Millions of knives have been sharpened by our family of brands across the globe since 1965! We are an easy, secure, and fun online service, making your knives sharper than the day you first got them! Try us out and see how we are making the world a sharper place, one blade at a time.
Sharpenters (sharpenters.com) has 136 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Also known as
sharpenters.com
Website
sharpenters.com
Category
Production Services
Location
Naples, Florida
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 57% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: March 2025.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
DO NOT TRUST this company with your knives. They lost 4!! chef’s knives of mine, blamed the post office, told me I deserve (sic) to be reimbursed for my loss and completely disappeared!!!! This has been going on for almost 2 month!! Bunch of irresponsible losers. And not the cheapest around the block either.
PS. It’s end of August. My knives missing for 3 months now. And Post Office officially denied Sharpers claim. And company refuses to reimburse me for the lost/stolen items?!? HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE?!?
RG
RGH
They pay the postage and claim the knives' are insured...they refused to cover the in-transit loss of a cleaver.
I recently engaged the services of Sharpenters, an online knife sharpening service based in Naples, Florida. I purchased a one-time promotional offer for sharpening seven knives every six months at a standard rate of $76.93, with an initial promotional rate of $57.70. According to the representations made on their website, Sharpenters provides all necessary packaging, postage, and insurance to and from their facility. I tendered the package to the post office and received a tracking receipt as evidence of shipment. However, several days after my shipment, on May 27, 2023, I received electronic correspondence from Sharpenters indicating that the package had arrived damaged, containing only six knives instead of the expected seven. Sharpenters said they would initiate a claim with the post office on my behalf. After waiting patiently until the latter part of June, I inquired about the status of my claim. I was informed that the Post Office denied it, and Sharpenters did not provide supporting evidence of the denial. I then emailed and asked about the guarantee on their website that all packages were insured during shipment. I received no response.
Furthermore, despite receiving only six knives, Sharpenters charged me for sharpening seven knives. The replacement cost of the lost knife was approximately $68 on Amazon. Despite paying for postage and insurance to and from their facility, Sharpenters refused to reimburse me for my loss. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this service due to the company’s lack of integrity and poor communication.
sharpenters.com
AJ
A.J. C.
Do Not Use This Company !
I tried there service and the 5 knives came back "sharpened" but not very good and lasted for maybe 10 days. Without my knowledge they billed be for a second sharpening at a much higher price, which I disputed. They never answered me and I had to refute the charge on my credit card as we did not order or send our knives a 2nd time. They say I didn't read or understand their terms of service, which I did not agree to. This company is a sham and I would not recommend their quality of service or their business ethics. Shame on me for not checking these reviews before. Shame on you if you use this disreputable company.
HH
Hendrik H.
Not a professional knife sharpening service!!!!
Complete garbage. They are not knife smiths but an industrial grinding operation. They use belt grinders to put on an unpolished, rough edge that might last a week. If you send them a knife 3 times they will have removed so much material that your 8 inch chef's knife will be a paring knife.
HP
Heather P.
Awful customer service
I could give them a negative star I would. I have had a terrible experience from the start and I was told I put the address in wrong. Their system doesnt allow you to send these as gifts basically. I have ordered 3 packages since May and 2 of my sets went to the wrong address. Luckily one was local and I fixed it... But one set of knives I sent from Bonita, FL was delivered to someone I sent a gift to (in Massachusetts) a few months back and they thought this was a second part of their gift! SHARPENTERS doesn't care to rectify the situation... And continues to blame me. Even though the address affiliated with my order is a Florida address not Massachusetts. Their system doesn't work that way, but they aren't accepting any responsibility. I asked about their 100% customer satisfaction guarantee on their website and they said, it's doesn't cover this situation. So, it's actually a LIMITED satisfaction guarantee. All I asked was for a refund, because now I have to guy buy 5 new knives for my friend this gift was for.
I asked multiple times for a phone number to call or for someone to call me. They refused and will only email. That's nice though, bc my CC company has proof for their refund.
In response!!!
I won't accept the "free" postage as my mother has already used the knives and thinks they were a gift. I have stated this to you multiple times. I am not about to tell her they aren't, she says she loves them. All I asked for was a refund. As I have already had to purchase new knives for my boyfriend. Your company has plenty of crap reviews about your customer service and you are proving it as we continue this. All you had to do was refund $79 and you would have had a customer for life. Sad that you were willing to lose a customer over that minus the postage, what $50? I already had 3 subscriptions with you this year, now cancelled.
Response from SharpentersSep 9, 2022
Dear Heather,
We are very sorry that your experience was not reflective of the high standards that our customers are accustomed to. Having spent considerable time communicating with you about this topic privately before this public post, I am fully aware of your frustration and our offer to provide you with free postage is still available should you change your mind and choose to accept it.
As we discussed in our conversations, when you requested to change your address-of-record, all future shipping labels were printed to reflect that new address (even if the shipping label on the package you send in is different from the new address...as was the case for your Florida package). We designed this system to give our customers flexibility to send packages to other addresses because many of our customers do order our service as a gift to others, and many of our customers travel between multiple addresses and benefit from this flexibility. Because we never received a request from you to change your address back to the old address, we had no authorization to do so and therefore, the package that you wanted to go to Florida went to Massachusetts (the last address you requested us to change your address of record to). You'll recall that immediately after you contacted us, we responded by updating your address to the Florida one and with the solution to send extra postage to your contact in Massachusetts so that they could send the package back to you free of charge. Our satisfaction guarantee is indeed applied to the sharpening service, however, we want the overall experience to be excellent for our customers and so we do apologize that you were not fully satisfied with your experience.
Again, we would appreciate the opportunity to fix this for you and send you free postage to have your package sent from your contact in Massachusetts to Florida if you change your mind and choose to accept this. Thank you for sharing your experience and for allowing us an opportunity to serve you.
-Sharpenters
In Response to your latest edit (9.13.2022):
Again Heather, we are very sorry that your experience was not reflective of the standards that we have and the history of our customers' experience. We understand your frustration and sympathize with your unique situation. As is evident from the fact that we have so few negative customer service reviews, I hope that you will understand that we strive to provide our customers with every possible solution to meet their needs.
Sincerely,
Sharpenters