Mr. SteakReviews of mrsteak.com

4.768 reviews
Meat, Seafood & Eggs

Mr. Steak

About Mr. Steak

Mr. Steak delivers steak house quality meats right to your door & quality infrared grills that make those meats stand out.

Mr. Steak (mrsteak.com) has 68 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.

Also known as: mrsteak.com
Website: mrsteak.com
Category: Meat, Seafood & Eggs
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 82% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: January 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

Mr. Steak reviews

68 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Jeni B.
Dec 10, 2020
Family Stamp of Approval on the 24oz Porterhouse
We ordered (2) 24oz. porterhouse steaks on the Saturday before Thanksgiving 2020. On Wednesday afternoon they showed up at our doorstep perfectly packaged. We appreciated the eco-friendly materials used and the steaks were top notch and delicious on Thanksgiving day. Our 10-year-old son would love to eat them weekly but alas, they are not in our regular grocery budget. 😉 They are super for special occasion meals!
Response from Mr. SteakDec 16, 2020
Hey Jeni, Thanks so much for the review. We greatly appreciate it. It sounds like you had a wonderful Thanksgiving! We love porterhouses over here, and we think steak should be part of every Thanksgiving meal (move over Turkey). Christmas too! If you ever have any questions, please email me at [email protected]. Thanks, James
Donald B.
Dec 6, 2020
First time buyer
First time buyer. Had some of the prime filets. So far very good. Among the best steaks we’ve had. Looking forward to trying some more from Mr Steak.
Response from Mr. SteakDec 16, 2020
Hey Donald, Thanks so much for giving us a try. We're happy you're enjoying those filets! Nothing makes us happier than to get these incredible steaks into people's homes. Nothing beats a super tender prime filet. If you ever have any questions please email me at [email protected] Thanks, James
Natalie
Nov 24, 2020
I ordered the Super Starter Box and the…
I ordered the Super Starter Box and the steaks arrived cold (frozen) on my front door step. The Green Foam cooler did its job and the overall packaging was very nice - nothing damaged. Brisket Burgers were out of this world, as were the Ribeyes. I'll be ordering again!
Response from Mr. SteakDec 16, 2020
Hey Natalie, Thanks for the review! We LOVE those brisket burgers, and we're so happy to offer them because they're normally so hard to come by. When you get a chance, check out our Grill School blog posts about burgers for some epic pics of Mr. Steak brisket burgers we cooked. Thanks, James [email protected]
Chase C.
Nov 10, 2020
Grease Fires
Are you a fan of burnt meat? Really like when a grill flairs up uncontrollably? Then do I have the grill for you! Due to a poor design flaw in the heat deflectors, they act as a grease traps catching all that rendered fat resulting in an uncontrollable grease fire. Seared steaks? Nope. Chicken? Burnt. Pork chops? Abysmal. Save your money and buy a Weber.
Response from Mr. SteakNov 11, 2020
Hi Chase, thanks for reaching out and for sharing your experience. Our grills utilize a unique infrared technology that is used in fine steakhouses. It's tricky to master at first because it's so different from other grills most of our customers have used throughout their lives. That being said, the ultra high heat and very even grilling surface creates incredible meals, once you spend some time with the grill and have a chance to figure out its quirks. For one, it cooks so much faster than other grills that you only need a couple minutes on each side in some cases. If you try to grill on it as you would a lower heat grill it will burn, as you mention. I would love to connect you personally with Mr. Steak to walk you through how to best use the grill if you are up for it. You can email me directly at [email protected] to set up a call. I hope you'll give us a chance to turn your past negative experience into a positive one with your Mr. Steak grill! I feel confident that once we share some techniques unique to the Mr. Steak grill you'll be grilling epic meals in no time. All my best, Liz Mr. Steak
John O.
Oct 4, 2020
I first purchased the single burner…
