Keystone Puppies Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of keystonepuppies.com

Keystone PuppiesReviews of keystonepuppies.com

4.81,920 reviews
Pet Stores
Mount Joy, Pennsylvania

Call Directions Website

Keystone Puppies

About Keystone Puppies

Founded in 2012, Keystone Puppies is a small, family-owned company dedicated to helping families safely find healthy, well-socialized puppies from reputable dog breeders.We are a trusted online puppy advertising platform that connects responsible breeders with caring families searching for puppies for sale. Our goal is to provide a credible, transparent place where potential pet owners can confidently find their fur-ever companion without uncertainty or risk.At Keystone Puppies, we carefully partner with responsible dog breeders who raise their puppies in clean, nurturing environments and prioritize proper veterinary care, early socialization, and overall health. We believe that well-raised puppies transition more smoothly into their new homes, creating lifelong bonds between pets and families.Through our Accredited Breeder Program, we recognize breeders who go above and beyond state requirements. Accredited breeders offer extended health guarantees, follow higher care standards, and remain committed to continually improving their breeding practices. By incentivizing these higher standards, we work to elevate responsible breeding practices across the industry.As a family-owned business, relationships matter to us. We are hands-on, involved, and committed to transparency, accountability, and improving the experience of buying a puppy online. Families across the United States trust Keystone Puppies to connect them with reputable breeders and healthy puppies raised with care.Every puppy deserves a loving home. Every family deserves peace of mind. Keystone Puppies exists to make that connection possible....safely, responsibly, and confidently.

Keystone Puppies (keystonepuppies.com) has 1,920 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.

Also known as: keystonepuppies.com
Website: keystonepuppies.com
Category: Pet Stores
Location: Mount Joy, Pennsylvania
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 18% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Pet Stores, Pennsylvania

Keystone Puppies reviews

Showing 1,747 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters

customer
Feb 24, 2026
Great breeders
Great breeders! We love our puppy!
Report
Shannon C.
Feb 24, 2026
We had a great experience working with…Andrew Beiler
We had a great experience working with the breeder Andrew Beiler and Sean from Keystone. They were both very caring and informative. We purchased Cassie, a sweet little Havapoo for my parents who recently lost their little furry friend and she is absolutely perfect!! They flew her from PA to TX and everything went smoothly. I got updates from both Andrew and Sean and a follow up when she arrived. I would definitely recommend them and would absolutely buy another puppy from them. My parents are in love with their new pup. She was in perfect health and has the most amazing personality. THANK YOU!!
Response from Keystone PuppiesFeb 24, 2026
Thank you so much for your beautiful review. It truly means a lot to us. We’re honored that you chose Keystone Puppies, Andrew, and Shawn to help your parents welcome Cassie into their home. Knowing she arrived safely, healthy, and with such a wonderful personality is exactly what we hope for every family. Hearing that your parents are in love with their sweet Havapoo makes our day! Thank you again for your trust and recommendation. We wish your family and Cassie many happy, love-filled years together.
Report
tlalbright
Feb 23, 2026
We had a great experience with who we…Super Great
We had a great experience with who we got our new puppy from. Clean and well cared for. She is a sm. poodle and is just a ball of fun. Levi Stoltzfus was so kind and called a few times afterwards to check on her. Great to deal with. Thank-you, Terry and Brenda Albright
Response from Keystone PuppiesFeb 24, 2026
Thank you so much for your kind review! We’re so happy to hear you had a great experience and that your sweet little Poodle is such a fun addition to your home. It’s wonderful to know she was well cared for and that Levi continued to check in after she went home...that kind of follow-up and care means a lot to families. We truly appreciate you choosing Keystone Puppies and for taking the time to share your experience. Wishing you many joyful years with your new ball of fun!
Report
Shan K.
Feb 23, 2026
We absolutely love our new puppy 10/10 recommend
We absolutely love our new puppy! We definitely recommend John and the King family! He went above and beyond to help us and make sure we were happy with our puppy (: 10/10 recommend this breeder!!!
Response from Keystone PuppiesFeb 23, 2026
Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled to hear how much you love your new puppy! It means so much to hear that John and the King family went above and beyond to make sure you were happy. We truly value breeders who are committed to their puppies and to the families they serve. Thank you for trusting Keystone Puppies and for your 10/10 recommendation! We wish you and your new furry family member a lifetime of happiness together!
Report
Diann
Feb 23, 2026
Parson Jack Russell Terrier
I had a lot of questions considering I was purchasing out of state. Keystone puppies associate was very helpful with answering a lot of my questions. I got a Jack Russell Terrier puppy and the breeder was Levi King. He was very helpful and nice and helped me through the process when calling a couple times back-and-forth. The puppy seems very healthy. Furry Trails did my delivery drove the puppy from Pennsylvania to Las Vegas. They did an excellent job kept in touch with me throughout the entire time. Thank you
Response from Keystone PuppiesFeb 23, 2026
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience! We know purchasing a puppy out of state can come with a lot of questions, and we’re so glad our Keystone Puppies team was able to help guide you through the process. We’re happy to hear that Levi King was helpful and supportive throughout your journey and that your Jack Russell Terrier is doing well and healthy. That’s exactly what we hope for every family! Thank you again for trusting Keystone Puppies to help you find your new best friend. We wish you and your new pup many happy years together!
Report
Kathleen F.
Feb 21, 2026
Great experience
Friendly and responsive family . Willing to answer all questions we had. So happy to have a new addition to the family.
Report
Nathan and LeighAnn L.
Feb 18, 2026
Easy process
Breeders were great and very knowledgeable. The site made finding a puppy very easy!
Report
customer
Feb 17, 2026
Two Puppies
We got two puppies from the same litter. The family who sold them to us were wonderful and caring. We couldn't be happier with our new pups.
Report