Whiskey Library Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of whiskeylibrary.com

Whiskey LibraryReviews of whiskeylibrary.com

4.2507 reviews
Beverages & Liquor

Whiskey Library

About Whiskey Library

Discover Premium Whiskeys at Whiskey LibraryWhiskey Library is your ultimate online destination for rare and hard-to-find whiskeys. Founded by passionate aficionados, our mission is to simplify your search for unique spirits and deliver them conveniently to your doorstep.Extensive Selection of Premium WhiskeysExplore our meticulously curated collection of American whiskeys, including bourbon, rye, single malt, and blended options. We also offer world-class selections from renowned regions like Scotland, Ireland, Canada, and Japan. Discover exclusive releases such as the Doc Holliday 10-Year-Old Bourbon and unique limited editions that are hard to find elsewhere.Exceptional Shopping ExperienceOur user-friendly platform ensures a seamless shopping experience, from intuitive navigation to secure, timely delivery. As a member of our exclusive Library Card program, you enjoy benefits like free shipping, priority access to rare single-barrel picks, and early access to limited releases.Engaging Community of Whiskey EnthusiastsBeyond being a retailer, Whiskey Library fosters a vibrant community of whiskey lovers. Engage with insightful blogs, expert reviews, and exclusive events that enrich your whiskey journey. Our commitment to quality, integrity, and community reflects our foundational value of "Preet" (love), evident in every aspect of our service.Why Choose Whiskey Library? Specialized Expertise: Our focus on whiskey ensures a curated selection that caters to both connoisseurs and newcomers. Exclusive Membership Benefits: The Library Card program offers perks designed to enhance your whiskey experience. Community Engagement: Join a community passionate about whiskey through our blogs, reviews, and events.Whether you're a seasoned connoisseur or a curious beginner, Whiskey Library invites you to explore, savor, and share the rich, diverse world of premium whiskey with us.

Whiskey Library (whiskeylibrary.com) has 507 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.

Also known as: whiskeylibrary.com
Website: whiskeylibrary.com
Category: Beverages & Liquor
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 94% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Beverages & Liquor

