Annuity GatorWe believe the way people buy annuities should be radically improved for all Americans. Researching and buying an annuity should be simple, transparent, and enjoyable. Annuity Gator’s mission is to make that happen.
Annuity Gator (annuitygator.com) has 544 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Investments & Wealth · NEW YORK, New York
Excellent
Investments & Wealth · Seal Beach, California
Excellent
Investments & Wealth · New York, New York
Excellent
Investments & Wealth · Conyers, Georgia
Excellent
Showing 32 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
James J.
Annuity Gator and their associated companies utilize third party lead generators to provide leads to their agents. These third-party lead generators violate the TCPA by calling those that have registered their number and do not wish to received telemarketing calls. I will let as many people know as possible via reviews on the internet. Scammy marketing tactics!
Michael G.
Had an appointment set up with an ELI from Annuity gator to discuss annuities. I was on the zoom call and also tried to attempt connection via phone call for phone number provided. Zoom called timed me out. They never got on the phone line. I am going to stick to buying annuities from people I know.
Response from Annuity GatorMar 26, 2025
Hi Michael, We’re genuinely sorry for missing the call. That’s not how we do things, and we completely understand your frustration. We missed the mark, and we’re truly sorry for the inconvenience that caused. It looks like Eli was able to reach you afterward to offer his apology, but we know that first impressions matter. If you’re ever open to reconnecting in the future, we’d appreciate the opportunity to continue the conversation. Wishing you all the best with your retirement planning.
Judy R.
Great experience. Very knowledgeable and no pressure. Give them 5 stars.
Craig
You must be kidding. How do you rate your service when I received none. Promised phone call never happened.
Response from Annuity GatorJun 4, 2021
Hi Craig. We are sorry to hear about your experience. We've notified your advisor so he will likely be reaching back out to you again soon in order to reschedule you call and assist with any questions you have. You can always also request to be contacted again at this link: http://www.annuitygator.com/contact
Garry
Appointment was not kept as promised after I reserved time for phone conference. Failure at that stage shows unconcerned employee toward customer and I certainly was not offered anything for the waste of my time. If you fail that early in the investment process how much bigger would the failure be should I have given the second chance. My money and I believe to be the best decision to not do business with a company that doesn't care. My message to annuity gator is never contact me unless you are willing to receive hostile conversation from a pissed off customer!
Response from Annuity GatorJun 4, 2021
Hi Garry. We are sorry to hear about your experience. We've notified your advisor so she will likely be reaching back out to you again soon in order to reschedule you call and assist with any questions you have. You can always also request to be contacted again at this link: http://www.annuitygator.com/contact
Duane
They scheduled my appointment but failed to keep it on a holiday weekend because someone didn't remember they were closed.
Response from Annuity GatorJun 4, 2021
Hi Duane. We are sorry to hear about your experience. We've notified your advisor so he will likely be reaching back out to you again soon in order to reschedule you call and assist with any questions you have. You can always also request to be contacted again at this link: http://www.annuitygator.com/contact
Barb
Annuity Gator sent 3 emails to confirm my phone appointment, but when the time came, their agent totally forgot about it. After waiting 20 minutes, I called in to inquire what was going on, and then about 1/2 hour later, Brian called acting as if nothing were wrong. When I advised him he missed the appointment, he gave me a lame excuse of different time zones. He was also going to provide some information for me the next week. Never happened. Don’t trust this company!
Response from Annuity GatorJun 4, 2021
Hi Barb. We are sorry to hear about your experience. We've notified your advisor so he will likely be reaching back out to you again soon in order to follow-up with answers to the questions discussed. You can always also request to be contacted again at this link: http://www.annuitygator.com/contact
Ann
Agent inexperienced and selfish. Did not listen to what I wanted only focused on what would yield him a higher commission
Response from Annuity GatorFeb 5, 2021
Hello Ann. We are sorry to hear of your experience. Our team has reached out to you to rectify the situation. You may also email us directly at [email protected] for a reply.