The Alloy MarketReviews of thealloymarket.com

Alloy appeared at first to be a scam. Their initial offer to me was a low ball, about $250 below what I would expect. I spoke to their rep, who claimed they had made a mistake and would offer more. Later, a second rep called me and I felt a lot better about that conversation. I believe that rep #1 was inexperienced and made some customer interaction mistakes. Based on conversation #2, being fair minded, I decided to amend my initial review here. I believe that alloy could improve communication misunderstandings by stating up front what they will pay based on your initial inputs to them on the condition that when they receive the item, and it is verified, you will get the price offered. Also, it would be better to have their offer email contain not just an "Accept" button, but also a "Decline" button, so you dont need to speak with them (they are few in number) to decline the offer and retrieve your goods. There are lots of scammers out there and ultra caution is warranted when dealing for the first time. These measures would alleviate anxiety on both ends, save time and assuage any fears that they are not reputable.

Be prepared to be lowballed. The first offer was at 57% of spot price. I declined. Within a couple of minutes, here comes offer two. A hundred dollars more. Acceptable at 76% of spot price. DON'T be afraid to say no and wait for another offer

I love Amy that works there, I’ve dealt with them before. I was hoping to get more than they offered, this is my second time. I felt like my stuff both times was worth more, but you can’t argue about getting something for your stuff, you’ll never get what it’s worth, but it’s fine. I use them cause I like Amy she’s been good to me, and I hope this company has a great business, but this is the last time I can use them and I’m out of jewelry and really feel if I could of sold it myself, I would probably got more money, but these are nice people, especially Amy, I wish they could of done better