Whiskey Library reviews

507 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Mark W.
Oct 2, 2026
Everything was good so far except shipping process.
Everything was good so far. I really enjoyed the Lost bottle. My girlfriend’s favorite was the Clyde Mays. The shipping was the only issue. I had to make several trips to a location about 20 miles away as I was not home when UPS delivered and they needed an ID. Then the item was shipped all over southern Indiana and finally arrived at a local business that I had to pay to have it delivered to. I travel for work and I’m single so I need a free shipping option so I can have it delivered somewhere else or to my neighbors when I’m not in the area. I’m going to have the same issue this time I’m sure.
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Mark, thank you for the detailed feedback, and glad to hear the Lost bottle and the Clyde Mays were hits, especially the Clyde Mays being a favorite. We're sorry the shipping process gave you such a headache though, having to chase down a package across multiple locations and pay for delivery isn't what we want for anyone, especially when travel makes being home for delivery tricky. Could you reach out to [email protected] so we can look at the delivery options available for your address, including whether an alternate delivery location can be set up for future shipments? We appreciate you sticking with us through that, and we'd like to get this sorted before your next shipment goes out. Cheers, The Whiskey Library Support Team
Report
David H.
Oct 2, 2026
Started off quite excited…
While my overall experience was good, it was tainted by my being told that the Old Soul Tintype #1 was out of stock, and this was several days after my order being confirmed. I’ve worked in the wine and spirits industry for years and one the most important aspects on the retail side is make sure you maintain an accurate inventory as this helps builds buyer confidence and trust, particularly with so much competition out there! On a more positive note, Whiskey Library gets kudos for carrying harder to find options and were outstanding in terms of communication before I placed my first order.
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi David, thank you for the thoughtful feedback, and especially for calling out the pre-order communication and the harder to find selection, we're glad those stood out. You're right that accurate inventory matters, and finding out the Old Soul Tintype #1 was out of stock days after your order was confirmed isn't the experience we want to give someone, especially with the industry background you're bringing to that point. We've got your order pulled up and will look into what happened and make sure it's resolved properly. We appreciate the honest take, inventory accuracy is something worth getting right and feedback like this helps us do that. Cheers, The Whiskey Library Support Team
Report
Mike P.
Oct 2, 2026
Great service and great selection
Great service and great selection! The gang hasn’t disappoint yet and I highly doubt that they ever will!
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Mike, Thank you so much for the fantastic 5-star review! We're thrilled to hear the service and selection have been great, and that we haven't disappointed you yet, that's a track record we plan on keeping up. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to proving you right for a long time to come! Cheers The Whiskey Library Support Team.
Report
Michael D.
Oct 2, 2026
I love the experience
I love the experience, and the surprises each month. The only downside is shipping issues. Either shipments being lost, or damaged.
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Michael, thank you for the review, we're glad to hear you love the experience and the monthly surprises. We're sorry to hear shipping has been a recurring issue for you though, lost or damaged shipments shouldn't be something you have to deal with regularly. Could you reach out to [email protected] with details on the shipments that were affected? We'd like to look into what's been happening and get it fixed going forward. We appreciate you sticking with us despite that, and we want the shipping experience to match how much you're enjoying everything else. Cheers, The Whiskey Library Support Team
Report
Eric S.
Oct 2, 2026
The little extras like a hat and…
The little extras like a hat and glasses are not important to us. Also, the high alcohol content is not necessary either. Flavor is our goal!
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Eric, thank you for the feedback, and for being upfront about what matters most to you. Good to know the extras aren't a big draw for you, flavor being the real goal is something we're with you on. We appreciate you taking the time to share what you'd rather see more of, feedback like this helps us shape things going forward. Cheers, The Whiskey Library Support Team
Report
Christopher
Oct 2, 2026
Lack of Communication
Hello, I purchased a couple bottle from Whiskey Library and had a good experience. The last bottle I purchased, I received a different bottle from the same brand. I followed the instructions to get my bottle replaced with the correct bottle. Although I followed the instructions, I never received any further correspondence or confirmation of my issue. With this, I ceased from buying anything from Whiskey Library.
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Christopher, thank you for taking the time to share this, and we're sorry to hear about the trouble with the bottle replacement. You followed the instructions and did everything right, so the fact that it went unanswered after that is on us, not something you should have had to chase. We've reached out to you directly by email to get this resolved and make sure you get the correct bottle. We're sorry this is what led you to step away, and we'd really like the chance to make it right and earn your business back. Cheers, The Whiskey Library Support Team
Report
Justin W.
Oct 1, 2026
Greatest customer service of anywhere
Greatest customer service of anywhere. Love the selection and experience that comes with being a part of whiskey library.
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Justin, Thank you so much for the fantastic 5-star review! We're thrilled to hear you'd call us the greatest customer service anywhere, and that the selection and overall experience have made being part of Whiskey Library feel worth it. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to keeping that experience going for you! Cheers The Whiskey Library Support Team.
Report
Alexander
Oct 1, 2026
1 year of mystery boxes
Today is officially my 1 year anniversary with Whiskey Library Mystery Boxes. 6 Connoisseur mystery boxes as of today's delivery. Excited to add these to the collection. 3 new bottles I've never seen in a store near me. Whiskey Library does a great job with these!
Response from Whiskey LibraryOct 2, 2026
Hi Alexander, Thank you so much for the fantastic 5-star review, and happy 1 year with Whiskey Library Mystery Boxes! Six Connoisseur boxes in and still finding 3 new bottles you've never seen in a store near you is exactly the kind of discovery we love hearing about. We truly appreciate your support over this past year and look forward to filling out that collection with many more boxes to come! Cheers The Whiskey Library Support Tea
Report