At BEAUTY PIE, our mission is to make you feel like a kid in a cosmetics candy shop. To bring you the fairy tale. To deliver the absolute best in beauty nonstop, at prices so amazing, even a splurge is a steal. Because there should be no guilt in getting gorgeous.
Beauty Pie™ - USA (beautypie.com) has 5,853 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
Also known as
beautypie.com
Website
beautypie.com
Category
Cosmetics & Makeup
Location
New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 14% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Meh at best
The candles are nice, although not that much cheaper than the name brand option. I bought two of the highest-ranking best sellers and have been using them for a month and they don't pack near the punch of my higher-end options. Plus, after factoring in the membership fee and shipping, it's not that much cheaper and not nearly as potent. I'm canceling as soon as I get out of the 3-month required membership.
Response from Beauty Pie™ - USAAug 13, 2020
Thank you for your review, please accept our apologies that some of the product you tried didn't have the results you were hoping for. We are always happy to help with recommendations that may be better suited to your skin concerns at Customer Service, if you send us an email on [email protected].
CU
customer
The products were bad
The products were bad, some were broken, and I can't cancel my membership.
Response from Beauty Pie™ - USAAug 13, 2020
Thank you for your review. I'm sorry to hear that some of the products you received were faulty, this doesn't sound like our usual quality therefore please may you email a photo to us for further review. Please be advised that we have a three month minimum term on all monthly memberships, once you've completed this we will be happy to process a cancellation for you at Customer Service on [email protected].
CU
customer
Not recommended
I was so excited to try Beauty Pie but sadly I am disappointed by the quality of the products, the value for the price you pay and the poor customer service. I do not recommend membership.
Response from Beauty Pie™ - USAAug 13, 2020
Thank you for your review. I'm sorry to hear you were disappointed with your overall BEAUTY PIE experience, I will be sure to pass your valued feedback onto the relevant teams to take on board for the future.
RA
Rachel
The missing star is not from the lack…
The missing star is not from the lack of product quality. I think the quality of products is great. It’s more for the set up of the program. I don’t mind paying $99 for an annual membership due, but the monthly $100 spending limit doesn’t go very far. Many of the products, or at least the ones that interest me, are between $60-125. So basically you only get 1-2 products per month for the membership due ($99/12 months), plus the product cost, plus the almost $9 in shipping.
If you buy all very high end brands at full retail price, sure it’s a bargain. But if for most of us you buy mid level brands and often wait for sales, it starts to not feel as the amazing deal they claim. For example, they claim full retail price for one of their lip stick type products is $30 when sold by other brands. Never in my life have I paid $30 for a lipstick type product. I get that very very high end luxury brands may charge this, but I doubt most Americans would pay for this. So right there, 1 lip product and a 1/3 of your spending limit is gone, now to find another item under $60. Or wait a whole month to pool your spending funds. Then you pay almost $9 in shipping, and not for 2 day shipping mind you. Come on Beauty pie, there are WAY cheaper shipping options out there, ask any other subscription box company. Still make us pay the shipping fine, but I know it’s not always $9!
If the monthly spending limit was not capped so low and the shipping was more competitive, it would feel like a much different experience. Not sure I will renew when my annual membership ends.
MA
Marney
Color me impressed...
I just received my first Beauty Pie order and I am really impressed with the products. I love the lip gloss and the makeup palette that I ordered! Although the lotion is a bit more fragrant than I usually buy, it feels great and isn't overwhelming.
CU
customer
LOVE ALL YOUR PRODUCTS>
LOVE ALL YOUR PRODUCTS>
PA
Pawel
Beauty Pie is the best !!!
Beauty Pie is the best !!!
CU
customer
Excellent Product choice and quality
Excellent Product choice and quality, coupled with efficient deliveries and great customer service. My personal favourite is the super retinol skin Care range.