High-End Traditional Handmade Jewelry from heart of Istanbul. Boutique Ottoman provides classic designs with selected gemstones to worldwide customers.
Boutique Ottoman Jewelry (boutiqueottoman.com) has 194 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
boutiqueottoman.com
Website
boutiqueottoman.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Location
Newark
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 98% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I had a problem with my shipping address. The customer service person was top notch and he/she really helped me change it and I received my ring within a week. I was very happy when I received a call that my ring had arrived.
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelryJul 17, 2023
Thank you for your valuable review.
FI
farouk I.
The products are of high quality
The products are of high quality! Also the shipping method is efficient and fast. I am very happy purchasing from Ottoman boutique.
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Thank you, Farouk! We’re so happy to know you’re pleased with the quality of our pieces and the efficiency of our shipping. ✨ Providing both exceptional craftsmanship and smooth delivery is at the heart of what we do. We truly appreciate your trust and look forward to crafting more timeless jewelry for you.
Warm regards,
Boutique Ottoman Team
MM
M M.
Premium products
Premium products. Excellent Quality. Fast Delivery
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Thank you, M.M! We’re delighted to hear that you appreciate the premium quality of our products and the speed of our delivery. ✨ Our mission is to combine luxury craftsmanship with reliable service, and feedback like yours assures us we’re on the right path. We look forward to serving you again soon!
Warm regards,
Boutique Ottoman Team
JP
Jeffrey P.
Great customer service and Quality
Great customer service! The quality of the white onyx ring I purchased is exceptional, the ring size is perfect and I get many compliments from people on this ring. Boutique's shipping is great and if for any reason there is a hold up they will keep you informed. Great company to order jewelry from!!
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Thank you, Jeffrey! We’re thrilled to hear that you love your white onyx ring and that it’s receiving so many compliments. ✨ Knowing that the fit, quality, and our service met your expectations makes us very proud. We’ll always do our best to keep our customers informed and satisfied. We look forward to crafting more pieces for you in the future!
Warm regards,
Boutique Ottoman Team
SJ
Seraphina J.
Excitement Over Order Turned Into Horror. Dishonorable and Fraudulent Business
I was super excited to buy my first Boutique Ottoman jewellery, because of all the positive reviews on their website; and because of how they presented themselves as a reputable jeweller, selling authentic and natural gemstones and they called other Etsy and Ebay jewellers fake, so being naive I trusted the website narrative Boutique Ottoman presented. It was only after I found that they routinely delete negative reviews from their website and any comments that question the authenticity of their gemstones from their Instagram page. Any negative buyer experience on Instagram, they delete and block buyer.
My background: I am an experienced gem collector with 20 plus years of experience. I have experience of buying precious and semi-precious gemstone jewellery from international and national jewellers; from premium brand name jewellers (who give GIA certificates for certain pieces) as well as mall jewellery stores (no GIA or equivalent certificates but good reputation and solid customer service).
However, I am sad to report that my first experience with Boutique Ottoman will be my last. They were incredibly rude and insulting when I merely asked polite and valid questions about their product details, regarding what kind of treatment if any their gemstones have undergone, and if their gemstones are all natural or coated because the gemstone in question didn't look natural to me. Instead of giving any straightforward answer, they were evasive and gaslighted me, and tried to intimidate me to shut me up. I only asked the question twice...after waiting several days for an answer, first red flag when a seller is defensive and tries to get you to stop asking valid questions about any order which you have every right to ask.
Second red flag, their prices are completely different on their own website compared to their Etsy reseller, you can check for yourselves.
Third Red Flag, they claim on their website that their jewellery costs so much because they have professional jewellers certify that their gemstones are authentic and not fake...and hence they pass the cost down to the customer. This would be acceptable only if they were also passing on the third party lab certificate of authenticity to the customer, as is the customer's right if they are passing down the costs to us. Instead, they send us their own brand card stamped with their logo, passing it off as a certificate of authenticity, when it is invalid as a certificate. They can print anything on it, it doesn't have any third party accredited lab verification.
As per their claim that they will issue refund if you submit lab report that their item is fake: they only allow us 30 days to get refund, when you submit your gem to GIA accredited lab or any legitimate third party lab for authentification, it takes the lab up to 2 months (especially GIA is working slowly due to Covid they are backlogged) and it costs $80 dollars for the GIA lab test plus $18 to $35 to mail the item to GIA and get it back. The Boutique Ottoman still refuses to refund you the cost of purchase claiming you were too late. They certainly don't refund you for the cost of the lab tests which proved their item is fake.
