Larry K.
I decided to give this a try
I decided to give this a try, following their advice by mixing 1-inch squares into my dogs’ regular food. One dog refused to eat it, probably because she’s had better quality raw meats from me than this pasty stuff. The other ended up with diarrhea but was fine once I stopped the raw meat. Now I’m cooking it instead, but one dog won’t touch the beef, and the other doesn’t like the turkey. I’m back to baking chicken legs and thighs, ground turkey, and ground beef with some brown rice and veggies, and the dogs are happy and pooping well again. I canceled my trial as soon as I noticed what was happening. I’m not sure why the dogs don’t like some of the food raw or cooked, but I’m definitely not buying it again. The food is so finely ground that it has a pasty consistency. They also provided a powder called a tasty digestive support mix-in, which, if left sitting too long, turns into a thick mush. You have to add water to loosen it up again. Some dogs lick their food, while others pick it up with their teeth. I have two lickers, and they can’t get any of it because it’s so sticky. I end up adding water to break it down so they can eat it, but 80% of the time, and throwing it away because they refuse to eat it. I waste more than they consume. My male dog has gone three days without touching this stuff, cooked or raw, so there must be something wrong with it. I spent a lot of money on this food, and after the trial period, it cost over $170 for 13.1 lbs. I’ll stick to buying fresh and grinding it into thicker or larger chunks, not an unidentifiable paste (probably organ meat, which is good for them anyway). At least then I’ll know what’s in their food. HEY! WE FEED RAW? If you want the rest back, send me a full refund, and I’ll gladly return what’s left. Update: 6/3/2026 - I did fail to mention that I did call to talk about the transition process and what was going on with customer service. When I asked for a refund, the lady told me to try another way to incorporate the food and use less then slowly build up the We Feed Raw food more each week till they built a tolerance to the digestion phase. By the time we tried different things that was recommended to us, the 30 days were over, and we didn't bother to call back. We just cooked it and fed it to the bigger dogs that will eat anything you put in front of them. Don't feel bad. They didn't like some of the other food companies out there that claim how great their food is. I just have really picky finicky dogs, and I have to make it. I was just trying to free up some of my time in this cooking process. Oh well, you're the 4th company I tried and it's failed.
Response from We Feed RawJun 3, 2026
Hi Larry, We’re sorry to hear this wasn’t the right fit for Poncho and your other dog. We understand how frustrating it is to spend money on food and feel like more is being wasted than eaten. Our food does have a soft, finely ground texture, which is intentional for this recipe style. We understand that texture can be a big factor for some dogs, especially dogs who prefer larger chunks or are more selective eaters..That texture works well for many dogs, but we understand it may not be the right fit for every pup, especially dogs who prefer larger chunks or are more selective with texture. We do offer a 30-day Happiness Guarantee for Starter Box customers. If a dog isn’t liking the food, we ask customers to reach out to our team within 30 days of placing the order so we can help with transition tips, protein adjustments, or other ways to make it right. Because we weren’t contacted before this review, we didn’t have the opportunity to help troubleshoot, offer transition guidance, or review options under our 30-day Happiness Guarantee. We’d still be happy to review this with you directly. Please reach out to us at [email protected]. We Feed Raw


