Whiskey Library Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of whiskeylibrary.com

Whiskey LibraryReviews of whiskeylibrary.com

4.2507 reviews
Beverages & Liquor

Whiskey Library

About Whiskey Library

Discover Premium Whiskeys at Whiskey LibraryWhiskey Library is your ultimate online destination for rare and hard-to-find whiskeys. Founded by passionate aficionados, our mission is to simplify your search for unique spirits and deliver them conveniently to your doorstep.Extensive Selection of Premium WhiskeysExplore our meticulously curated collection of American whiskeys, including bourbon, rye, single malt, and blended options. We also offer world-class selections from renowned regions like Scotland, Ireland, Canada, and Japan. Discover exclusive releases such as the Doc Holliday 10-Year-Old Bourbon and unique limited editions that are hard to find elsewhere.Exceptional Shopping ExperienceOur user-friendly platform ensures a seamless shopping experience, from intuitive navigation to secure, timely delivery. As a member of our exclusive Library Card program, you enjoy benefits like free shipping, priority access to rare single-barrel picks, and early access to limited releases.Engaging Community of Whiskey EnthusiastsBeyond being a retailer, Whiskey Library fosters a vibrant community of whiskey lovers. Engage with insightful blogs, expert reviews, and exclusive events that enrich your whiskey journey. Our commitment to quality, integrity, and community reflects our foundational value of "Preet" (love), evident in every aspect of our service.Why Choose Whiskey Library? Specialized Expertise: Our focus on whiskey ensures a curated selection that caters to both connoisseurs and newcomers. Exclusive Membership Benefits: The Library Card program offers perks designed to enhance your whiskey experience. Community Engagement: Join a community passionate about whiskey through our blogs, reviews, and events.Whether you're a seasoned connoisseur or a curious beginner, Whiskey Library invites you to explore, savor, and share the rich, diverse world of premium whiskey with us.

Whiskey Library (whiskeylibrary.com) has 507 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.

Also known as: whiskeylibrary.com
Website: whiskeylibrary.com
Category: Beverages & Liquor
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 94% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Beverages & Liquor

Whiskey Library reviews

507 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Austin A.
Oct 26, 2026
Worth the price
On time shipping and getting new and interesting bottles i can't get locally
Report
David L.
Oct 24, 2026
Very happy with this in all aspects
Very happy with this in all aspects
Report
Suzanne M.
Oct 24, 2026
Fun!
We are really enjoying the variety we have received from our mystery box! Looking forward to the next select9.
Report
Gina B.
Oct 24, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Whiskey Library has truly earned this Bourbon Witch’s loyalty! 🥃🧙‍♀️ Every bottle I've received has been an incredible discovery. I absolutely love the excitement of my monthly surprise, especially knowing I'm getting unique, hard-to-find whiskeys that you won't find at your average liquor store. But what truly sets Whiskey Library apart is their exceptional customer service. Last month, my shipment arrived damaged, and they immediately responded, offering either a replacement or a credit. No hassle, no excuses, just outstanding service. Great whiskey is one thing, but integrity and customer care are what keep me coming back. **Whiskey Library, you've earned five stars and a permanent place in this Bourbon Witch's collection.** 🌙🥃✨ A little mystery, a little magic, and a damn good pour. Cheers!
Report
Veldonna R.
Oct 24, 2026
Delivery was fast
Delivery was fast. Items we got were full size and very good quality.
Report
OSIRIS L.
Oct 24, 2026
Love this subscription
Love this subscription. Wish I got two bottles every month but sometimes it’s one bottle. I get to try different bourbons some I like some I don’t but I get to add the non favorites to my bar. But I also understand I’m not got to like everything. If you are looking to try new stuff this is the way to go.
Report
Ji
Oct 24, 2026
It took forever to get the order and…
It took forever to get the order and they screwed it up three times! I guess I should’ve never decided after I bought the first one they said oh get the second one and third one well then they charge right away they don’t wanna give it to you right away, but I never got my glasses. I never got any of the books. I don’t even know what those are still never got those and will never see them. I don’t feel like the value for the money and I was very hard to get a hold of everybody.
Report
Joe B.
Oct 24, 2026
Good bourbon but not what is heavily marketed
I have a top tier subscription and the bourbons are good, but I am yet to receive any of the “look at what you can get” bourbons that are so heavily advertised in all of WL’s advertising. Disappointing a bit at this price point
Report