Founded in 2012, Keystone Puppies is a small, family-owned company dedicated to helping families safely find healthy, well-socialized puppies from reputable dog breeders.We are a trusted online puppy advertising platform that connects responsible breeders with caring families searching for puppies for sale. Our goal is to provide a credible, transparent place where potential pet owners can confidently find their fur-ever companion without uncertainty or risk.At Keystone Puppies, we carefully partner with responsible dog breeders who raise their puppies in clean, nurturing environments and prioritize proper veterinary care, early socialization, and overall health. We believe that well-raised puppies transition more smoothly into their new homes, creating lifelong bonds between pets and families.Through our Accredited Breeder Program, we recognize breeders who go above and beyond state requirements. Accredited breeders offer extended health guarantees, follow higher care standards, and remain committed to continually improving their breeding practices. By incentivizing these higher standards, we work to elevate responsible breeding practices across the industry.As a family-owned business, relationships matter to us. We are hands-on, involved, and committed to transparency, accountability, and improving the experience of buying a puppy online. Families across the United States trust Keystone Puppies to connect them with reputable breeders and healthy puppies raised with care.Every puppy deserves a loving home. Every family deserves peace of mind. Keystone Puppies exists to make that connection possible....safely, responsibly, and confidently.
Keystone Puppies (keystonepuppies.com) has 1,920 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Also known as
keystonepuppies.com
Website
keystonepuppies.com
Category
Pet Stores
Location
Mount Joy, Pennsylvania
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 18% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Dog is very timid. Breeder does not even contact you to see how puppy is doing.
Glorified puppy mill.
Response from Keystone PuppiesNov 21, 2020
I am sorry that the breeder did not contact you after your purchase. I would love to know more information and if that is the reason you feel he was a puppy mill? We visit every breeders location and do not deal with any breeder that we feel is such. Please shoot me an email with details - [email protected]. Thanks!
KE
Kendall
Horrible Service
Horrible my puppy was scared and looked like he saw a ghost when we arrived. The person who delivered him was hitting and yelling at my poor puppy. I will not be buying from here again.
Response from Keystone PuppiesOct 17, 2020
I am so sorry to hear that you did not have a good experience! What you are describing is not acceptable from breeders who we advertise for. I would greatly appreciate it if you would email us at [email protected] to give me more information so we can look into this breeder immediately!
CB
carol B.
Not sure if I'm doing this correctly…
Not sure if I'm doing this correctly but I like Cassie the female puppy. Could I know more? How much, is she fixed, and how do I get her. I am in winneconne wisc. I lost my 12 years old dog in Aug and ready to love again😍
KK
Kim K.
I would never ever purchase another dog…
I would never ever purchase another dog from Keystone Puppies again nor did I ever heard about this Keystone puppies.com. I thought this was a repealable breeder that was in business for several years. The breeder of Mr. Elmer Lapp and Ruth Lapp, kept their dogs and puppies in a garage all the kennels had dog feeces laying around, I saw NO bowls of water for the puppies and adults cocker spaniel, the puppy I purchase from them was not clean, smell, dirty, had dog poop, urine on her, ate each other dog feece, the garage was very cold and one of the adult dog that was in the kennel by herself was in a corner shaking and was scare. The puppies has not been socialize outside to the world, they have never seen the outside world, etc. If I would have known the puppy Tinklerbell was in such the condition she was in I would have not purchase her and demanded my $200.00 deposit back. My friend was ready to tell me to just get up and go as he did not like the condition where these puppies and adult dogs where living. I informed my friend I was about ready to stay the something to you too. But my friend saw when the 1 1/2 old child started playing with Tinklerbell puppy which I had a deposit on went over. When I got home to where I live in Maryland I had to pay $40.00 at a dog wash to wash this puppy and I could tell this puppy never had seen a bath by the way the puppy put up a fight with me. I was told that these dogs were kept in a house and the puppies were house broken and crate train, Mrs. Ruth Lapp, on 02/29/2020, did not seem to want to be bother with me. When I ask questions I was told that all they puppies was housebroken and crate train, well this breeder LIE TO ME!!! Tried to ask question, and I informed Mr. and Mrs. Lapp that I would be arriving at 11 am at the place of resident that they provided me the address of and my friend and I had to sit in my vehicle for 1 hour while Mrs. Lapp finish giving her children a bath and dressing them. My friend and I arrive there at 11 am but we had to sit in my vehicle until 12 or after.
I also, notice on Saturday night (02/29/2020), of purchasing this puppy from them through Sunday and Monday that this puppy was leaking urine, I also, notice on Sunday that the puppy had an eye infection, and not to mention that this female puppy is leaking urine.
In 06/2006, I purchase a cocker spaniel from a breeder located in Florida, and she was a female, the breeder kept in contact with me for over 1 to 2 yrs to check on Lily (Rename to Freckles), Freckles came clean no dirt, smell of feece, urine, etc., and she came house broken and crate train. Freckles was 13 weeks old when I purchase her. Like Tinklerbell was 13 weeks old when I purchase her on 02/29/2020, My Freckles did not cause me to itch like Tinklerbell is doing to me, nor did my Freckles every potty in the condo like Tinklerbell is doing. My Freckles never whine, yelp, or cry like Tinklerbell is doing. My freckles was one of the best cockers spaniel I have ever had and she knew all her neighbor. My neighbor go to talk and pet Tinklerbell she takes off hiding and I went around and introduce Tinklerbell to my neighbors, and she will not go no where near them nor will she go for a walk she refuses. but to just sit outside and look.
Response from Keystone PuppiesMar 4, 2020
I am so very sorry to hear that you were unhappy with your experience! You did the right thing by letting us know of your concerns. We take all feedback very seriously and will conduct a surprise home visit to check on both the puppies & the adult dogs. We created our business for potential caring pet owners to have a credible, safe place to find their fur-ever friend and we truly apologize that you did not find that. Despite your negative view of Keystone Puppies, we remain committed to solving this issue. We are here if you need anything else! [email protected]
KK
Kevin K.
Running a scam service.
Running a scam service.. not address or location of puppies ever given Buyer beware!!!!!
Response from Keystone PuppiesNov 26, 2019
Kevin - Let me assure you that we are not a scam website. We have been in business for 7 years and run a legitimate service. Unfortunately there is a website keystonepupps.com that is running a scam website. We are aware of the situation and have been trying to get their website shut down for several weeks now. We have filed complaints with the Internet Crime Complaint Center, with the Attorney Generals Office, with Google (because this Keystone Pupps is paying Google to run ads - that's the only way you are finding them) and with Zelle because that's how people are paying for the puppies that they are not receiving. We are doing all we can to try to figure out how to shut them down. I sincerely apologize if you have been scammed but I promise it was not us. Please notice the difference in their website compared to ours.
keystonepupps.com - this is their website
keystonepuppies.com - this is our website
Please feel free to email me at [email protected] or call our office staff at (717) 492-4396 to discuss further.
MO
MoodOW
Products are very limited
Products are very limited, wish there was more to the store.
disappointing.
JA
Jack
Did not write the above, trustpilot did !!!!!!
I really don't know what to say except I am very happy that I bought the Boston terrier from Mr. Weaver and Keystone puppies. This puppy will eat anything including, Polish food ! " Thank you again "
Sincerely,
John and Lisa Thompson
213 Lamsden Dr.
Albrightsville, Pa. 18210