My Green Mattress Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of mygreenmattress.com

My Green MattressReviews of mygreenmattress.com

4.7742 reviews
Furniture Stores
1519 W. 55th Street, La Grange Highlands, Illinois

Call Directions Website

My Green Mattress

About My Green Mattress

My Green Mattress was founded by Tim Masters. Tim is an experienced businessman, master craftsman, and devoted family man. Tim's daughter, Emily, inspired him to expand his offerings to include all natural mattresses. Shortly after Emily was born, it was apparent that she suffered from eczema and allergies. Tim and his wife, Cindy, took Emily to see the best pediatric dermatologists, but also did their own research and found that all-natural products could help alleviate Emily’s symptoms.Tim realized it was time to offer all-natural mattresses to his customers, and rushed to put one in his daughter’s crib. Emily is now sleeping on a twin-size, all-natural mattress handcrafted by her Dad. She is a happy, healthy little girl that loves to play with her three sisters, Rylee, Madelyn, Megan, and with her brother, Kyle.Tim began working as an apprentice at family-owned, Quality Sleep Shop, that was established in 1968. As an apprentice, Tim mastered the art of mattress making. He eventually bought the business, and has expanded it with the addition of the My Green Mattress division to keep up with the ever changing needs of his customers.

My Green Mattress (mygreenmattress.com) has 742 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.

Also known as: mygreenmattress.com
Website: mygreenmattress.com
Category: Furniture Stores
Location: La Grange Highlands, Illinois
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 9% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Furniture Stores, Illinois

My Green Mattress reviews

742 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Larissa S.
Jan 2, 2026
Just right
Firm enough for him. Soft enough for me. Love this bed.
Report
Victoria W.
Jan 2, 2026
Zero break-in period, comfort from the start!
Everything arrived quickly and the mattress is SO COMFORTABLE! We thought we may have to compromise on comfort to get a safe mattress for our family, but it was amazingly comfortable from the first night. Zero break-in period. We couldn't be happier!
Report
JC
Dec 3, 2025
Great Mattress
I ordered a king size and delivery went smoothly. I forgot to add removal service for old mattress but customer service set up an appointment right away. Very impressed. The mattress perfectly firm in my opinion.
Report
AmyDT
Dec 2, 2025
Disappointed. Wish I had chosen Avocado.
I did a lot of research comparing My Green Mattress with Avocado (I already own one Avocado) and ultimately landed on this one. The delivery and setup were fine, but the mattress is more firm than I had anticipated. I ended up having to add a mattress topper, which mostly negated the price difference. I had high hopes that this would be a more economical option while still offering high quality, but unfortunately it is not.
Report
Mia S.
Dec 2, 2025
Great mattresses, fair customer service.
Pros- the mattresses (we own two) are very comfortable, high quality, and most importantly healthy materials. Shipping was quick. An emailed question about a detail on our bill was quickly answered. Cons- I sent a chat and an email asking about the difference in firmness between different mattresses on the site- never got a response for either format. If I didn't already own one of the mattresses and trust the company, I wouldn't have purchased this time. Fortunately it worked out.
Report
N. M.
Dec 1, 2025
A win, win, win!
Awesome customer service, quick delivery and a comfy mattress that's a healthier option...overall, a great experience!
Report
Samantha W.
Nov 7, 2025
Great customer service
Great customer service. They reached out and double checked my address was correct (it wasn’t) and made sure it was delivered correctly. Bed is firm and comfortable. Will be ordering again for my kiddo!
Report
Patricia
Nov 2, 2025
Love it
Love it. I feel better knowing I am sleeping on a chemical free mattress and comfortable too!
Report