Pie InsurancePie Insurance provides workers’ compensation insurance directly to small businesses. Small business owners can now get a workers' comp quote in 3 minutes — which means getting coverage really is as easy as pie.
Pie Insurance (pieinsurance.com) has 636 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingAdministration & Services
Excellent
Administration & Services · New York, New York
Excellent
Administration & Services · RIVERTON, Wyoming
Excellent
Administration & Services · Nashville
Excellent
636 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Ami M.
Best customer service! Never had such an easy time with an insurance provider. From the initial phone call until the problems were solved was under 10 minutes. Thank you!
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 24, 2022
Hi Ami, thanks so much for this five-star review, we're always happy to help!
Jon B.
Nacy Sexton is the best. She alerted me to need to get my audit info in pronto. I got in touch with my payroll company, they sent me the info, I sent it on to Nacy, and she took care of the rest. Outstanding service by Nacy Sexton. Give her a raise.
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 24, 2022
Hello Jon, thank you for this glowing five-star review, we'll be sure to pass your kind words on to Nacy!
Jim
Pie Insurance claim to have sold insurance to a Florida based company, who, they claim, failed to pay for the service, leaving them owing over $3000. Rather than pursue the Florida based company, they instead chose to harass a completely unconnected UK company that had a similar name. Despite having their error pointed out to them, they chose to continue the harassment by getting a debt recover company to do it! If you are thinking of using this company for cover just keep in mind how poor they are at the most simple of things. Why didn’t they get and verify the correct email address at the outset? Why do they continue to ignore the fact they’ve had this pointed out to them? Do they not have a phone book? Some stamps? If you do use them, it would seem you stand the risk of having your personal information shared with complete strangers who, I guess, just happen to have similar names. Do you really want your dirty laundry airing in public?
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 17, 2022
Hello Jim, we’re very sorry for this frustrating experience. We have informed the collections agency about the mistaken identity so you should not be receiving further communication from them. Please don’t hesitate to give us a call if you have any questions.
Elliott B.
Zack is thorough and fast. Great experience.
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 15, 2022
Hi Elliott, thank you for this five-star review, we'll be sure to share your kind words with Zack!
Leslie B W.
Rosario was so so patient with me today and was able to answer and assist.
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 15, 2022
Hi Leslie, we're so glad to hear you had a great customer care experience, we'll be sure to share your kind words with Rosario!
Artur N.
It was a great experience getting the wc coverage for our company. The agent was very helpful and understanding
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 15, 2022
Hello Artur, thank you for this five-star review, and welcome to the Pie family!
Clarence C.
The representative was very understanding of my concerns. I was shocked to see that I was being charged extra and I believed there was an error on the part if PIE or ADP. The representative allowed me to explain and provide accurate information regarding my payroll. I would up getting a credit back on the policy. I was very happy that I got this representative to work with.
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 15, 2022
Hello Clarence, we're happy to hear you got the assistance you needed, thanks for being a Pie customer!
Seny M.
My contact was Daniel Heinz. He made the process very smooth and easy to understand. If I had any questions, he answered them succinctly and it was done. Very helpful to me.
Response from Pie InsuranceAug 15, 2022
Hi Seny, we're so glad to hear Daniel provided such great customer care, we'll be sure to share your kind words with him!