We believe the way people buy annuities should be radically improved for all Americans. Researching and buying an annuity should be simple, transparent, and enjoyable. Annuity Gator’s mission is to make that happen.
Annuity Gator (annuitygator.com) has 544 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Also known as
annuitygator.com
Website
annuitygator.com
Category
Investments & Wealth
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 6% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Doing business with Bruce Colwell has been a wonderful experience. He is incredibly thorough, competent and knowledgeable. He walked us through the annuity maze and clarified all the details in a manner which made us feel confident we had selected the correct product for our needs. I would highly recommend Bruce to others for their annuity/ financial needs.
JR
John R.
Annuity gator gave me useful…
Annuity gator gave me useful information and then put me in touch with a professional advisor Rick Kelly who was able to explain to me the advantages of an annuity.
He talked me through all the difficult to understand language of an annuity contract and led me to the types of annuities that I was looking for.
JO
Jorge O.
My Experience with Annuity Gator
Well maintained communication throughout the process. Good exchange of information during meeting sessions. A good experience overall.
PA
Paul
Very satisfied
Very satisfied. Really helpful through the whole process. Answered all my questions. Walked me through the provided information. No High pressure sales. Very informative.Highly recommend Cal.
MS
May S.
The rare gem you can trust
I worked with big firm financial advisors recommended by an acquaintance in the financial sector. The feeling they left me with was that they'd say anything to get their hands on my retirement funds to trade and earn commissions. Just another amount in a big machine, without any real interest in my situation or goals.
So I called Annuity Gator for a second opinion. My intention was not to work with them yet.
However, the minute I started talking things over with Mr. Robb Rothrock, I knew I found someone I could trust with my retirement. Robb asked questions about my specific goals, risk tolerance, and minimum needs and hoped for best best-case scenario. Then he proceeded to answer all my questions and concerns with a realistic outlook on market performance.
Once he had a good idea about the specifics of my situation, he went off and prepared a comprehensive list of options for us to go over in a second call. He included details about each company such as rating, performance during down markets, and how to protect myself from those. We even started talking about options in addition to annuities and through it all, Robb handled my retirement fund decisions as a partner, but more importantly, he handled it with an eye on the fact that it is the financial stability of a person, not just another account.
I don't have adequate words to express what a relief it was to be working with someone so competent about all the details of his sector, willing to go the extra mile to get answers that are beyond his immediate area of expertise, and who I know that I can trust his advice to be with my interest first in mind.
Robb is someone who acts and works as an embodiment of his fiduciary responsibility.
My deepest gratitude.
CG
Christopher G.
Great experience with Rebekah Hart
Rebekah Hart was the licensed annuity investigator that I worked with and she was great. She communicated in a timely fashion and was professional. She helped me lock in a good annuity on the last day of a promotional period. I would definitely recommend her to others.
EJ
Edward J. H.
I found Bruce Colwell on the internet
I found Bruce Colwell on the internet. The name Annuity Gator seemed kind of hokey, but the other annuity offers I was getting from the big well-knowns were not meeting my goals in an income annuity. Bruce found us the best rate and the best rated Insurance company. It matched our requirements perfectly.
What did I like about Bruce?
He is honest and communicative every step of the way. It's exactly like having an inside friend in the Annuity business!!! We liked him so much that we bought a another deferred annuity from him and he is now our agent for medicare too meticulously paring the details of these advantage plans so that we saved $1728 a year plus we got better coverage and no co-pays. We are lucky that we found him!!!
KS
Kathy Serago H.
My husband and I have been meeting with…
My husband and I have been meeting with Bruce for the past few months. Bruce has helped us with 3 different investments. Bruce has been very informative in answering all our question. We belive that Bruce has lead us on the correct path for our future needs.