David R.
Worst online purchase ever and I make…d
Worst online purchase ever and I make tons of them. First of all. In my opinion 123Ponds is NOT a stand alone business. It is a brokerage type of business ( like Ali Express and Temu) that actually stocks NONE of products seen on line. When an order is placed 123Ponds goes to an outside source that actually carries the product ordered by a customer. I don’t know how many of these sources 123Ponds brokers for but I imagine the number is considerable. In my case I purchased a near $700 pond pump, We have a 10,000 gallon koi pond with a waterfall that requires a lot of water flow. Our pomp failed and we needed to replace it ASAP. I searched the internet and found a CalPump with a flow of 8000 gal per hour on the 123Ponds website. I ordered one on August 17th. On the 18th I decided to try to fix the broken pump we were replacing. I found that water had gotten inside the pump shell and shorted out the unit.I resolved that issue, waterproofed the shell and fixed the problem. Early in the morning on Aug 19 I sent an email cancelling the orderi had placed for a replacement pump. No response. Later that day I received a notification that the order had shipped and was given a UPS tracking#, When I I checked the tracking #, it stated that a shipping label had been created but UPS had NOT received the package. This is a typical scam when a vendor wants a customer to think that it was too late to cancel an order. In fact, the order was not picked up by UPS until August 20th.i contacted 123Ponds again and received an email telling me that they had received the cancellation request AFTER the order had been packaged and shipped… a total lie. I responded telling them that I would refuse delivery and open a disputed transaction case with my credit card provider. They responded to THAT telling me that I would be responsible for the shipping charges (both ways) and also a 25% restocking fee. Bottom line, I decided to keep the pump as backup. And, oh yeah, the pump had been shipped by a company named “Franklin Electric” located in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 123Ponds is located in Sarasota, Florida. My suggestion is for anyone seeking any items pond related, stay as far away as possible from this supplier. It is nothing but a broker carrying NO inventory of its own…in my opinion. , “ . . .
Response from Store 123pondsAug 26, 2026
David, this review omits important facts and contains several false accusations. You placed the order on August 17 at 5:49 p.m. because you believed you urgently needed a replacement pump. After placing the order, you decided to attempt repairing your existing pump. Your cancellation request was received on August 18 at 4:50 p.m., nearly 23 hours after the order was placed, after our posted office hours and after the order had already entered fulfillment. A carrier’s first physical scan does not determine when an order was processed or whether it could still be canceled. Franklin Electric is the manufacturer of the pump. When our available stock is depleted, the manufacturer may fulfill an order directly on our behalf. This is a normal fulfillment practice and is clearly disclosed on our website. One order shipping directly from a manufacturer does not mean that 123Ponds carries no inventory. That claim is false. You also omitted that we voluntarily reduced the applicable restocking fee from 25% to 10% as an accommodation. You ultimately chose to keep the new pump as a backup. We welcome honest feedback, but describing normal, disclosed manufacturer fulfillment as a “scam,” calling our documented explanation a “total lie,” and claiming that our company stocks no inventory are not accurate representations of this transaction or our business.


