Manly Bands is the fastest growing DTC men's wedding bands destination. We make wedding bands with only the most epic materials like meteorite, dino bone, deer antler, wood and more. Check out over 300 unique styles and designs.
Manly Bands (manlybands.com) has 371 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
Also known as
manlybands.com
Website
manlybands.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Location
Lindon, Utah
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 61% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Months in to an order, these folks have not delivered products ordered nor issued a refund. They blame shippers. Banks and everyone bit themselves. Numerous emails followed up with polite excuses with no results.
Response from Manly BandsMar 21, 2025
Hi Frank, I'm afraid we can't find your order in our system. Are you sure you ordered from Manly Bands and not some other company?
DJ
Dasha J.
Manly Bands Dropped the Ball!
Overall, my ordering process was not handled with care, which resulted in my ring coming more a week AFTER my wedding . I placed my order through Klarna, the third party processor on Jan 22 and received a confirmation email with my order number, so I thought everything was fine. After days of no notice regarding shipping timelines, I reached out to Manly Bands on Jan 31 to inquire about when my order would ship since my wedding was nearing on Feb 15. I was told my order can take 4-6 weeks to process due to the free engraving add-on, so I requested to expedite this, but was given no solution.
On Feb 4, I reached out again and began emailing with Holli who informed me that Manly Bands did not receive my payment the entire time! How was I supposed to know my order was on pause? I expressed how I wasn't made aware of this sooner to get it resolved. Time was cutting it even closer and I stressed that I would be getting married the following weekend and needed the ring before that. I asked Holli how can Manly Bands ensure I receive my band on time, but this was dismissed.
She ended up sending me a new invoice so I could pay this, and this placed my order (foreal this time smh). As you can imagine, the lack of quality control dragged the timeline out even further. That week passed, and the next week passed with no ring resulting in me not having a band to present my husband for our wedding day. I had to use someone else's instead. Manly Bands dropped the ball at a few points including:
1) Not having a quality control system that notified me they didn't receive payment sooner. This resulted in my order floating around and me having to reach out to see what the hold up is.
2) The original rep on Jan 31 not catching that payment wasn't received and brushing it off as extended timelines due to engraving, which was incorrect.
3) Lack of urgency and apologetics on Manly Bands and Holli's part after I wrote back in on Feb 4 to inquire further about to hold up, where I found out no payment was received. Manly Bands could have expedited me the ring: 1-day shipping, 2-day shipping, anything! But I didn't have a ring to present my fiance when I originally ordered on Jan 22.
I requested a partial refund for the anxiety and stress this caused right before my wedding, plus the lack of urgency with my entire order, which was granted. But this should have never happened in the first place. I ordered from Manly Bands after seeing such great reviews, but my experience was so difficult. I am in the wedding industry myself and I will not be recommending this company to my brides unfortunately.
Response from Manly BandsMar 5, 2025
Hi Dasha, I truly want to apologize that this was your situation before your big day! Looking more into your situation, I can see and confirm that the Klarna processing issue was an issue on Klarna's side of things and they should have reached out to you and sent an email saying that the original payment was not successful. Unfortunately since Klarna is a 3rd party company, we do not have any access or control on their side of things. But despite that issue on their end, I see that Holli jumped in immediately to help you out and get a resolution as soon as possible! Even though the processing issue was not an issue on our end, we totally understood the frustration you had to deal with because of that and we went above and beyond to get you taken care of (by helping to process your payment a different way and partial refund). In regards to the timeframe of 4-6 weeks for crafting, when you are on the product page and select the size you need, there will be a badge that pops on the page to tell you whether the ring is in stock or if it is made to order which takes 4-6 weeks. We do our very best to be as transparent about these timeframes but understand the information can be easily missed. We hope your wedding was still beautiful and to please reach out if there is anything more we can assist with!
JA
Jennifer A.
Terrible quality, bad return/exchange policy
We found a really cool ring zirconium with a whiskey barrel inlay, but the ring fell apart after 1.5 months of wearing it for 8 hours at an office job. Quality is terrible and this company’s return/replacement policy is very restrictive. They gave us “an exception” to exchange with another ring because we certainly didn’t want the same ring or another with an inlay. We spent $600 on the first ring and got a replacement worth $200. I would never recommend to a friend or use this company again.
Response from Manly BandsJan 28, 2026
Hi Jennifer, I can see that we got you taken care of with a new ring of same or more value than the original ring! If you are still needing any further assistance, please reach out and we would love to help :)
JE
Jesse
Fell Apart after 10 days
Fell Apart After 10 Days My wife bought me this ring, and at first I was really excited. I thought the whiskey barrel and meteorite was a neat combo. Unfortunately, after 10 days of wearing the ring, the wood is literally falling off the ring and in other parts, its pulling back. The edges are super sharp too. I didn't wear the ring to work or do anything extreme with my hands, never wore it in the shower or out in the rain. My wife contacted Manly Bands, and they basically just blamed me and said my hands are naturally oily and that's what caused the ring to fall apart, which honestly seems ridiculous. If a ring can't stand up to natural oils that your skin produces, I can't imagine it'll hold up to much else. We wanted a refund, but manly bands refused and only offered a store credit. I don't have much faith in the quality of their products after my experience with the Lynchburg. On top of that, it's really limiting to find a replacement on their website, I don't want to spend more on a new ring, and if I pick one that's cheaper, my wife will be losing out on the money she spent since they won't refund the difference. I left a review on their website last week, surprise surprise, it doesn't show up when you look at the reviews of the Lynchburg. So I'd imagine they're either cherry picking reviews and deleting the other ones, or the reviews on their website just aren't real. Steer clear of this company and don't trust the reviews on their site.
