not smart enough to print as ordered, messed up the rotation, didnt check after they manually changes the facing, shipped a garbage product, promised to redo. LITERALLY printed the same shit, with oversight, warped product, utter garbage, AVOID AT ALL COST
MV
Mo V S.
Custom Sleeves so bad it felt like an insult
Don't know about their other products, but do not buy custom sleeves from these guys. Incredibly thin (corners damage easily), sticky, they also stink to high heavens (even after airing them out for multiple days) - and paint keeps peeling of the edges. It even stuck to some of my cards and will be a pain to remove without damaging them.
On top of that, they charge about double than comparable companies and nickle and dime you for everything. The most brazen part was their "premium editing" service for your uploaded image they tried to push on me at every opportunity (as a payed add on of course). Turns out this premium editing is just AI upscaling (likely waifu2x, which is free).
Low quality, high prizes, brazen business practices, stay away.
SH
SH
Don't do it.
Don't. First they say you that there has to be a 2 cm edge due to cutting. Then they will cut away the edge that you purposely built into your design, just to stretch the remaining mat so that the result will be distorted. And finally, they will not even cut it straight so that your mat will have some bearing.
TR
Thomas R.
Poor quality!
I received the mat about a month after I received it. It was not as I had expected. It was out of alignment and crooked with a lot of the graphics missing. It was totally unusable for my purposes. I threw it away. Will never order from them again.
Response from Your PlaymatApr 3, 2026
Hi Thomas,
I’m really sorry to hear about your experience, and I also want to apologize for the delay in getting back to you here. I’ve been looking into your case to understand what may have gone wrong.
What you described with the alignment and missing graphics is definitely not the standard we aim for, and I take that seriously. If something like this happens, I always want to review it properly and make it right.
Please try to understand that photos of issues like this are the only way for me to clearly verify what went wrong :/ If we can verify the problem, we take immediate action, whether that’s a replacement or another solution. Since the playmat was thrown away, it makes it harder for me to fully assess the issue and understand exactly what happened on our end.
That said, I’ll still reach out to you directly to see if we can find a way to solve this anyway!
Best,
Julian T.
Your Playmat Support
JO
John
Do not trust this company
I ordered custom card sleeves a full month before a Magic tournament. When I didn't receive any shipping updates, I reached out multiple times over several weeks asking for a status update. Every message went unanswered. When they finally responded, it was to tell me they couldn't fulfill the order. By then it was too late to order from anyone else.
They issued a refund, but a refund just gives me back money for a product they never delivered. It doesn't solve the fact that I'm now going into a tournament without custom sleeves. If they had responded to even one of my follow-ups, I would have had time to go elsewhere.
This was my first time ordering from this company and I will never order again. There are plenty of places to get custom sleeves and playmats. Do not trust these guys!
Response from Your PlaymatMar 3, 2026
Hi John,
I am truly sorry we let you down. We know how much prep goes into a tournament and failing to get your sleeves to you while leaving your messages unanswered is completely on us.
To be transparent, we had some extreme weather that shut down our operations and we just didn't communicate that to you fast enough to let you find another option. A refund doesn't fix the fact that you're heading into your tournament without your gear, and we feel terrible about that.
I’ve just sent you an email so we can try and fix this situation to the best of our abilities.
We’d love the chance to earn your trust back.
Julian T.
Your Playmat
LL
Luca L.
I placed an order in August (Unacceptable customer support and unfulfilled promises…
I placed an order in August (order #83912) that included a custom playmat and 120 custom sleeves.
The playmat was finally delivered on November 11th, but the sleeves were missing.
On November 11th, a customer support agent (Alexandra) offered either a refund or a replacement shipment for the missing sleeves. On November 14th, the same agent explicitly confirmed that a replacement shipment would be sent using a different courier and that tracking information would follow.
Despite these assurances:
the sleeves were never delivered
no valid tracking number was ever provided
months later, I only received automated replies with incorrect and outdated tracking information referring to an item already delivered
As of February, more than five months after the order and nearly three months after the promised replacement, the issue is still unresolved.
This order was intended as a birthday gift, and the lack of follow-through after repeated guarantees made the situation particularly frustrating.
Delays can happen, but false reassurances and the absence of real human follow-up are unacceptable. I am still waiting for the refund that was already offered by their own support team.
Very disappointed. I cannot recommend this company based on my experience.
SS
Syr S.
Yeah this site's garbage and scamming…
Yeah this site's garbage and scamming now. Apparently they're strapping for cash as they decided not to fulfil my order, delete my account and never deliver my tracking number.
Like damn, that big a deal? I just wanted some damn custom sleeves, it's not that deep.
Warning's out there. Use Yourplaymat at your own risk. This site's not the same as it used to be. The are way better and actual honest choices out there.
AN
Anon
Cannot ship any orders but still accepting new ones?
I had ordered some custom sleeves about 2 months ago, and there was radio silence afterwards. Sent an email after 2 months asking about the status and received a canned reply message saying they're sorry for the delay and would give a discount code for another purchase.
About a day later received a support message stating, and I quote, "We’ve received an update from our production team that they’re currently unable to ship any orders due to the ongoing issues with shipping charges and taxes."
If your company cannot ship ANY orders, that's a huge issue. Why is this not mass communicated to all of your current customers? Why is the website not informing the customer that if you purchase from their site, you will not be getting your order? Such a scam to take money and not deliver. So I receive my refund and never do business with them again.