With the Largest selection of tabletop games in the world, Noble Knight has a game for everyone! We carry board games, role-playing games, card games, miniature games, dice, supplies, and accessories for all games and gamers. Shop our website or visit our substantial castle-themed store and gaming hall in Fitchburg, WI, where we offer access to thousands of new and old games from around the globe. Gaming groups and events are hosted in our spacious Gaming Hall seven days a week!
Noble Knight Games (nobleknight.com) has 171 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Also known as
nobleknight.com
Website
nobleknight.com
Category
Gaming
Location
Fitchburg, Wisconsin
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 100% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I had purchased a used game that was misslabled and opened it at home to find out it was missing parts. Through email we were able to get the problem corrected and they mailed me the parts. What srarted as a frustrating experience turned out to be a pleasant one. Thank you Noble Knight. I look forward to my next visit. (Edit spelling)
Response from Noble Knight GamesMar 2, 2026
Thank you so much for sharing this!
We are really sorry the game was mislabeled and missing parts, that is definitely frustrating. We are glad our team was able to get everything sorted out and send the missing pieces your way. Turning a tough start into a positive experience is exactly what we aim for.
We truly appreciate your patience and your kind words, and we look forward to your next visit as well. Happy gaming!
KJ
Kirk John D.
Arrived broken, bad packaging. New Update
Ordered a mage knight with then but states near mint, package arrived but would just be in the box and plastics inside. So 2 of the piece arrived broken after waiting for weeks before they arrived.
Expected to receive a Near Mint Condition but arrived broken.
They should have atleast secured the pieces in the packaging but everything is just scrambles all together in the box of course it will not went well and it will broke upon shipping.
Totally not satisfied on this order.
Update: seller sends out replacement. Cant give 5 stars as something went wrong the first order but hoping this review will help them have good packaging next time. Replacement arrived fine.
Thank you for fast action.
Response from Noble Knight GamesFeb 5, 2026
We are very sorry for how your Mage Knight order arrived and for the frustration this caused after such a long wait. Receiving a Near Mint item with broken pieces due to inadequate packaging is absolutely not acceptable, and we understand why this left you so dissatisfied.
Our team will be reaching out to you this morning to make this right and work toward a resolution. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and truly regret that this order did not reflect the care we aim to put into every shipment.
MO
Matt O.
Inaccurate Product Listings
EDIT: I wish to amend my previous review, due to the extraordinary measures that Noble Knight Games has taken to address my concerns. My most pressing concern was not the payment for an item with missing parts; it was that the transaction left me feeling that I could not rely on the item descriptions for used products. Not only did Noble Knight Games act swiftly to correct the erroneous item descriptions, they also reached out to let me know that they had updated the descriptions; but, more importantly, they also informed that they had implemented some new procedures to help ensure that these kinds of description errors will occur less frequently in the future. Many thanks and much appreciation for Scott, the Customer Service Manager; he really took the time to understand why the accuracy of the used items descriptions was so important to me, and went above and beyond to keep me informed of the steps they had taken to correct the underlying issues. Thanks, Noble Knight Games!
I purchased a copy of Star Fleet Battles Module X1 The X-Ships that was represented as a used but otherwise complete copy in VG+ condition. The slipcover clearly states that the product comes with a 64-page rule book, a 96-page book of ship systems displays (SSD), and 108 cardboard counters. The copy arrived without the 96-page SSD book; and, Noble Knight Games did not, initially, act to correct their error. The only option they left me was to purchase the only remaining copy, which was advertised as having no slipcover, but being in otherwise complete condition. They did, however, physically inspect the second copy to insure that all the other parts were included, after I requested it.
In the process of trying to figure out how to somehow make myself whole without direct intervention from Customer Support, I put them onto to another item that was not as described in the product description text. They also physically inspected that product, and confirmed it was not what was listed, only one part from the described item.
More than 30 days later, the erroneous description is still displayed. Not only did they do absolutely nothing to correct their mistake, I had to email back and forth with their Customer Support for 10 days, before ultimately deciding it was better to just buy the other listed copy than get into trying to do a return on a fairly inexpensive item.
Response from Noble Knight GamesMay 1, 2025
Hey Matt,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We're truly sorry to hear about the issues with your order and the frustration caused by how it was handled.
At Noble Knight Games, we strive to ensure all our product listings are accurate and that our customers feel supported and valued. It’s clear we fell short in this case, and we sincerely apologize for that. Your concerns are valid, and we want to make this right.
Our Customer Service Manager will be personally reaching out to you shortly to address this matter directly and work toward a resolution. We appreciate your feedback as it helps us improve our processes and better serve our customers in the future.
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to make this right.
MI
Mike
Description is not full.
Not always an actual description. The game state was shown as VG+/EX, with the comment about the sticker on the box, but also one of the miniatures was broken.
For another two games all ok, as described.
Response from Noble Knight GamesJul 25, 2024
Thank you for your feedback, Mike. We apologize for the oversight with the broken miniature. We're glad to hear the other two games met your expectations. Please reach out to us directly so we can make this right.