tanvi R.
Big Promises, Zero Delivery! Stay Away from Dewey Smart
Dewey Smart was a huge disappointment. All the counselors were college students with no real experience. My child is a senior, and the ones assigned to us were completely unprofessional. Their calendars were booked weeks into admission season, and even then, they kept canceling at the last minute. We ended up using barely 2 hours of actual service in three months because no one was available or responsive. The so-called “guaranteed internships” are a total scam — they just send a list of random links, half of which don’t even work. No one actually helps or guides you through anything. Their website is slow, buggy, and badly managed. The only good thing is they refunded the money, but by then we had already lost valuable time we should have spent working on essays early. If you care about your child’s college applications, avoid Dewey Smart. They waste time and give you nothing useful in return.
Response from DeweySmart: Ivy League Tutors & College CounselorsJan 9, 2026
Tanvi — I’m sorry for the experience you described. For a senior in admissions season, booked-out calendars, last-minute cancellations, and slow responsiveness are unacceptable, and I understand the opportunity cost of lost time on essays. A couple clarifications for future families: • “Guaranteed internships.” In the past we offered a separate program that included a refund guarantee tied to internship outcomes. We have since discontinued that program and do not market internship outcomes as “guaranteed” today. If anything you received felt like a generic link list (or had broken links), that’s not the standard we want and we’ve updated how we handle opportunities and guidance. • Website / platform performance. We’ve rebuilt our public website and also replaced our internal operating system with Gigpie, which is faster and more reliable. We continue shipping improvements to scheduling, communication, and accountability to prevent exactly the coordination issues you ran into. I’m glad you received a refund, but I recognize that doesn’t restore the time you lost. If you’re open to it, please email [email protected] with the name/email on the account and “Tanvi Roy review” in the subject so I can personally review what happened (availability, cancellations, responsiveness) and ensure we learn from it. — Boris, Owner, Dewey Smart




