Custom stuffed animals of your pets! Petsies makes custom pet keepsakes for any pet, including Custom Plushies, Pillows, Blankets, Figurines, Pajamas, and more!
Petsies (mypetsies.com) has 290 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
Also known as
mypetsies.com
Website
mypetsies.com
Category
Children's Entertainment
Location
Boynton Beach, Florida
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 67% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
For the amount I paid, I honestly expected a thicker blanket. It was a memento gift for someone and it looked cheaper than what I knew was the cost. The photo picture wasn't as defined as I hoped, so I was disappointed in this purchase.
Petsies reply still disappoints. I did not order the cheapest possible blanket, but a medium size one. For the price I paid, it should have been more substantial. I doubt the recipient realizes this.
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Hi Judy!
We're sorry to hear that you weren't totally pleased with your blanket. We do offer multiple options for material/thickness levels at varying costs and see that you had chosen Arctic Pro Fleece, which is the base option. As for the picture, we do apologize that it was not as clear as you had hoped. It is possible the file was not large enough for the blanket size chosen, and had to be stretched a bit.
Nonetheless, we hope that you and the person you gifted the blanket to were still satisfied with it, and we do appreciate the review!
-The Petsies Team
NB
Nancy B.
Rarely am I speechless, but Petsies made it happen.
Had no idea this was being made for me. As soon as I opened the box and saw the crossed paws, I knew immediately what it was and could not speak from shear surprise and joy. Have missed my dog for 5 years and still think of him every day. Now my heart jumps every time I see him. Incredible details and spot on likeness! Thank you for my baby.
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Nancy,
I am absolutely honored to hear that we were able to help you feel connected with your dog again. Pet loss is never easy, and while time may pass, we always miss our best furry friend. I hope that your Petsie helps you remember all your favorite memories that you shared together. Although they may be gone, the bond and love you both shared will never go away. Thank you for such kind words!
JS
Jennifer S.
This is the 3rd one I've had done by…
This is the 3rd one I've had done by Petsies & each one has been so realistic that people think they are real! I highly recommend Petsies!
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Jennifer, we're honored that you have chosen Petsies not once, not twice, but three times! We appreciate the kind words!
CO
Conner
Good on the pattern, dull colour choices, fat chunky sausage body
The body is one big sausage there's no differentiation from the head to body. There's no neck. The colours are all wrong it's so dull and grey. The photos of my cat show that he's a lot more saturated golden and brown, this looks so grey and lifeless. The quality of the fur is literally falling off of it as I touch it. I understand it's a doll and not a replica, but it's not even close to resembling my cat. It's so uncanny and scary. The pattern is accurate it's just the colouring, the shape, and the quality.
Response from PetsiesApr 14, 2025
Hi, Conner!
We're so sorry that you aren't 100% satisfied with your Petsie. We see that you have been in contact with our team and hope we can resolve the issue. Please continue to reach out there with any other questions or concerns so we can better assist!
BT
Beverly Tobar R.
Please help me !!!!
I don't want to give a bad review, but it has been 14 weeks and they have already got their money and i have not received my petsies.... they keep telling me that its taking longer than usual because of the volume ? but i see here on the reviews, that people have ordered after me and have already got their petsies !!! I lost my Bebo this year and iam so heartbroken.... please can somebody help me ? I have reached out to Petsies i left Emails & voicemails and all they tell me that its in production. PLEASE
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Hi, Beverly!
I checked in with our team and they do not see that they have received any contact from you. Additionally, we do not see any orders placed under your name. PLease reach out to [email protected] with your order number, and we'll be happy to help!
JM
James M.
Difficult experience, but they tried. Very high quality.
This is a difficult experience to rate. We ordered a stuffed animal replica of our cat who passed on, but since our cat was a basic black cat without much in the way of distinguishing features, I was worried we would get a "generic black cat" plush. I sent pictures and explained her unique features, and...I got a generic black cat plush. It looked very little like my cat. I got in touch with customer service who offered to remake it, there was a bit of confusion about what I wanted (they felt the problem was I thought it was too big, but that was a secondary issue) but they agreed to remake it in a smaller size for no additional cost. The remake took a very long time, but they did offer to let me keep the first attempt (I chose to send it back to them). When we got the second attempt, it was much better. Not perfect, but they clearly made an attempt, and it definitely captures her "essence" more than the first one.
I will say this stuffed animal (both the original and the remake) are *extremely* high quality. The fur feels realistic, it looks amazing, and several times I've looked at it and thought my cat was back and sitting on her couch. Our other cat has even been fooled by it. They're not cheap, but they are an amazing product and definitely a fitting memorial to our cat.
I kept flipping between 3 and 4, but the main reason I settled on 3 is because they are in the business of dealing with people who have lost pets, people who cared enough about their pets to want something to remember them by. Quite simply, their first attempt was extremely upsetting, I wanted something that looked like my cat and it was *not* my cat. They fixed their mistake and I may be being a bit too judgmental, the loss was still very new. And quite honestly, while I admit I was partly at fault because I was very upset, their customer service was not very friendly or understanding.
I'd still recommend their product, especially if your pet has distinctive markings or something they can more easily replicate. Just be ready if things don't end up the way you expect.
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Hi, James!
First off, we're sorry the production and perfection of the Petsie took so long, but we're very glad that you were pleased with it in the end! We know that it can take a bit of time, especially when there's a remake involved, as these are custom products. But this is to try to capture every detail and replicate each pet's likeness as much as possible!
With that being said, we really are glad you were happy with it in the end. We really appreciate the kind words about the quality of your Petsie, and we're honored that we were able to help you feel a bit more connected with your cat again.
WH
William H.
Very well done
Very well done. The likeness is almost spot on. Thank you
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Thanks for the review, William! We really appreciate it
BL
Brekka L.
Thank you for a great experience!
Our stuffed animal is so realistic that the other dog is doing play bows to it. It resembles our sweet deceased Luna very well and is a tremendous comfort to my son. We especially appreciated the opportunity to sign up for a sneak peak before receiving our special plushie. Thank you!
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Hi, Brekka!
We're delighted to hear that your Petsie was able to bring comfort to you, your family, and even your dog! We also appreciate the kind words about the Sneak Peek option. We want to make sure that each customer is satisfied with every detail of their Petsie, and Sneak Peeks really help us in ensuring that! Thank you for the review!