Gabe “Fireball” W.
Good Overall Experience
My first order, almost a year ago, was for three pairs, two pairs of boots and one pair of shoes. The shoes I received were just the wrong size (received a size 8 instead of 11 lol). Had no issue with exchanging for the right shoe. Since then I've ordered several more pairs. Only quality miss was on a super discounted pair of 365's as they were close to their cycle end, and it was just a piece on the tongue that held the shoestrings down was coming undone, nothing too serious. Haven't had much issue with customer service, deliveries have been a bit slow recently but nothing crazy. The biggest miss across the board is the insoles the shoes come with. Obviously I'm not expecting supreme comfort but what they have standard is absolute garbage. Even worse when they decide to glue them down inside. Replacing them helps comfort out a lot, as with any shoe, but it feels like I'm forced to change the insoles. I notice among other reviews that sizing seems to be hit or miss. I haven't personally experienced any sizing problems outside of being sent the wrong shoe size, but even then it was just the box size listing not matching the shoes sent. Maybe it's more of a problem with smaller feet, as everything I've ordered at 10.5-11 US has fit pretty well and accurate. Overall very solid designs and experience. Quality hasn't changed after a year. Hope I don't have to come back and change the review because I do really like Taft and their designs. Look forward to more designs in the future!
Response from TAFTAug 13, 2025
Thank you so much for taking the time to share such detailed feedback! We’re thrilled to hear that overall you’ve enjoyed your Taft shoes and designs over the past year. We appreciate your honesty about the insoles and sizing. Your insights help us continue to improve both comfort and consistency for all customers. We’re glad our team was able to make your initial exchange smooth and that your subsequent orders have generally met expectations. We look forward to bringing you more designs in the future and hope every pair continues to meet your standards!


