Heaven Mayhem is an accessory and lifestyle brand celebrated for its refined, wearable statements that elevate the everyday. Rooted in timeless design and reimagined for the modern wardrobe, each piece is developed with our community in mind.
Heaven Mayhem (heavenmayhem.com) has 114 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.0 out of 5.
Also known as
heavenmayhem.com
Website
heavenmayhem.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Location
Los Angeles
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 17% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Heaven Mayhem customer service was top notch! So responsive and resolved my situation immediately. Normally I buy jewelry from here but I am loving their jewelry box storage options and letter/desk items too. I will definitely be back on their site soon!
Response from Heaven MayhemOct 4, 2026
Katie - Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us such a kind review! We take so much pride in our customer support team, and we’re thrilled to hear you had a great experience. We’re so glad you’re here and can’t wait to have you back! xx
EM
Emma
I pre-ordered the Gaze Choker on…
I pre-ordered the Gaze Choker on February 14, 2026, with an expected delivery in April. After months of silence, delayed promises, and constantly having to chase customer service, I finally received it in August—6 months later.
To make matters worse, the choker arrived damaged, with a torn strap and scratched silver. Instead of sending a replacement as requested, they issued an unannounced refund. Now the price has gone up. Poor communication, awful quality control, and zero resolution. Save yourself the headache and think twice before buying from them.
Response from Heaven MayhemSep 16, 2026
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience. We’re very sorry to hear how frustrating this process has been, especially after waiting so long for your Gaze Choker.
We’d really appreciate the opportunity to look into what happened here and see how we can make this right. Please reach out to our customer service inbox ([email protected]) and ask to be forwarded directly to Sarah. She’ll personally review your order and experience from there.
Thank you again for bringing this to our attention.
BR
Brooke
Late Arrival
I paid for expedited shipping only for my items to be received 4 days later than expected. Will be returning items.
KE
Kerstin
Bad Quality, Bad Customer Service
I've placed five orders with all different experiences. My first was the knot earrings, I've had them for a couple of years and one of the backing completely snapped off as I was putting it on. The next two orders have been fine, *so far*.
Next, I purchased their new laptop cover.. To be honest the price stung a bit. $100 is steep for a case that doesn't have any padding to it. Within ONE month, all four corners have completely fallen apart. I don't travel with my laptop often, so this is disappointing. One of the few times I did, something put pressure on the case, causing my laptop screen to break, a $1,000 fix. Shouldn't the case protected it from that? I asked for a replacement and they said they would add me to the list as it was out of stock, and it would ship immediately when it is available. I waited two months, and one day, decided to check their website (during their sample sale). To my surprise.. it was in stock. I emailed them and they took a week to respond, no apology, and sent it out.
The most recent order was the velvet jewelry pouch from the sale, it has been a month and it still has not shipped. It says in the email order confirmation it ships within 1-2 days.
I am so incredibly disappointed by HM and most likely won't order from them ever again.
TA
Tatiana
Pure excellence and excitement from the purchase
I looooove everything about my purchase! The Giselle watch is so beautiful and elegant and luxurious, I can’t stop looking at it! 🤩🤩🤩Thank you! Appreciate the complementary pouch that the watch comes in, very nice piece. I wish you could recreate the same watch in silver with white dial or another color dial - up to your beautiful imagination 🌹
Response from Heaven MayhemJul 19, 2026
Hi Tatiana, thank you so much for the beautiful review! We’re so happy to hear how much you love your Giselle Watch. And we love your idea for a silver version with a white dial—we’ll be sure to share that with our team. Thank you so much for your support! ❤️
KA
Kate
Unfortunately giving zero stars is not…
Unfortunately giving zero stars is not possible but I ordered a MacBook 13 air cover and they sent me the completely wrong item. I didn’t even want to get my money back just exchange it for the correct case and they would not let me. Customer service sucks, don’t buy from this website.
Response from Heaven MayhemJul 14, 2026
Hi Kate,
We're so sorry to hear about your experience. We'd love to help make this right.
If you purchased your laptop cover during our Final Sale event, we'd still be happy to exchange it for the correct size. The MacBook Air 13" covers can be a little confusing because there are two different versions depending on your model.
We'll work with you to make sure you receive the correct cover. Please reach out to our customer support team with your order number, or reply to your existing email, and we'll get this sorted out for you.
We appreciate you bringing this to our attention, and I'm sorry for the frustration.
OK
Olga K.
They never even shipped my order…
This has been one of the worst online shopping experiences I have ever had. I paid for my order, it was marked as shipped on July 3rd, and eleven days later the tracking still shows the parcel was never handed to the carrier. It never left their warehouse. The “shipping confirmation” was nothing but a label.
Their customer service is a joke. On Instagram I got a copy paste apology and a promise to follow up “right away.” That was the last I heard from them. Since then my messages have been seen and ignored. The contact form on their website leads nowhere either. Complete silence the moment they had my money and I had questions.
This level of unprofessionalism is honestly pathetic for a brand that presents itself so polished on social media. Pretty Instagram feed, zero operations behind it.
I am filing a chargeback with my bank and reporting the store to Shopify. Do yourself a favor and do not order from their website. If something goes wrong, and clearly it does, nobody will answer you.
Response from Heaven MayhemJul 14, 2026
Hi Olga,
Thank you for bringing this to my attention, and I'm truly sorry for your experience. I'm the Customer Experience Supervisor, and I'd like the opportunity to make this right for you.
I'm sending you an email right now so we can work together on a resolution as quickly as possible. Thank you for giving us the chance to address this, and I hope we can regain your trust.
ST
Steph
Beautiful and stay on all day
As a petite person with small hands and thin wrists, I am extremely pleased to finally have a beautiful chunky bangle to wear. I have tried so many other brands throughout the years and none have ever worked for me. This bangle stays on all day no matter what I'm doing - I've even worn it while mucking horse stalls. I hope Heaven Mayhem continues to produce bangles and other bracelets in this size. I'll forever be a customer if you do.
Response from Heaven MayhemJul 8, 2026
This made our day! Thank you so much for taking the time to share! We’re so happy to hear the bangle has been such a great fit for you. The fact that wear to muck horse stalls is amazing by itself! Wow! 🤍 Thank you for being part of the Heaven Mayhem community.