Athenastyle Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of athenastyle.com

AthenastyleReviews of athenastyle.com

3.486 reviews
Clothing & Underwear
39899 Balentine Drive Suite 200, Newark, California

Directions Website

Athenastyle

About Athenastyle

At Athena Style, we have been a trusted supplier of sports team jerseys for over five years, serving thousands of happy customers. We offer a wide range of player jerseys as well as custom name and number jerseys to help you represent your favorite team or personalize your own look. (Please note that custom orders may take longer to process, so we appreciate your patience!)Although our base is in California, USA, we operate warehouses worldwide to reduce costs and provide the best quality jerseys at reasonable prices. Whether you're looking for jerseys for players, teams, or yourself, visit athenastyle.com to find your perfect fit!(Please note that custom orders may take longer to process, so we appreciate your patience!)

Athenastyle (athenastyle.com) has 86 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.4 out of 5.

Also known as: athenastyle.com
Website: athenastyle.com
Category: Clothing & Underwear
Location: Newark, California
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 69% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Clothing & Underwear, California

Directions Write a review

Athenastyle reviews

Showing 4 reviews with 2 stars · Clear filters

Nick W.
May 15, 2026
Trying to exchange jersey for a…
Trying to exchange jersey for a different size. Emailed about it. It’s been a week. No response.
Response from AthenastyleMay 17, 2026
Dear Nick, We're very sorry for the frustration and truly apologize for the inconvenience. We have actually replied to your email multiple times regarding your size exchange request, but it's possible that our messages may have been filtered into your spam/junk folder. We absolutely want to help resolve this for you and are still happy to assist with the exchange. Please check your spam folder or feel free to contact us again so we can take care of this as quickly as possible. Your satisfaction is very important to us. Thank you so much and have a good day
Report
James M.
Apr 18, 2025
Poor quality Received my 2 jerseys
Received my 2 jerseys, the orange used on the stitched lettering is a faded orange. The orioles patch is not a patch it’s almost like a thick screen print. Lose thread on most of the buttons and other stitched areas. Xxl is more like an xl. On a plus the jerseys arrived a week before I figured they would after I found out they were coming from out of country.
Response from AthenastyleApr 21, 2025
Thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear about the issues with the jerseys and truly appreciate you bringing this to our attention. We haven't received any emails regarding this order, so we kindly ask you to contact us through our contact form or at [email protected]. Please include your order number and, if possible, high-resolution photos of the concerns mentioned — this will help us resolve the issue more quickly and accurately. We’re here to help and want to make things right!
Report
Scott D.
Jun 4, 2024
Size is severely off
The item came in the approximate time they said I would receive it. The jersey itself was of average quality, appears to be everything I asked for. The size is severely off. I am a big guy, and I order from other sites, and 4XL always fits me. This 4XL is not even close. it's more like a 2XL, so be warned on what size you order if you are a big/tall person like myself
Response from AthenastyleFeb 18, 2025
We’re sorry to hear about the sizing issue with your jersey. We take full responsibility for ensuring the correct size, and if the wrong size was sent, we will immediately arrange a replacement—there is no refusal to this request. Please contact us again at [email protected] with your order details so we can check and resolve this for you as soon as possible.
Report
John in D.
Mar 5, 2024
Beware of ordering from Athenastyle...
I have used this company before and actually received my items only after 6 months! That's the only reason I will give them 2 stars instead of 1. I tried them once more to see if it was just a fluke. After months, my items never arrived. The "customer no-service" is a joke! They set up addresses in the US but the items are coming from China so there is no one you can reach other than leaving a message on their website with your order number and good luck if you get a response. Be aware of Athenastyle. They suck.
Response from AthenastyleFeb 18, 2025
We’re sorry for any confusion regarding your order. Please provide the order ID of your second order to [email protected], and we will check again. Regarding your first order, it was canceled in late October/ November 2023 due to a payment error, and we had contacted you to confirm that the refund was processed automatically. When you reached out again, we were willing to resend the item as a free gift since the cancellation email may not have reached you correctly. We truly appreciate your patience and hope you can check again. We’re happy to assist further.
Report