AutoRentals.com puts the Renter First in Car Rentals. By presenting the most comprehensive search results for your car rental search in innovative and easy to view results, renters can quickly choose the perfect car at the best price!
AutoRentals.com (autorentals.com) has 289 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.8 out of 5.
Website
autorentals.com
Category
Activities & Tours
Location
Port Washington, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 13% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Hello Richard,
I understand your concern about a $1500 deposit. Please understand that Autorentals.com does not set the amount of the deposit. Each supplier on our site has their own local rules and policies for each of their locations. Autorentals.com does not set the policies or have influence over them. You do always have the option to reach out to our customer service team for assistance with a car rental. We can help you search for rentals with specific needs. For example, mileage requirements, accessories and low deposits. We are here for you every step of your rental journey. We appreciate your business!
RU
Rudy
Disappointed Customer Kimberly is NOT Friendly
Kimberly is not friendly at all. Did not want to make simple
Changes to our reservation. Extremely contentious! The guy next to her was better and seems to not mind to be at work. Kimberly did not want our business she treated us like “Why The Heck Are YOU here? We were a major inconvenience to her day! Absolutely disgusting 🤮 as we re customers paying for a service. No free handouts just trying to get a rental car. Wish we went to Fox next door.
Response from AutoRentals.comSep 18, 2026
Hello Ruthie,
I am so sorry to hear of your experience! However, it sounds like your issues were with your supplier and not Autorentals.com. Autorentals.com is your booking agency and the company who actually provides the rental car is the supplier. In your case, that would be Economy Rent a Car. Please know that when you rent a vehicle through Autorentals.com, we are there with you every step of your journey. If you have any issue while making your reservation or during your rental period, our customer service department is just a phone call or email away and ready to help. Our customers matter to us and our goal is for every customer to have a great experience.
I will be reaching out to Economy Rent a Car regarding your experience. It is our expectation that our suppliers maintain the same high level of customer care as we do at Autorentals.com. We hope you will come back to Autorentals.com for your future car rental needs. We appreciate your business!
JA
Jacquelyn
Wrong address listed for car rental
I booked a car rental and the location is listed as the Saint Pete airport. But after booking I went back and looked again and the address associated with the Saint Pete/Clearwater airport is actually the address for the Tampa airport-which is 30 minutes away.
Response from AutoRentals.comSep 11, 2026
Hello Jacquelyn,
I am so sorry to hear of your experience. I duplicated your search and got the same results. I have reached out to our tech team who will reach out to the supplier to get this rectified. The information we relay to you in your confirmation email comes to us directly from the supplier. We very much appreciate you bringing this to our attention so that we can gets this fixed asap. I would be happy to assist you in creating another reservation. Your experience matters to us. We want all of our customers to know we are here for them every step of their travel experience from booking the reservation to completing their travels. You matter to us!
TT
Tarnisha T.
Booking process
Booking process
PP
Pierre P.
Change in terms between voucher and booking
'I booked my rental through AutoRentals.com based on the terms and price clearly stated in my rental voucher. However, when I arrived at Avis to collect the vehicle, I was presented with terms and additional charges that were substantially different from what was stated in the original voucher.
As a result, I had no practical choice at the counter but to pay additional money out of my own pocket in order to obtain the vehicle.
The biggest problem is not simply that Avis charged additional fees. My issue is that the conditions I was faced with at pickup did not match the rental agreement/voucher I had received from AutoRentals.com when I made the booking. If important conditions or mandatory charges can change between the booking and the pickup counter, then the advertised price and voucher are extremely misleading from a customer's perspective.
I booked through AutoRentals.com expecting the voucher to reflect the actual terms of my rental. Instead, I ended up paying considerably more than I had budgeted for and was left to deal with the discrepancy at the Avis counter myself.
This was a very disappointing experience, and I would strongly recommend that customers carefully verify every single condition and potential charge directly with the rental company before relying on an AutoRentals.com voucher.
I have kept the original voucher and documentation showing what was offered at the time of booking, as well as the additional charges I was required to pay at pickup. I expect AutoRentals.com to explain why the terms presented by Avis differed from the terms in my voucher and to reimburse the additional costs that resulted from this discrepancy.
