Bellevue Rare Coins has specialized in buying and selling coins, jewelry, gold, diamonds, and valuables since 1979. Four convenient locations to serve you!
Bellevue Rare Coins (bellevuerarecoins.com) has 441 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Also known as
bellevuerarecoins.com
Website
bellevuerarecoins.com
Category
Investments & Wealth
Location
Bellevue, Washington
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 30% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I have had the pleasure of using your facility with Christina. She was very informative, timely. I enjoyed the atmosphere as well. Thank you so much for your time. I would recommend your company to my friend and family.
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsFeb 12, 2026
C Scott,
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We are thrilled to hear that you enjoyed our facility's atmosphere. Christina is a rockstar, and she’ll be so happy to know her informative and timely approach made such a positive impact on your visit. We truly appreciate the recommendation!
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
AS
Angie S.
Christina went above and beyond to help…
Christina went above and beyond to help all 3 in our party. Very knowledgeable and honest even if we didn't like what we thought our treasures were worth. Very polite and courteous to our feelings. Highly recommend.
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsFeb 12, 2026
Angie,
Thank you for sharing your experience! We know that 'treasures' often come with deep sentimental value, so we strive to be as honest and transparent as possible during our evaluations. We're so glad that Christina’s professionalism and courtesy made the process easier for your group. We truly appreciate the recommendation!
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
DP
Deb P.
Do NOT trust the staff and their…
Do NOT trust the staff and their professional lying skills! They will tell you your gems aren't worth anything because of the manufactured gems nowadays and not being able to tell the difference, hence your gems not worth much... LIES!!! I was in there selling items (which I had done several times, unfortunately) I walked in as an older man, obviously desperate for cash, like many of us that go in there to sell our family heirlooms. I literally heard one of the staff say, "oh yeah" very happily and celebratory, another staff said, "did you score diamonds?" The guy said " oh yeah, big ones" they laughed and then realized I was in there. I wasn't going there because I had jewelry laying around, I went out of desperation due to job loss. It was my fourth time going in, up to that point I had made the mistake of trusting these sheisters, the way they manipulate your trust is disgusting. I decided to sell one item because I needed gas... I found another place called Seattle Gold, they aren't sheisters, they are at least honest about what they are doing. I took gold there, received almost double what Bellevue coins gave me, and for the jewelry they weren't going to resell, they took the gems out and gave them back to me so I could sell just the gold, most places want the gold to melt. I left this place in shock knowing what Bellevue coins had done, but it was too late to do anything about it. I had spent the money they gave me, so I couldn't even try to purchase it back even if I wanted, which I doubt they would allow anyway. I travelled to Pittsburgh to visit family, a friend of a family member has become a jeweler, I shared the story with them; they couldn't believe what I was telling them, and how much I was paid. Anyway, STAY AWAY FROM BELLEVUE COIN! I am sad I ever went there, I sold items for half of what I should have received. Do your due diligence before you sell your jewelry, call around to different places see what they offer, and how they go about purchasing your precious gold.
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsJan 21, 2026
Deb,
We take reviews like this seriously, and we’re genuinely disappointed that you left feeling unhappy with your experience at Bellevue Rare Coins. That said, we strongly disagree with the claims made here and feel it’s important to clarify how our business operates for the benefit of anyone reading this.
Bellevue Rare Coins is a licensed, long-established precious metals and jewelry buyer in the Pacific Northwest. Every offer we make is based on current market values, metal content, gemstone quality, and resale viability, not on a customer’s appearance, personal situation, or perceived urgency. We do not misrepresent items, and we never tell customers that natural gemstones are “worth nothing.” However, many gemstones, especially small diamonds or stones removed from mass-produced jewelry that may have limited secondary market value.
All transactions at our shop are fully transparent and completely voluntary. Customers are encouraged to ask questions, decline offers, compare prices elsewhere, or walk away with their items at any time. We do not pressure anyone to sell, and we do not prevent buybacks when they are requested within reasonable timeframes and availability.
Pricing differences between buyers are normal. Some businesses operate on different margins, specialize in different resale channels, or choose to pay above market on certain items while making them up elsewhere. Receiving a higher offer at another shop does not mean a prior offer was dishonest but rather it simply reflects differing business models.
