Keystone Puppies Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of keystonepuppies.com

Keystone PuppiesReviews of keystonepuppies.com

4.81,920 reviews
Pet Stores
Mount Joy, Pennsylvania

Call Directions Website

Keystone Puppies

About Keystone Puppies

Founded in 2012, Keystone Puppies is a small, family-owned company dedicated to helping families safely find healthy, well-socialized puppies from reputable dog breeders.We are a trusted online puppy advertising platform that connects responsible breeders with caring families searching for puppies for sale. Our goal is to provide a credible, transparent place where potential pet owners can confidently find their fur-ever companion without uncertainty or risk.At Keystone Puppies, we carefully partner with responsible dog breeders who raise their puppies in clean, nurturing environments and prioritize proper veterinary care, early socialization, and overall health. We believe that well-raised puppies transition more smoothly into their new homes, creating lifelong bonds between pets and families.Through our Accredited Breeder Program, we recognize breeders who go above and beyond state requirements. Accredited breeders offer extended health guarantees, follow higher care standards, and remain committed to continually improving their breeding practices. By incentivizing these higher standards, we work to elevate responsible breeding practices across the industry.As a family-owned business, relationships matter to us. We are hands-on, involved, and committed to transparency, accountability, and improving the experience of buying a puppy online. Families across the United States trust Keystone Puppies to connect them with reputable breeders and healthy puppies raised with care.Every puppy deserves a loving home. Every family deserves peace of mind. Keystone Puppies exists to make that connection possible....safely, responsibly, and confidently.

Keystone Puppies (keystonepuppies.com) has 1,920 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.

Also known as: keystonepuppies.com
Website: keystonepuppies.com
Category: Pet Stores
Location: Mount Joy, Pennsylvania
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 18% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Pet Stores, Pennsylvania

Keystone Puppies reviews

Showing 1,747 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters

Katherine L.
May 27, 2021
My baby loves her puppy❤️
My baby loves her puppy❤️
Report
william S.
May 27, 2021
Met a great breeder and found a new…
Met a great breeder and found a new family member for the pack.. ty
Report
Jason
May 24, 2021
Best Puppy Ever!
We are supremely happy with our newest addition to our family. He is healthy, happy, well adjusted and is great with the kids. I am grateful we found Keystone Puppies and that our Bo was available. We even had a chance to meet Bo's big mama, and she is super friendly! I cannot express how happy we are and how thankful we feel toward Keystone Puppies for their humane, compassionate, and customer oriented practices. We endorse Keystone Puppies and recommend them to anyone looking to add a furry friend to their family.
Report
Jeanette
May 24, 2021
Excellent experience overall
Thank you for the excellent communication and more importantly, for our new best friend! Winx is now Beau, and he is healthy and happy with us in his new home! So happy with the entire process!
Report
John
May 21, 2021
The purchase of our silver Labrador…
The purchase of our silver Labrador Retriever from Elmer King was an exceptional experience from beginning to end. From the initial phone call Elmer answered all our questions and concerns. Upon pick up of our puppy Elmer had all the necessary paperwork and took the time to explain everything. He provided us with an extremely happy and healthy puppy confirmed by our veterinarian. To our surprise two weeks later Elmer called to check up on the puppy and how things were going. The small gesture was so greatly appreciated. Our puppy AJ is a wonderful dog and I would definitely recommend Elmer King to anyone looking for a puppy. Thank you Elmer.
Response from Keystone PuppiesMay 24, 2021
Thank you so much for giving such an amazing review about Elmer! He is a great breeder and we are so happy you too agree with that! We are so happy to hear your puppy is doing so well and hope you will keep us updated! Thanks again!
Report
Marie L.
May 21, 2021
Stop thinking about it and just do it!
I was nervous to purchase a pup and have it shipped across the country (I'm in CA), but I shouldn't have been! The entire process was seamless from start to finish. Shawn stayed in very close contact on shipping day and I knew where our pup was at all times. She's gorgeous, healthy, socialized, and everything we wanted. A week after she arrived, Ephraim Stolzfus (breeder) called to check up on her and make sure I was happy. Excellent service, and would purchase a puppy from Ephraim a hundred times over. Will definitely be purchasing from Keystone Puppies again!
Report
Mark
May 21, 2021
The entire experience was easy and…
The entire experience was easy and exciting. We love our puppy who is beautiful and entertaining. She is training US well. I think she’s going to keep us! Thanx
Report
Cesilia V.
May 19, 2021
Loved You Guys
I loved the communication with Mr. Lantz I fell in love with my puppy who now is 5 months he has brought so much happiness to my my familys life. Thank You For Evreything Great Customer Service
Report