Based on this experience, I would not use AutoRentals.com again.'
Response from AutoRentals.comSep 1, 2026
Hello Pierre,
I am so sorry to hear of your experience! This is not the type of experience we wish for any of our customers. I do want you to know that I researched your issue and first of all, I want to thank you for reaching out to us in Customer Service regarding the issue before coming to Trust Pilot. We appreciate you giving us the opportunity to assist. We value our customers and will always try to do the right thing for the customer, in any situation.
The delay in resolving this is not on our part. Our agent has reached out to Avis multiple times and, as recently as last week, was told they would get back to us within 15-30 days. We have expedited your case to their upper management and we will keep on this case till we get a resolution for you. We will not forget you or abandon this issue. You matter to us!
BO
boflit
below average, recommend to avoid.
Initial booking online was straightforward. However, I realized a week before that I had not been offered insurance for my european hire, but had for my England hire. I had to take up insurance when I arrived to collect my car which cost me significantly more.
I ordered a Renault Captur as I wanted a small car for the small Italian towns we were going to, instead, I got a Ford Focus estate, a longer car, wider car than I was wanting, heavier too, yet it came with a piddly 1.0L engine and wheezed its way up italian hills. Was not a pleasant experience.
I needed to call autorentals due to an error on collection, the phone numbers on my hire voucher were disconnected.
In the end what should have cost me $2300 approx, cost me $3500.
Do not use autorentals.com, they will disapoint and cost you dearly.
CP
Chris P.
While friendly staff and easy pick up…
While friendly staff and easy pick up from lisbon, have had a bad experience dropping car off due to miscommunication and with extra costs. I decided to book via AutoRentals after finding a good price for a rental one way from Lisbon to Porto. Price seemed much better than nearest competition, so expected some other costs upon arrival in Lisbon. The extra charges included security deposit, and paid for extra cover to reduce this, and for a device to go through tolls. Total cost came to about the same as competitors for about the same deal, so was happy enough. At the time, everything seemed OK, staff at Lisbon office helped answer questions about drop off at Porto airport, and were quite specific of the time I could drop the car off there.
However, on arrival at the Porto office, I was told that there was an extra charge of 140EUR for one way drop off. This was not mentioned at all on pick up. They explained the problem had arisen because the booking from autorentals had been from Lisbon-Lisbon (despite my email and receipt stating Lis-Porto). My contract I signed on closer examination did state lisbon-lisbon, so perhaps I should've mentioned something on pick up in Lisbon before signing, but the fact that I had had a frank discussion about my plans at the time, and was giving explicit verbal information about the drop off at Porto meant that I did not forsee any issues.
I was told to pay the extra charge and a new contract with the additional 140EUR was made up (stating one way fee and Lisb-Porto). I was advised to discuss with AutoRentals about the error. At this point I was obviously upset, as not only did this seem like a hidden charge, but if I was told this upfront, I almost certainly would have gone for an alternative, likely cheaper service, and that choice was taken from me by the service I was provided and the communication.
Autorentals have now come back and stated that there is nothing they will do, stating that in the additional info at the bottom of SurPrice's terms, a one way fee may be included due in pick up. Well, maybe it should have been, but certainly shouldn't be added at the end, and made untransparant. My advice is if booking, book directly via SurPrice, and maybe over the phone, and check the contract closely.
VP
Vinay P.
Rented in Miami
Rented in Miami, FL thru AutoRental Comp from Corpusa, on 3947 NW 26th st. A car on 11/20/2017. The NISSAN Versa has Tires Bald & with Air Leaks &was Banged up. Weak battery so with head lights on lights inside car gets very deem. Charged $432.39 to my Credit Card for Rental thru 11/25/2017& I returned car on 11/24/2017 9.30AM & Agent Rep. Drop me off At Miami Airport. I was unable to go or use car as it was NOT reliable & had to put Air in Tires everyday & Paid $20 for Air & Fix A Flat can. People were nice but speak little English. I think I should get my Money back.