Regarding the alleged staff conversation, we categorically reject the implication that our team celebrates or exploits customers. Our staff regularly discusses inventory in professional terms, and any interpretation beyond that does not reflect our values or conduct.
We understand that selling personal or inherited items can be emotional, especially during difficult times, and we regret that you feel distressed in hindsight. However, we stand by the integrity of our evaluations, our staff, and our long-standing reputation in the community.
We always encourage sellers to do exactly what you ultimately advised: get multiple quotes, ask questions, and choose the buyer they feel most comfortable with. We are confident that customers who do so will continue to find Bellevue Rare Coins to be fair, professional, and honest.
If you would like to discuss their transaction directly, I welcome you to contact me so we can review the details together. I can be reached at (253) 328-4014 or by email at [email protected].
Thank you for your time and details of your store visit, I hope we can rectify the situation and provide you with 5-star service.
Andrew G
Regional Manger
Bellevue Rare Coins
EJ
Eric J.
Communication Challenges
From the day my wire cleared until the order was ready, was 36 days not 10 as I was told. The individuals that I began the process with became unreachable in the end and would not return emails. I would have given 1 star if it were not for Andrew G., who was great at the end.
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsJan 9, 2026
Eric,
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. I again want to make sure you know that we are very disappointed on how this transaction transpired and I am glad that you were finally able to receive your products. We should have been better with our communication and this can be used as training on how to create positive service in the future. Although I was unable to assist you until the end of the timeline, I am glad that I could find your products, ensure they were delivered, and communicate the order pick up with you.
I hope you see this as a one off mistake and we hope to assist you again in the future. As I stated at the time of our conversation, please feel free to communicate with me directly in the future to ensure this type of issue does happen again.
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
JC
Jennifer C.
I am SO glad I chose to go to Bellevue…
I am SO glad I chose to go to Bellevue Rare coins. I had a LOT of items. Elizabeth in Bellevue was the BEST! She took her time, explained, listened, helped, and made it a good day. I’d go there again and again!
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsJan 21, 2026
Jennifer,
Thank you for taking the time to leave a positive review for your visit to our Bellevue location. It is great that Elizabeth was able to create such a wonderful experience for you. She has been a great addition to our team and I hope she can continue to treat our customers in this manner. Thank you again for the great review and Elizabeth looks forward to working with you again.
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
CU
Customer
survey response
Informed service reps with a willingness to explain. Appear to be very honest.
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsNov 10, 2025
Thank you for taking the time to leave a positive review. We are thrilled that our staff members were informed and willing to explain our process. We pride ourselves in being honest and transparent when dealing with our customer's belongings.
We thank you again for taking the time to leave a review and we hope to assist you again in the future.
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
JD
Joeph D.
Estate Valuation
We worked Bellevue Rare Coins to help us with an estate valuation. We worked with Zach and he was outstanding! He was professional, proactive, thorough, and reliable. I highly recommend Bellevue Rare Coins, and especially Zach, for any work you may need. Thank you Zach!
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsOct 29, 2025
Joeph Dobler,
Conducting an estate valuation requires a high degree of trust and expertise, and we are so pleased that Zach was able to provide you with the thorough and reliable service you deserved. It's fantastic to hear that his professionalism and proactive approach made a challenging process easier for you.
Thank you for choosing Bellevue Rare Coins and for specifically recommending Zach. We value your business and hope to be of service again in the future!
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
MT
M. T.
I visited the Lynnwood store yesterday…
I visited the Lynnwood store yesterday and was so pleased with the experience. I was treated with respect and patience. I was helped by Joe, who explained every step of valuation. I would definitely recommend this location and I look forward to going again.
M. Taylor
Response from Bellevue Rare CoinsAug 15, 2025
M.Taylor,
Thank you for taking the time to leave a positive review about your experience in our Lynnwood location. We’re so glad Joe was able to walk you through each step with respect and patience. He does a great job assisting customers and leads by example when evaluating items. Your recommendation means the world to us, and we look forward to welcoming you back again soon.
Andrew G
Regional Manager
Bellevue Rare Coins
