We believe the way people buy annuities should be radically improved for all Americans. Researching and buying an annuity should be simple, transparent, and enjoyable. Annuity Gator’s mission is to make that happen.
Annuity Gator (annuitygator.com) has 544 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Also known as
annuitygator.com
Website
annuitygator.com
Category
Investments & Wealth
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 6% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I was looking for some where to put some of my retirement funds that would not be subject to the stock market swings. I reached out to Annuity Gator for advice and options. I was very fortunate to have Toney listen to my concerns and take time to discuss some options for some of my 401k funds. He took the time to meet with me and help me find a good fit. I am very pleased with Annuity Gator and Toney for all they did for me. I will continue to use them for funding options.
CH
Charlie H.
I needed to change my Annuity so I…
I needed to change my Annuity so I called Joshua
and once again he came to my rescue. He switched me to a "FIXED DEFFERED ANNUITY" and now I will receive a monthly income for life, that means that no mater how long I live, from this day forward I will get a monthly check. Now I am all set. Thanks again Josh!!
TB
Thomas B.
Barbara Halperin was very thorough and…
Barbara Halperin was very thorough and deliberate in finding just the right annuity for me. She stayed in touch me on a regular basis over a 6-month period until I was totally confident with my decision. I now have a guaranteed income for life that also keeps pace with inflation with no loss in value. Let the good times roll !!. PS. During the whole process, Barbara made me feel like a valued friend, and not just a run of the mill client.
JE
John E.
Excellent experience and outcome
Working with Tom Scheurer was really excellent. He listened to my objectives, answered my questions, embraced my need to understand the deep details, and ultimately helped deliver a great annuity solution.
JS
James S.
Tom was fantastic
Tom was fantastic. He was well informed, responsive and helpful. I would highly recommend him to anyone interested in annuities.
SL
Steve L.
So pleased I purchased 2 annuities
I was paired with an awesome financial advisor, Joshua Schlinsky. I was looking for 2 annuities, 1 to satisfy an estate trust obligation and another to replace one of my non-performing ones. In my first 2-3 virtual meetings with Mr. Schlinsky I was surprised that there was no "selling", but only questions about my goals, objectives, and needs. Only after what I felt to be very careful consideration of both of these needs by Mr. Schlinsky did he offer specific annuity solutions. The annuity for the trust worked out perfect, funding a monthly income for life to one of the trustees, and the one for my personal situation nailed it, exactly what I needed to get out of a non-performing annuity and recoup a rather significant loss. Once I decided to go with these annuities, Mr. Schlinsky's office was most helpful in assisting with the application process, as well as follow up to make sure all was as expected. This was a very pleasant, no pressure experience, in my opinion not typical of this industry, but greatly welcomed.
SJ
Sue J.
Very pleasant and knowledgeable
Very pleasant and knowledgeable
CU
customer
Jacob Hall is awesome
Jacob Hall is awesome. I highly recommend his services! Jacob really cares about us and what our retirement goals are. He spent hours with us, educating us and helping us pick our annuity. We feel confident that we have made the right decision on the Annuity we chose and Jacob of course. I’ve honestly never seen better service from anyone than Jacob has given us. Thank you.