Pet Supplies online with same-day order processing and shipping. Shop for supplies for dogs, cats, birds, fish, small animals and other pets. Compare our pet supply prices.
ArcataPet.com (arcatapet.com) has 529 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
Website
arcatapet.com
Category
Pet Stores
Location
Arcata, California
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company has not replied to any reviews yet.
Latest
Most recent review: November 2025.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Easy and quick first (and now second) experience(s) with Arcata Pet
My companion was helping me locate the Water Hole water dish, and found Arcata Pet.com. She said that Arcata is a place she used to live near, and when she found this store online, suggested i order from here. No problems. Quick. Great price. Cheers!
Update: as of January 2, 2016, my second order with Arcata Pet was just the same. Uneventful is good.
LI
Linda
I appreciated the confirmations, and the goose toys my schnauzer carries every where.
I was pleased with the service and product the first time I ordered, and returned for other items.
JB
Julia B.
My Dog's BFF!!!
I was having a hard time finding my Chihuahua's favorite toy (black/white latex squeeky shoe). I originally bought it at Petco who claimed that they always carry the same toys for your pets, while they did for several years we have not been able to get it for the last 2 years, they told us the manufacturer stop making it. In the meantime we spent a lot of money buying different squeeky toys for my dog but alas she would not touch or chase them and we feared she was getting depressed because she did not seem to want to play. When I decided to go on line ArcataPet.com was the only one to carry a squeeky toy that looks anything like my dogs toy. I ordered and sure enough she now is back to her oldself she greets me at the door with her best friend forever ready to play!!!!
My Chihuahua and the Benskin family Thank you,
Julia Benskin
BH
Bheki
Prong Collar arrived super fast!!!
I needed it "yesterday" and my new prong collar came just in time for my scheduled dog walk. Very impressed with the quick service and quality of the product. Thank you ArcataPet!
VS
Val S.
You saved me from a grumpy cat.
My Sasha cat loves to play with little foam balls but they have to be replaced periodically because of claw holes. My local pet stores have stopped carrying the ones she likes. Sasha was down to her last ball and was reminding me (loudly) that it was time for replacements. I searched the internet but every other store wanted an outrageous price for cheap foam balls. I found the best prices and service right here. Give them a shot.
JI
jim
Faster than driving to Petco...well almost
I am nursing a little piggy back to health and the vet recommended Critical Care. My current supply was running low and my schedule was very busy. I didn't know when I would have time to run down to the local Petco to purchase it. I decided to try Arcata and order it by mail. If delivery was slow, there was still time to drop and run to Petco. Turns out, it was delivered almost the next day. Wow. I am impressed and my little piggy is quite happy too (at my vet's advise, I mix it with a bit of vegetable baby food. Now my piggy waits for her next meal. wasn't that way before)..
KJ
Kimberly J.
Had exactly what I wanted!!
My little pug, Spencer loves the small soccer balls that squeak and I can't find them anywhere. I was so happy to find them so I bought 6! We will be ordering again!!
JO
Johanna
Hard to find items, Hard to beat service!
One of my Redsided Eclectus Parrot boys has been breaking his food bowls in an attempt to impress upon me to feed him his favorites each time, every time :) UH OH, as his cage model and bowls were discontinued and no longer available.
Aracata Pet to the rescue, with the hard to find bowls. But they were out of stock! I called the store and was told that they'd be back in stock soon. By the time I'd hung up, I already had an email from Arcata Pet telling me that the bowls had arrived in stock. I ordered them that evening and they were shipped out the next day. Arrived a few states North in a couple days, just in time before Bosco broke the last bowl.
I also ordered some AviTec supplements and Harrison's Bird Food - all were fresh and everything arrived in perfect condition, neatly and carefully packed.
The email "in stock again" notification and online ordering worked smoothly, simply, flawlessly. Painless online ordering and check-out. Fast, economical, and safe shipping.
The folks at the store were friendly, warm, and helpful, and I felt as though I was ordering from "extended family" for my "avian family". I will be ordering from Arcata Pet's great selection of supplies, toys, food, health items and more again. Happy Birds, Happy Mama, thanks Arcata Pet!
Johanna