may have never had a positive one. Beware of both if you like a stress free transaction. There are other great sites to buy and sell which Inhave always used in the past. Unfortunately for me, the buyer found AICERTIFICATE.COM on Afternic . I prefer sedo, flippa, and others as they have NEVER put me through such a fiasco. Have even in the domain game since 1997 and Afternic takes the cake for their process, fees and service.
***INITIAL REVIEW***
I just read these reviews and feel the same is happening with me! They sold my domain name AICertificate.com for $4,444 and then took 30% transferred my name to the new buyer and have yet to get paid. The first time they said the tax forms weren’t filed correctly. I rectified that with a Transaction assurance agent over the phome who knew nothing which dumbfounded me. She said she saw the forms completed and the payout would be done at 9 am EST Today. The website is super buggy which i figured out for afternic. I called this morming to verify the payout was complete to only be told by Dena that now this could take 24-48 hours to process then 1-5 days to hit my bank! I’m pissed and just yanked all my domains from afternic and when back to the office will pull all from Godaddy and Dynadot! I won’t be robbed by anyone yet I feel I have been at this point. The name is already someone else’s website and i have nothing. The assurance agent Lyubov even sent me an email stating my facts amd that the payput would be done this morming, but now the story has changed. i will sue everyone out of principle on this one. Afternic, Godaddy and Dynadot!
one pissed off ex customer
Response from AfternicMar 20, 2025
Hello Robert ,
Thank you for your feedback. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot requesting additional information.
My thanks,
JM
CU
customer
Afternic is a Scam – They Steal Your Money and Avoid Paying Sellers
Afternic is a complete scam! I sold a domain through their platform, and despite multiple confirmations from their support team that my payment was "successfully processed," I never received a single cent.
After waiting over 10 days, I contacted my bank, and they confirmed there was never even an attempt to transfer the money. Afternic first claimed the payment was sent, then changed their story and said the bank rejected it—a complete lie. The bank further confirmed that they do not block incoming transactions, and if there were an issue, the money would have been placed in a temporary account. That never happened because Afternic never actually sent the money.
I repeatedly requested a SWIFT transaction document as proof of payment, but Afternic refused to provide it. Instead, they sent an internal receipt from their payment processor, which is NOT a proof of transaction. My wife, who works at the bank, checked everything, and there was zero evidence of any payment attempt from Afternic.
Now they are ignoring my requests and refusing to provide real proof. This company is running a fraudulent operation, stealing money from domain sellers while pretending to make payments.
If you value your time and money, stay FAR AWAY from Afternic. I will be pulling all my domains from GoDaddy and warning others to avoid this scam at all costs. If they continue this behavior, legal action will follow.
Response from AfternicMar 20, 2025
Hello customer,
Thank you for your feedback. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot requesting additional information.
My thanks,
JM
MM
Matt M.
Weeks have gone by and still no…
Weeks have gone by and still no payment. They keep telling me my bank isnt accurate. It is. Ive confirmed with BofA. These guys are so full of shit. Ive fw to my office to review for fraud.
Response from AfternicMar 13, 2025
Hello Matt,
Thank you for your feedback. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot requesting additional information.
My thanks,
JM
MA
Muhammad Arslan N.
Payout Transactions are very smooth
I have sold 4 domains within last 12 months by using Afternic platform. Overall I have excellent experience. They charge 15% on sale if domain is using Afternic nameservers, 20% if using their nameserver along with boost feature and 30% if domain is using nameserver other than Afternic. My all 4 transactions were very smooth and I received payment on time without any problem.
Response from AfternicMar 13, 2025
Hello Muhammad,
Thank you for your feedback. We are very glad to hear that you received such great support from us. We look forward to helping again in the future and thank you for being a GoDaddy customer.
With much appreciation,
-JM
CB
Christopher B.
Afternic - deception - greed
Been with Godaddy since it started. Have spent thousands of $ on domains has i have several websites and lots of domains. Godaddy bought Afternic and from within my Godaddy account i listed tons of domains for-sale with internal account with afternic. I went through the entire back end within Godaddy and how they connect to their own brand Afternic. I even use my Godaddy login for the Afternic. Been loyal to the Godaddy brand forever and even own thousands of dollar of shares in stock. So was able to sell 2 domains this week and got good $ for them. Found out that the commission is 30% not the 20%. Even at 20% it seems high but for the security of all going through godadaddy escrow it is worth it. Afternic denied me the 20% rate due to some landing page policy meanwhile all my domains when you search for them all have url afternic.com and the rest of the url for that paricular domain. All i did was list the domains inside my godaddy / afternic account. Now they want to charge the 30% rate and not the 20% for whatever reason they have invented when i have had these listings live for years. Ever since Godaddy had it setup within your account. I have reached out to support and you get nowhere. Really pissed that Godaddy company would allow this to happen within their company. So i am advising anyone selling domains to never use afternic services especially at their high % rates. It is pure theft. Plus addressing the issue with support went nowhere. Really pissed since i have been loyal godaddy customer, stayed within my account , followed the internal process to have deception and spent thousands. To have this of process is aweful. Selling shares of stock. This review, people selling stock, and my own further business will add up to way more losses in customers and revenue, for what they do. I can see why now when i went to do this review i saw at 2.7 star rating. Never though that a Godaddy brand would have such a bad rating. Now you know why from a real loyal customer!!!!
Update for this review. After 4 different support contacts, they went to the 20% commission rate vs the 30% rate they charged. I listed these domains 3 years ago and let it just keeping running. Their policy changes is what caused the issue with them. Still was unhappy that i had to go through this process to get something that was listed, fair and proper pricing. Pay 30% commission on a $4k sale is absurd. I get the percentage wants to be higher for the low domain sales, but when they are higher in price, there should be a flat rate about a threshold. At least they resolved the issue with me after 4 days. I still stand by my review though since i had to go through the process.
Response from AfternicMar 6, 2025
Hello Christopher,
Thank you for your feedback and I am sorry to hear of your disappointment with our commissions structure and customer support. I would like to better understand your experience and have sent you an email through Trustpilot requesting additional information.
My thanks,
JM