New Yorker BagelsReviews of newyorkerbagels.com

Pretty disappointing. Too airy for my liking. They squish down when you put the cream cheese on. Just like super market bagged bagels for twice the price.

Ordering was very easy. The website is simple to navigate, checkout was smooth, and the cost for a dozen bagels with 2-day shipping felt reasonable, especially after applying the $5 introductory coupon. The bagels arrived exactly as promised within two days. I immediately taste-tested one and froze the rest as recommended for freshness. As for the bagels themselves, they weren’t bad, but they weren’t great either. In fact, they were about the same quality as what I can get locally. Because of that, I don’t think they’re worth the premium cost once shipping is factored in. Overall, the ordering and delivery experience was solid. The product quality just didn’t justify paying extra over what’s already available nearby.