Invicta is a fast growing watch brand, and is considered by collectors and enthusiasts alike to be a market leader in horological innovation and creativity. The long held belief that supremely crafted timepieces can be offered for a modest sum is the founding principle of Invicta.
InvictaStores (invictastores.com) has 740 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.2 out of 5.
Also known as
invictastores.com
Website
invictastores.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Location
Davie, Florida
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 4% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I have been very happy with the Invicta products and service. All items received met or exceeded my expectations. They make a great product that is of good quality for the price you pay. Would highly recommend.
AR
Anonymous R.
Invicta on Whatnot (Long‑Term Customer Perspective)
I’ve been an Invicta customer on Whatnot for over 7 months, with 500+ purchases totaling over $23,000, so this review reflects long‑term experience, not a single incident.
Recently, I was removed from a jewelry livestream hosted by Eliana after mentioning I had the host muted due to tinnitus. This was a general comment, not directed at her. I was told to mute my phone, which I already do at times, but muting means I can’t hear important product details. Whatnot’s closed captioning is inconsistent and often inaccurate, so it isn’t a reliable alternative. Despite calmly explaining this, I was removed — an arbitrary decision given the accessibility context.
Meanwhile, far more questionable moments on other Invicta streams have been tolerated without issue, which highlights inconsistent moderation.
Across Invicta‑run channels, there are recurring issues:
1. Yves Rocher credibility concerns
Teenage hosts promoting anti‑aging skincare weakens trust. Oversaturation led to low engagement and uncomfortable shows that didn’t feel sustainable.
2. Mayamar value issues
Gold‑dipped jewelry is marketed with high value claims and “no tarnish” guarantees, yet tarnishing complaints already exist. Combined with a two‑week return window, trust is difficult.
3. Host behavior affecting purchases
A first‑time viewer was told by Eliana, “This show isn’t about you,” causing her to cancel her purchase. Due to repeated negative experiences, I no longer buy from Eliana’s shows and rarely from Brooke’s.
4. Pressure during diamond shows
On the InvictaLifestyle show, Brooke and Ilianna expressed frustration about “window shopping” while selling high‑ticket lab‑created IGI diamonds. Most buyers wanted smaller, affordable stones under $150, yet the hosts pushed larger‑carat pieces with a much smaller audience. Lab‑created stones don’t carry the same cachet as natural diamonds, and pressuring viewers creates discomfort.
5. Inventory vs. audience mismatch
InvictaForHer often shows 300–500 units of a watch to an audience of ~150 viewers, making urgency messaging feel unrealistic and contributing to host frustration.
6. Overreliance on hype and giveaways
Giveaways are used as purchase incentives rather than engagement tools. Some hosts “flash” giveaways for only seconds, making them impossible to enter — especially for Android users whose animation cannot be sped up due to Whatnot’s override.
7. MSRP misuse
Invicta’s own website regularly discounts items 40%+, making MSRP feel theoretical and undermining credibility when used as a pricing anchor.
8. Limited product education
Hosts repeat basic specs without explaining why they matter, which doesn’t build trust when selling watches or fine jewelry.
Conclusion
There is a clear disconnect between the audience Invicta wants and the audience it actually has. Better training, consistent moderation, realistic value framing, and genuine customer research would go a long way. As someone who has invested significant time and money, I want to see Invicta succeed — but current practices are eroding customer confidence and long‑term loyalty.
OT
Othon
A joke of a company
Orders should be provided in a timely manner. If your company sets an expectation of 1 to 5 business days, you should honor this. Beware, this company is not a serious company.
DS
Deshawn S.
One of my watches never arrived
One of my watches never arrived. The rest of them came pretty quickly so im not too mad about it, even though I would like the watch I ordered.
SJ
S J.
Fools Gold-Glycine Combat Diver
Fools Gold-Glycine Combat Diver
Run from this brand, watch was only two-years old and the spring engine failed. The customer service stated that the watch needed a complete overhaul for 380USD. Well, that 90% of the purchase price. Get a top-tier time piece from Seiko or Citizen, or Ten Casios for 380USD. Thank you for attention to this matter.
JO
Jonathan O.
Over a month and no update on the order
Over a month and no update on the order and when it will be shipped. Their customer service was useless and kept saying they are waiting for the store to ship it to the warehouse. Makes no sense! Sounds to me like its not in stock and they continue to oversell.
CW
Carlos W.
Quality and unique watches
Quality and unique watches
CF
Craig F.
I truly enjoy the Invicta Brand
I truly enjoy the Invicta Brand. I currently own 10 watches in my collection. Great colors and styling