Sarah K.
Fish were good I did however loose one…
Fish were good I did however loose one week after I got the fish

The iFISH Store provides one of the widest selections of freshwater aquarium and pond fish available online today. We have been providing freshwater fish to aquarium and pond enthusiasts for over 20 years. Here's what you can expect from The iFISH Store: High Quality Fish / Low Pricing / Fast, Low Cost Shipping / Superior Customer ServiceFollowing quarantine, all shipments are sent via FedEx Overnight at a flat rate on all orders regardless of size. Interested in something you don't see in our store? Contact us at [email protected] or 516.524.6423 and just ask!
The iFISH Store (theifishstore.com) has 4,236 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 143 reviews with 3 stars · Clear filters
Sarah K.
Fish were good I did however loose one week after I got the fish
LEON N.
The fish is not all good quality, they mixed some good and some bad quality fish together.
Response from The iFISH StoreSep 8, 2021
Hello Leon; Thank you for your feedback. We’re sorry you’re not happy with all of your Koi. You received 2 Platinum Ogons and 3 Gold Ogons. Since we haven’t received any other communication from you that gives us more detail on which Koi you are unhappy with and why, we’d like to ask if you would submit photos of the Koi you are identifying as “bad quality” to us at [email protected] as a starting point to assess the situation. Also provide a bit of detail on the qualities of the Koi that you find undesirable. Then we can move forward from there. Thank you again for your feedback and we hope you reach out to us.
First time Fish T.
I ordered 13 Tiger barbs just earlier today, so far the experience has been great the prices, the selection, etc. I’m going to leave this at 3 stars and change it accordingly to the well being of the fish on arrival. Thank you for your amazing services so far!😁
Reggie
The Good: Great pricing on fish and delivery. Excellent packing job! The Bad: I ordered (9) 2 inch Discus fish and received 2 that were a tad larger then 2 inches but the rest were closer to 1.5 inches and a couple that are only 1 inch.(= false advertising on their site) One died a couple days after receiving them. One of the 1 inch Discus appears to be a runt. It has been 3 weeks and all the discus but this one have grown.
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 20, 2021
Hello Reggie; Thank you for your feedback. We list our juvenile Discus as ~2 inches and they can range in size from 1.5 - 2.0 inches measuring from tip of nose to end of tail. We're sorry to hear that one has perished and one still appears smaller in size after 3 weeks. We typically feed our Discus frozen bloodworms and keep tank pH and temperature very steady. Would you say that the smaller Discus and/or the one that perished are/were getting their fair share of food? There is always the possibility that one Discus is just smaller in size but we like to take a look at all other possibilities. We wish your experience was a better one, hope the rest of the Discus are doing well and appreciate you taking the time to provide this feedback.
Daniel M.
Fish did not do well well order alot of fish 90 dollars worth sent email 4 died in transit and 6 died later so it equals out to what you pay in fish store not a good deal for me but if they 80 % would of lived for a week instead of 50 % might be a better deal. Color was good and size accurate but not happy how fast half died
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 19, 2021
Hello Daniel; In looking back at our email communication, you had reported that 3 fish had perished in transit. We emailed you back asking if you would like a refund or a credit on a future order for them. However, we never heard back from you. And now we see in your review that in total, 10 of your 20 fish perished. We genuinely like to work with our customers when there are issues but we can only do that when we are notified. We're glad that you liked the coloring and size of the fish and really would have liked to work with you to get to the root of the problem with them perishing. Thank you for your feedback. We're sorry you did not have a better experience and hope that you will consider working with us again.
Brett V.
I am not too sure as I pick 3 star I will come back 3 months change to better star because I order babies those picture not same I guess babies not show color I wait 3 month might change color ....
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 16, 2021
Hello Brett; Thank you for your feedback! To your point, juveniles do not yet have their distinctive color and markings yet. We're confident that with proper feeding and tank parameters, you'll be happy with how they look as they reach adulthood. Appreciate your business and your input!
Jeremy K.
The fish were pretty! Good sized. There was a few that had issues. Three of the ten had Ick really bad. They were the Livingston and the Taiwanese reef cichlid and the eye-bitter had a couple.
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 10, 2021
Hello Jeremy; Thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear that 3 of your cichlids had ich. Ich is a rather insidious protozoan and is widely prevalent. It can go undetected until a fish undergoes stress. There are many causes of stress in a fish's life including water temperature, water quality, tank inhabitants, improper diet, and a variety of other factors all contribute to stress, but one of the most severe causes of stress occurs during shipping of fish. Even though we do a thorough visual examination of our fish upon arrival in our facility, treat their tanks, perform a quarantine and do a final inspection before shipping, ich has shown up on occasion once a customer receives their fish. We advise to treat them with Ich Be Gone which should clear up the problem. We're glad you liked the appearance of the cichlids and hope, with treatment, the ich will quickly clear up in the 3 that were affected. Should you continue to have an issue, please feel free to contact us at [email protected].
Scott
I'll give 2 stars because I got my fish in good shape and alive......but....... I had purchased, according to my invoice, non-albino strawberry peacocks and received albinos. You don't even have albinos listed on the website. Kinda disappointed to say the least. I usually get great fish from iFISH....don't know what happened...... Update..... Ok 3 stars instead of 2.......Faith in iFISH partially restored. The customer service was surprising and nice to see.....partial refund for my purchase of in store credit should I decide to order from them again......good move iFISH......
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 9, 2021
Hello Scott; Thank you for providing us with your feedback on your Strawberry Peacock Cichlids. And you are correct, we do not list Albinos on our site and don't order them from our supplier. However, on occasion , we have found that our shipment includes some Albinos mixed in with the Non-Albinos. We receive a large quantity of Strawberry Peacocks at once and do our best to separate them but apparently not thorough enough as is seen in your case. We apologize for the mistake and would like to extend a credit for $44.97 to cover the cost of the three 3 inch cichlids that you ordered. To use this credit, you simply need to mention that you would like to apply your $44.97 credit from Order No. 15939 in the Notes/Comments Section on your next order. We hope this rectifies the situation for you. We appreciate your business and hope to fulfill your aquarium needs again in the future.