Buyers Beware, Boutique Ottoman is not only fraudulent and sells cheap gems for overinflated rates, they lie about their certificate, they don't have third party lab certificate of authenticity, and they won't refund you even when you prove their items are fake. They will gaslight you and be insulting and try to intimidate you. As if their fraud and selling fake stones isn't bad enough, as other reviewers mentioned, their gems routinely fall out of their mount setting, which is shameful for any reputable jeweller to have such poor quality control. Any reputable jeweller will either fix or repair the item free of charge, because it is a quality control issue that should NOT happen in mere 4-5 months after a purchase, shouldn't even happen within 2 years of purchase for normal wear. But Boutique Ottoman has shown they will always make excuses, as you can see from their responses to other customers they mistreated. Boutique Ottoman has shown a pattern of not accepting responsibility for their inferior quality and yet they charge extremely overinflated prices for same exact items which you can buy from Turkey yourself for $13-$50. You can also check this for yourself.
When I posted comment on Boutique Ottoman's Instagram page, they not only deleted my comment but they blocked me. I intend to post screenshots of their responses and my experience with this fraudulent and dishonorable seller, so that others may learn from my horrible experience with them.
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Dear Seraphina,
Thank you for your feedback. We would like to clarify a few key points:
Boutique Ottoman does not operate on Etsy or any other third-party marketplace. Our jewellery is sold exclusively via our official website, boutiqueottoman.com
. Any listings you may find on Etsy or elsewhere are unauthorized resellers and not affiliated with us.
All gemstones we use are natural and authentic. Each product includes a Boutique Ottoman authenticity card signed by our certified jewellers. As clearly outlined in our Terms & Conditions (accepted before checkout), we do not provide GIA or third-party certificates unless specifically stated in the product description.
Our refund and return policy is transparent: returns must be initiated within 30 days of delivery. Independent lab testing outside this timeframe cannot be accepted as per our policy.
We never delete or hide reviews from Trustpilot, where all feedback—positive or negative—is verified and publicly visible.
We regret that your experience left you dissatisfied, but the accusations made in your review are not accurate. We remain committed to transparency, authenticity, and customer satisfaction. For any further clarification, please reach out to [email protected]
with your order details so we can review your case directly.
Sincerely,
Boutique Ottoman Team
MN
Muhammad Nurhady Bin Ab H.
Better Than Expected
Item arrived earlier than expected. The package was professionally and beautifully done, with a warranty card and clean cloth. The ring looks better in real life. Satisfied, and probably gonna buy more in the future.
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Thank you, Muhammad! We’re delighted to hear that your ring arrived even earlier than expected and that you enjoyed the professional packaging and details. ✨ Knowing that you’re satisfied and already considering future purchases is the greatest compliment we could receive. Your trust motivates us to keep delivering excellence every time.
Warm regards,
Boutique Ottoman Team
IR
Iram
Very awful experience the company lied…
Very awful experience the company lied about my parcel not clearing through Turkish customs when I tried to return a parcel from the UK. My courier service Parcelforce Worldwide Global Priority conducted an investigation and were able to confirm that the parcel definitely cleared customs but Boutique Ottoman did not take the parcel. I paid a lot of money for the parcel to reach Turkey. I sent evidence to a supervisor at Boutique Ottomans but they did not reply.
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Dear Iram,
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We are sorry to hear about your experience and understand your frustration. Please note that for all international returns, parcels must clear Turkish customs and be officially delivered to us in order to be processed. Unfortunately, if a parcel does not reach our warehouse, we cannot accept or issue a refund, regardless of the courier’s investigation.
We always advise customers to use return methods with full tracking and customs clearance support to avoid such situations. Our Terms & Conditions — which must be accepted at checkout — also explain this process in detail.
That said, we regret if you felt unanswered. Our team is always available at [email protected]
, and we are happy to review the documentation again if you share it directly with us.
Warm regards,
Boutique Ottoman Team
DN
Dendy N.
Zultanite
The Zultania ring that I ordered is awesome! The silver ring 925 looks very great and the quality of the stone is amazing great looking! time of delivery it was much faster than I expected. The ring size is true to fit. I would highly recommend Boutique Ottoman to anyone looking for a quality ring.
And i really really hope that the Zultanite stone is original and real natural.
Coz i dont have the courage yet to checking zultanite stone to the lab in my country…
But once again with ramadhan sale this is the best Zultania stone silver ring i ever had..Thanks Boutique Ottoman.
Response from Boutique Ottoman JewelrySep 1, 2025
Thank you, Dendy! We’re honored to know your Zultanite Silver Ring arrived faster than expected and that it exceeded your expectations in both quality and presentation. ✨ At Boutique Ottoman, we strive not only to craft authentic, natural stones but also to deliver a premium shopping experience from start to finish.
Your trust and kind words mean a great deal to us, and we’re proud this has become the best Zultanite ring you’ve ever owned. We look forward to serving you again with the same excellence.
Warm regards,
Boutique Ottoman Team