Response from Manly BandsFeb 12, 2025
Hi Jesse, I am so sorry to hear this and about your frustrating experience. I can see that you are currently working with one of our agents, I am going to work with them and have them reach back out to you to see how we can get this resolved :) Talk again soon!
DR
David R.
Don’t buy
Biggest scam, good are not like in pic, will not give money back.
Do not buy , scam !!!
Response from Manly BandsJan 28, 2026
Hi David, we are really sad to see this! We can assure you that we are not a scam. If there are any questions or concerns you may have about our rings or anything at all, please shoot us a quick email at [email protected] and we would love to help :)
ST
Stephen
Time sensitive, Terrible customer service, False Claims or inconsistency of warranty
I ordered a wedding band for myself recently, but realized that the address was incorrect, going to home instead of school. I followed their instructions, and emailed them but to my surprise, a crappy AI responded, and directed me to contact "customer support" but gave no way to do so, or to reply "agent" to speak with one. I tried agent, it didn't do anything. When I looked for that support, it didn't even exist on the website. They had only one email (the AI one), no phone number, and a chat feature. I then tried the chat feature, hoping to actually find a person. To my greater frustration, the same AI began talking. When it prompted me to talk to an agent again, asking yes or no, I said yes and it responded as if I had said no. Finally, after several minutes of me trying to get it to let me talk to a person, I told it I wanted to cancel the order. FINALLY it said I should talk to a person about this, and said it put me in the cue. After waiting quite awhile, no one responded. Go figure. At this point I am very angry, as I need a ring for my wedding that is coming up. As a former first responder (which they have discounts for), I am quite upset at this service.
Another issue: On the page where I bought the ring, it said that there were FREE returns, and a FREE WARRANTY. But then, when I went to the cart, I see a fee of $55 roughly added for the warranty and free returns.
Now, if you want to improve, get rid of that darn AI feature, or get a programmer who knows what they are doing. AND TEST IT YOURSELF so you can see if a customer is going to get frustrated by it. Also, STATE CLEARLY what you mean by your warranty, and explain why there is a cost for something that you CLAIM to be free. I do want to buy from y'all, but if you don't step it up, your customers are going to stop being customers because they can't talk to a person.
Response from Manly BandsJan 30, 2025
Hi Stephen, I am sorry to hear about your frustrating experience. And I am sorry to hear about your frustration with our AI bot - we have that bot to help our small team with inquiries, it helps us handle the smaller/easier items and then the more complicated ones can come to us! And of course, if you ever do just want to talk with a team member, all you have to say is 'agent' and it will pass you right on over to one of our agents for further assistance!
We do offer *free returns and lifetime warranty, with some exceptions. You can find additional information about these policies and others on our website help center.
In regards to the extra $55 service you are talking about, that is the Redo Order Protection that you can read more about in our help section. That is an optional service that you can take off before you place your order and even after you place your order, before it ships out!
Please let us know if we can assist with anything else :)
AD
Aynsley D.
Terrible experience
Terrible experience, cannot recommend.
We ordered a ring nearly seven weeks ago and finally received it today. The site suggested sizing down for a comfort fit and we did.. and it's too small. So we tried to follow up with them based on their policy that they will provide a free trade in if your ring size isn't right.. but that's BS. They were happy to sell us the ring, take nearly two months to deliver it and then they put the ring on clearance and don't have any more on stock. The only options provided were that we would need to trade it in for a different ring or pay a fee to send it back as a return.. so now we're trying to return the ring and the website is redirecting us to exchange it whenever we get to the final step of the return process. This is a mess.
We're ordering from someone else. Contacting customer service was a joke as well. NEVER order your ring from this company if you have any concerns about sizing or time. We're now less than two months out from our wedding and need to find a new ring.
Response from Manly BandsJan 16, 2025
Hi Aynsley, I am so sorry to hear that this was your experience with us. We would love to make it right! I couldn't locate your order, so please reach back out to our customer support team and we would love to further assist with this!
MA
MagicMerker
This is a scam company you can buy…
This is a scam company you can buy these rings for 3 dollars each off Temu.
Response from Manly BandsJan 28, 2026
Hi MagicMerker, as we can speak to our quality of rings - we cannot speak to the rings you buy off of Temu! As well as we offer an extensive warranty to have your ring covered incase something does happen to it! If you have any further questions, please reach out :)