I first purchased the single burner portable grill for my RV. After six months, I love it so much, I also purchased the duel burner portable for my patio. It takes a little if trial and error to get used to it because it cooks so hot. But that’s the beauty of it, as it sears in the juices and cooks so fast. Just monitor it and check every few minutes. Meat has never tasted so great. If there is anything negative to say about it at all, it is a little difficult to clean the grate. But if you purchase the wooden Mr. Steak cleaning handle, it molds right to the shape of the grate after one or two uses and eliminates that problem. We love these grills!!!
Response from Mr. SteakDec 16, 2020
Hey John, Thanks for the review! We love that you have two of our grills, and one for your RV. Mr. Steak takes his portable two burner with him for his summer vacation every year. There's nothing like steaks on the open road. And thanks for the feedback regarding cleaning the grate! Next time you grill, please take some pics or video, and email [email protected]. We'll post you on our social media! Thanks, James
Roger R.
Oct 1, 2020
Worth Trying
After a bit of a hiccup at the beginning of our ordering process which everything eventually worked out just fine. Customer service quickly rectified the technical glitch that occurred when placing our initial order. This initial order was a gift for someone and they did send a picture after they cooked the first T-bone steaks and it looked amazing they said the steaks were delicious the packaging was great so all in all a huge plus. The number one priority is customer service and Mr. steak went above and beyond to rectify the error, which we were very appreciative of. Quick delivery, great packaging, fair pricing, and terrific customer service- and for all these reasons they have earned our business moving forward.
Response from Mr. SteakDec 16, 2020
Hey Roger, Thanks for your review and feedback. We're sorry you had an issue with the ordering process, but glad that we were able to work it out. If you ever have another problem or suggestion, please send me a message at james@mrsteak, and I'll get right on it. We hope your friend enjoyed that T-bone, as it seems like they did. Mr. Steak loves his huge cuts. Porterhouse for Christmas? :) Thanks, James
Cameron
Oct 1, 2020
Cowboy steak, ribeyes, and burgers.
Cowboy steak and ribeyes look great! The burgers they gave me were very good and the shipping was fast. I've got nothing to complain about. Thanks guys!
Response from Mr. SteakDec 16, 2020
Hey Cameron, Great to hear you enjoyed those steaks! That cowboy steak is epic, right? The next time you grill one of our steaks, please take some pics or video, email [email protected] and we'll post you on our social. We love to see our customers eating right! Thanks, James
Jana T.
Sep 17, 2020
Order damaged
When I got my order, Fed Ex called as the package had broke open due to the ice melting. Once received, the steak packages were torn and the meat was exposed. I sent pictured. I repackaged them and re-froze them. The steaks are very good, but the delivery process was clearly flawed. Thank you,
Response from Mr. SteakSep 17, 2020
Hi Jana, Thanks for leaving this message and bringing this to our attention. FedEx had some delays due to fires and hurricanes recently and we sincerely apologize that it impacted your box. We didn’t realize that the packages were ripped due to this. That’s not acceptable and we want to make this right for you. What can we do to raise your review to 5 stars? Please email me directly at [email protected] and I will make sure you are taken care of. Thanks and so glad you felt the steaks were very good regardless! I look forward to helping you! Liz

Mr. SteakReviews of mrsteak.com

About Mr. Steak

About these reviews

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

Great Moose Woodcraft

OC Wild Seafood

Fresh Catch Fish Co.

Big Fork Brands

Mr. SteakReviews of mrsteak.com

Mr. Steak reviews

Family Stamp of Approval on the 24oz Porterhouse

First time buyer

I ordered the Super Starter Box and the…

Grease Fires

I first purchased the single burner…

Worth Trying

Cowboy steak, ribeyes, and burgers.

Order damaged

About Mr. Steak

About these reviews

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

Great Moose Woodcraft

OC Wild Seafood

Fresh Catch Fish Co.

Big Fork Brands

Mr. Steak reviews

Family Stamp of Approval on the 24oz Porterhouse

First time buyer

I ordered the Super Starter Box and the…

Grease Fires

I first purchased the single burner…

Worth Trying

Cowboy steak, ribeyes, and burgers.

Order damaged