Grant B.
Great experience!
Great experience. I received more than double the amount on a few gold items that a local jeweler offered me. I was paid $1023 and am very happy. I definitely recommend ReDollar!

Transparent & Beneficial Like A Bank | You can sell jewelry, gold, silver, platinum, palladium, coins, bars, diamonds, gemstones, luxury watches, art, antiques, and other valuables online. With reliable business morals, transparency and best possible deals we pay the highest prices for your assets! All while we treat you with the most respect and consideration.
reDollar (redollar.com) has 494 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Huntington, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · Brooklyn, New York
Excellent
494 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Grant B.
Great experience. I received more than double the amount on a few gold items that a local jeweler offered me. I was paid $1023 and am very happy. I definitely recommend ReDollar!
A happy C.
I was nervous sending gold and silver through the mail, so I didn’t send much the first time to check it out. Everything was really easy and got paid instantly. Since then I’ve sent in stuff pretty regularly, usually around $1000 but up to $2500. I started using the ACH deposit instead of a check and it’s always in my bank account the next day. I don’t send gold or silver anywhere else now, no one is as easy and pays as well. Very happy with their service!
Tyler M.
They are legit! My mom was all sketched out about sending her old wedding band and gold bracelet to an online company. Turns out this company paid more than any of the local shops by far. I sent the gold in on Wednesday and they zelled me $1700 on Friday. Sweet deal!
Kim V.
I haven't ever sold jewelry online, but had to sell a gorgeous diamond ring I inherited. No idea what it was worth, so was happy to find redollar and asked for the free mail-in appraisal kit they advertise online. Instead of sending I was surprised to get a reply from Susan Parker asking me for details about the stones and my price expectations for the ring. Replied that I had no idea what grade the stones are, or what it was worth ... but isn't appraisals what you do at redollar? She replied: "send more photos. based on your photos we will give you an estimate" so I did, even sent a quick video of the ring. Next reply, I get asked for my price expectations again ??!! and knowing diamond value varies greatly so confused not to receive the help with an appraisals as promised ... I did some quick research and sent an uneducated guess using an average of 3 comparable looking rings that I found online, Instead of sending the kit and giving an appraisal as promised, I was told and they could not meet my price expectations and as such would not be "distancing themselves" from the purchase of the ring. Very disappointed to receive no help with the appraisal, which is advertised on their site. It's false advertising.
Response from reDollarJan 14, 2025
If we are unable to meet or come close to meeting our customers' price expectations, we believe it is in the best interest of both parties to avoid unnecessary shipping costs and time incurred by accepting a piece of jewelry. Yes, we offer appraisals; however, if we cannot meet someone's price expectations due to differing price perceptions between buyer and seller, there is no point in accepting an item when there is no basis for a successful sales transaction.
Ronnie B.
Warning...DO NOT send them any melted metal and/or agree to a melt test. If their XRF machine can't determine as they claim, request your metal back and find another avenue to sell. Don't settle.. Once your metal is altered by them, they will claim half purity and take you for half it's value. Gold and silver does Not disappear when melted. At that point, it's your word against theirs. What I sent them was 100% verified, so I agreed to melt test. They got me for over $500. They are not the only one's who know metals. Recommended by a Police detective?? LOL, like the one's caught on video in a corrupt act? I FAAFO, but you do you. Edit: They will investigate themselves, find no wrongdoing and reply to this review defensively. Edit #2: High tech as using Aqua Regia solution and Sodium Metabisulfite? Yea, I know a little also. There is some science in it, but not what you're shoveling. Again folks, use at your own risk. A "melt test" is just a legal loophole to short you.
Response from reDollarDec 20, 2024
This is what happened: The customer sent melted material that was classified as VERY low-grade, potentially gold-filled material with little to no monetary value. Our laboratory sent the following message to the customer via email: “…shows indications of being gold-filled or VERY low-karat gold. Melting would be necessary. Only agree if you understand the risk of receiving a disappointing assay.” The customer responded, “Yes, I agree to the melt request.” Our lab reached out a second time, sending this message: "Please note that there is a very high risk that the items are gold-filled/plated (or have low gold content). Do you really want us to proceed with the melt test?” The customer responded: “Yes, I did agree.” Our lab then proceeded with the melt test and confirmed what was already assumed: the submitted melted materials contained only a small amount of pure gold, which led to the customer's disappointment. We did everything possible to make the customer aware of the risk of receiving a low gold assay. We strongly recommend that private individuals do not buy melted materials for resale. Only a high-tech lab has the means to accurately handle melted materials; private individuals will NOT be able to perform an accurate test. Very often, melted materials are made to deceive buyers, and it then falls on us to present the unpleasant truth that the material purchased has little to no monetary value. All our test results are 100% accurate, and we regret that the customer incurred a loss by buying and reselling merchandise of unknown value.
Madeleine
AMAZING! reDollar are highly efficient, highly professional, and pay the best prices. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
ROBB
From start to finish the communication was awesome. They did exactly what they said they would do and paid over triple what the local pawn shop offered me for my gold.
Happy C.
After checking out trustpilot reviews myself and starting out with a small order of silver as a test, I can now say I am SUPER impressed with this company. I have now sent some very large lots of platinum, sliver and gold and each time they have been completely transparent and they usually pay within 10% of spot price. No jeweler even comes close. One offer I had for a lot was $350 and they paid $1100. They will deduct for stones (obviously) but based on weights they are honest. They pay for insured shipping and give you a complete lab report before you agree and then pay you the same day you approve via Zelle. They will also have their experts answer questions about jewelry with diamonds and other items you have questions about before you submit. Just check out their web-site to 'ask an expert' a question. I love their business model, they are honest and fast and pay the most you will find for scrap or jewelry. Right now with the price of gold, selling your jewelry for scrap price is much more lucrative in some cases. You can deal with them in complete confidence. I have used them at least 6 times now.