Emily
BOTM has really gone down hill
BOTM has really gone down hill. The picks are all over the place, loyalty bff features have become free “add ons” instead of a free book, you can no longer pull from your want list if you don’t like what’s available for the month, they have a bunch of features no one asked for, and (three times now) my pick has been “popular” (aka poor planning) and not arrived until the 28th-30th. If any other business didn’t deliver on the ONE THING they were supposed to, they would have made it right. They are doing so much with magazines, 100 year celebrations, offbeat finds, podcasts and audiobooks but it’s at the expense of the actual books we are purchasing. It’s embarrassing that there is only one thing they are supposed to do: ship a book once a month. They cannot do that. Oh! And! The books physically smell bad (there is a Reddit on this problem, I’m not the only one). I’ve have years with them and my grandma used to submit by catalog back in the day. They’ve been a staple in my life and a big deal in my family. I would rather shop local than continue to spend with a brand that acts like book martyrs. If I see one more article from them about how “no one reads any more” I’m going to lose it. Ship our damn book so we can. To BOTM: clean up the dead weight of your offers, let us choose what we want to read if we don’t like your 5 (you still get full price), don’t make loyal BFFs pay for the theft of birthday and lolly books (set a 2 month+ minimum), and plan appropriately based on a book’s reviews! This should not be so hard!!
Response from Book of the MonthAug 24, 2026
Hi Emily, Thanks for being a longtime member and sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear you’ve had a frustrating experience as of late. Longtime members like you make BOTM what it is, so we truly appreciate hearing your thoughts, suggestions, and feedback, and we have shared all of this with the relevant teams. We really hope you decide to stick around, but if you have any additional thoughts you would like to share please reach out to us directly at [email protected].




