FLAT RATE SHIPPING! Get it NOW! from CaskCartel.com | At Cask Cartel, we provide a selection of premium spirits online. We carry whiskey, rum, moonshine, vodka, and more. Buy and send liquor to loved ones! | Buy/Order 24/7 | Gifts for Yourself and Ever...
Cask Cartel (caskcartel.com) has 189 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 1.5 out of 5.
Also known as
caskcartel.com
Website
caskcartel.com
Category
Beverages & Liquor
Location
Cheyenne, Wyoming
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 46% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I had an overall great experience as a first time customer. There were some supply issues with my order, but the staff has gone above and beyond to make right those wrongs (which by the way, really was not the fault of Cask Cartel) and made accommodations with which I am totally pleased. I will most definitely be a long time customer
Response from Cask CartelFeb 9, 2023
Thank you so much for sharing your experience, Brian! We are happy we were able to turn this experience around for you.
PA
Paul
Customer Service is the best. They sent me what I ordered and…
They sent me what I ordered and resolved any issues i've had. For the items I ordered in the past it takes some time before I get them. I have learned to plan ahead to get the order when I need it. They are very reliable and ready to help with any problem you may have.
Response from Cask CartelJan 19, 2023
Paul, thank you so much for this provided feedback. We are so happy to hear that our Customer Service Team has been good to you and we look forward to assisting you in the future with any of your spirit needs!
AR
Arvin
Great Gifts for Clients! Even better support team!
Simple and easy to use! I also needed my invoice to include on my expense report. I emailed Cask Carter's helpdesk and within minutes I got a response!
Thanks so much to Ava for quickly solving my issue! Will definitely use again for future corporate gifts!
Response from Cask CartelJan 9, 2023
We appreciate the feedback and look forward to serving you and your clients in the future!
JG
Jonathan G.
I see a lot of negative reviews
I see a lot of negative reviews, and was discouraged after my order was not fulfilled immediately. However it all worked out well, it was fine.
First let me say this, if you want booze now, go to a liquor store, use Instacart or just go to a bar.
This is my experience :
I ordered 4 bottles of Slingsby Gin, that is generally not available anywhere in the USA. It is not exported widely. I have been to Harrogate, and truly enjoyed these gins, and wanted to have them in my home for my mother’s visit, as she is an older British woman, who loves her G&T.
I waited about 3.5 weeks and it showed up. Not cheap, not fast, but I got something that I cannot get anywhere that I know of, in America.
I contacted customer service after reading bad reviews, but they were all very nice and polite. Generally helpful, and gave me the information they could.
I would recommend Cask Cartel based on my experience of getting something that I really cannot get anywhere, and I sincerely thank them for getting this to me. IF YOU WANT SOMETHING THAT you cannot get easily, and can be a little patient, then it will work out.
DM
Diana M.
Would Recommend Cask Cartel to Everyone
After I placed my order I then checked reviews. I was VERY nervous about placing my order. That being said I would highly recommend Cask Cartel. Order was easy to place I received many updates on my order. Received my order today in great condition.
GM
gmellisjr
Very Happy With Cask Cartel
Although Cask Cartel has received a number of negative reviews in Trustpilot, my experience with them was stellar. I don't mind saying that after reading the Trustpilot reviews, I was not a little apprehensive. I ordered two bottles of specialty bourbon which I was unable to obtain locally. Although Cask Cartel was quite expensive, I received both bottles by FedEx ground within three days of my order. The communication from Cask Cartel was excellent, appraising me of each step of the process of fulfilling and shipping my order. I don't normally provide reviews, but my experience with them was as good as any vendor I have dealt with for shipping wine or liquor.
CC
Cater C.
Great and fast service!
I have yet to experience any issues purchasing from Cask Cartel. I stumbled upon Hibiki a few years ago. It’s no longer available here locally and my only option is to purchase online. I tried a few other websites but they won’t ship to my area.
Guess what, Cask Cartel does!
I also received a couple new bottles so I could try them. Nakka Coffey and nakka from the barrel.
TI
Time
From the looks of most other reviews
From the looks of most other reviews, you would think this is a terrible company. However, my experience was much different. I placed my order, THEN read the horrible reviews.... backwards, I know. I then requested PayPal refund my money so I could avoid the headache. No dice; the money cleared my account and PayPal told me I’d have to take it up with Cask Cartel. I did so and within a day I received an email assuring me my order had been received, was processing, and it would be shipped in the next 4-10 days. Long story short, I received my order less than 10 days later and it was exactly what I ordered. I will definitely be ordering from them again.