Score Jewelry - Modern Design Sports Themed Jewelry for Ladies and Men, Tungsten Sports Rings, Football Ring, Hockey Ring, Baseball Ring, Basketball Ring, Soccer Ring Jewelry, Modern Jewelry Gift Ideas
Score Jewelry (scorejewelry.com) has 101 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.5 out of 5.
Also known as
scorejewelry.com
Website
scorejewelry.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company has not replied to any reviews yet.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Buyer BEWARE!
This place is a joke and complete scam! Don’t be fooled by all the false positives on Trustpilot.. once you look you’ll see they’re all false positives. They get posted on the same day frequently, and the pattern is very evident!
I ordered with this scam early October for a Xmas present for my boyfriend. It wasn’t long before I realized I was never getting the ring. I got a confirmation email and that was it. Despite MANY contact attempts via their email, their web form and even their Etsy shop, shock… score jewelry (Jonathan) still never responded. It’s a joke. DO NOT BUY unless you want to give your hard earned money away. Hope this website gets shut down soon!
NS
Neil S.
Same Sad Story - This place is a Scam
Same sad story as a lot of other reviewers.
Score jewelry was quick to take my money (in USD... Strange for a Canadian company, hmm) and then I was completely ghosted. It seems that a lot of people had the curtesy of receiving courtesy lies from Score Jewelry whereas, I received nothing from them at all. I contacted them via email, over their website, over Etsy, and even called the number on my banking information... I never got a reply (or my money back).
It does seem to be a scam company. Either that or they are remarkably incompetent and only bother filling out some of their orders.
10 out of 10 would not recommend. Score Jewelry seems to be hoping that most people won't bother to push to get their money back or call a lawyer over such a, "small" amount of money. I wonder how much money that would add up if we all managed to get organized?
TW
Tammy W.
I wouldn't even give a 1 if had a…
I wouldn't even give a 1 if had a choice. Order matching Damascus steel rings on Aug. 10,2021. received 1 email with Invoice number and order# and that is it. I have sent 3 emails to them with no response and no number to call.
AP
Amy P.
Score Jewelry is a Scam
I placed an order for a pair of rings with custom engravings back on January 17, 2021. I was aware there would be a 2-3 week processing time. By mid February, I emailed Score Jewelry to inquire about order status. The response was my order would be ready in 4 days, and I would receive tracking information when the rings were shipped. That was essentially the last official communication I received from Score Jewelry.
Between March through September, I tried contacting the company about 8 times via email, FB messaging and Etsy messages, the company never provided me any tracking info or order status. Most of the time my emails/messages were ignored, and a couple of times they responded with promises of getting back to me with info, but those promises were not followed through. I was able to find a company phone number via my bank statement and they never answer my calls.
Since Score Jewelry essentially ghosted me, I submitted a chargeback request through my bank. The bank claimed they were not able to recover the funds because 1) It was an authorized transaction (i.e. I did make the purchase); 2) Score Jewelry rebutted that my order was shipped and delivered. When I requested the tracking info my bank received from Score Jewelry, it took the bank almost 3 months to get me that info - My case was closed in June, and the bank finally sent the info I requested in September.
I did my own research with the info provided by my bank, including the tracking information given to the bank by Score Jewelry. The tracking shows a USPS package shipped from LOMPOC, CA 93436 to an address in the same zip code. I live in Texas, and I have a TX shipping address on the order. And the package was not shipped via Canadian Post as one would expect from a Canadian company. Even when I contacted Score Jewelry with this info, I was still promptly ignored. To this date (October 2021), I still have not received the rings I ordered nor a refund.
And yes, I have all records of communications, receipts and reports to proof my case.
Canadian consumer protection bureau won't do anything with my complaint and won't do anything to Score Jewelry because the disputed dollar amount is too small, and that's how Score Jewelry gets away with it.
As far as I'm concerned, Score Jewelry is a scammer company. I don't know how Score Jewelry gets such high ratings. If you look them up on Better Business Bureau, you will see their "F" rating and samples of complaints against them. I wish I had seen the BBB report before making my purchase, instead of simply believing in Trustpilot, because obviously Score Jewelry does not deserve the 4-plus star rating.
EDIT: Upon reading a few recent reviews posted here on Turstpilot, and found at least two sets of identical reviews posted by different people, I have reasons to believe a lot of the positive reviews here are fake.
CB
Craig B.
This company is a total scam
This company is a total scam, I have been waiting for over 15 weeks at this point and have contacted them many times with no communication back at all. I would avoid buying from them and buy from a reputable company.
MR
Marissa R.
These guys are super amazing!!!!!
These guys are super amazing!!!!!! I absolutely love my engraved silver tungsten ring set I bought. And as it turned out my ring was a little too small but they were more than helpful and sent me a new ring with the right size. They even put a rush order on making the new one so that it got to me in time for my wedding. Thank you guys so much for being so helpful and for making me the perfect rings for my husband and I. I will and absolutely do recommend these guys too everyone. And I will definitely be ordering from them again soon.
BS
Bunn S.
what a great looking ring Iam looking…
what a great looking ring Iam looking to get one more great service
CS
Charlotte S.
Doesn't even desserve any sort of…
Doesn't even desserve any sort of rating absolutely discusted by this company ordered out matching wedding rings 8 weeks ago and received nothing been in contact loads even via etsy and they just tell you to email which we have done several times and had no response what so ever tried via Facebook and still nothing how sad and frustrating for anyone getting married and putting trust into a company for personal and different rings I advise everyone to stay clear of this website!!!