Susan Jewelry is a customer focused online store dedicated to offering stylish, affordable jewelry pieces designed to complement everyday looks and special moments.We pride ourselves on providing a wide variety of elegant designs from rings and necklaces to earrings while maintaining accessible pricing for our customers. Our goal is to make beautiful jewelry available to everyone without compromising on style.At Susan Jewelry, customer satisfaction is at the heart of what we do. We continuously improve our products, processes, and support to ensure a smooth and reliable shopping experience.We appreciate every customer who chooses to shop with us and supports our journey.
Susan Jewelry (susanjewelryco.com) has 327 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.8 out of 5.
Also known as
susanjewelryco.com
Website
susanjewelryco.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Location
Santa Fe
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 87% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Love my new ring 🩷 Delivered as promised. I will definitely buy another piece!
Response from Susan JewelryMay 26, 2026
Yay, we love hearing this! 🥰🪪 We're so happy your ring arrived right on time and that you're loving it! That pink heart says it all! 💗
We can't wait to have you back for your next piece there are so many beautiful things waiting for you! Thank you so much for your support, it truly means everything to us. See you soon! 💍✨
KK
Katherine K.
The moonstone ring
The moonstone ring was received as a replacement for a previous item. The ring is captivating. The sight and feel of the ring on my hand is a testament to the workmanship and quality of materials.
Response from Susan JewelryMay 26, 2026
What a beautiful way to describe your experience thank you so much for sharing it with us! 🪪✨
We're so glad we were able to make things right with the replacement, and even more delighted that the moonstone ring has truly captivated you. That stone is something special, and it sounds like it found the perfect home on your hand!
Your words about the craftsmanship and quality mean so much to us we pour a great deal of care and passion into every piece, and knowing it shows makes every bit of it worthwhile. Thank you for giving us the chance to make it right, and for being such a gracious and wonderful customer. We hope you enjoy wearing it for many years to come! 💍✨
MA
Mary Ann W.
The quality of the jewelry is great
The quality of the jewelry is great! Looks a lot more expensive. I do have a question - I submitted a request via email to see if I could get a larger size but haven’t heard . Is this not possible? And also I received 2 ring sets but I thought I had only bought one! Could you clarify?
Response from Susan JewelryMay 26, 2026
Thank you so much, we're thrilled you love the quality! That's exactly what we aim for, pieces that feel luxurious without the luxury price tag. 💍
We're so sorry you haven't heard back about your size request that's definitely not the experience we want for you! And we completely understand the confusion about receiving two ring sets.
Please reach out to us directly at [email protected] and we'll get both of these sorted out for you right away. You deserve nothing less than a smooth, happy experience from start to finish, and we're here to make that happen! 🌟
CU
customer
excellent customer service
Haven't received my ring yet, but the Customer Service is "Outstanding".........Best of Luck in all your new adventures :)
Response from Susan JewelryMay 26, 2026
Thank you so much for the kind words! 🥰
We're so glad our customer service team was able to make a great impression, we truly put our heart into every interaction. We can't wait for your ring to arrive and wow you just as much! Wishing you all the best as well, and thank you for being part of the Susan Jewelry family. 💍✨
CU
customer
Lovely, elegant, and versatile!
Lovely elegant earrings that would work for a nice evening out or to dress up yours jeans! I love the service and style at Susan’s. Don’t miss this sale!
Response from Susan JewelryMay 10, 2026
Thank you so much for your lovely review!
We’re delighted to hear that you love the elegance and versatility of the earrings. It means a lot to know you’re enjoying both our style and service. Your kind support truly brightens our day, and we hope you continue to find pieces you love at Susan’s. Enjoy your beautiful new earrings!
CC
Carlynn Coleman G.
The ring was very pretty and unique
The ring was very pretty and unique! I love it! Customer service has been great and the shipping was very timely.
Response from Susan JewelryMay 10, 2026
Thank you so much for your wonderful feedback!
We’re thrilled to hear that you love the ring and found it pretty and unique. It’s also great to know that you had a positive experience with our customer service and shipping. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again in the future!
SA
Susan A.
I love my ring!
I love my ring!! Very pretty! Customer service is awesome! They answered my questions immediately! Thank you for a very pleasurable experience!!!
Response from Susan JewelryMay 9, 2026
Oh this made us so happy to read! 🥹💛
We are so thrilled that you love your ring and that our team was able to make your experience such a pleasurable one that is exactly what we are here for! Fast, caring and attentive service is something we take so much pride in and knowing it made a difference to you means the world to us. 🌸
Thank you so much for sharing your experience and for the kind words you are so appreciated! We hope you enjoy wearing your beautiful ring every single day! ✨
AA
Ann A.
This is the Absolute best shopping experience
This is the Absolute best online jewelry shopping experience I’ve ever had in my life, from start to finish from Susan Jewelry.
First of all, one of the most important things is Customer Service. Susan Jewelry is a class act and they truly go above and beyond and have Grade A, 100% Best Customer Service I’ve ever had. Shipping is seamless and smooth, you immediately get your invoice with your order number and you can start tracking it right away and you see the process it goes through in real time. You get your orders within a week, maybe less.
Their response time is Excellent! I never had to wait more than a couple hours, if that, anytime I had a question. Customer Service is SO important! And it’s obvious it’s Super Important to them. I felt like I had an expert jewelry shopper, in person, right next to me the whole time. I felt heard, my questions were answered, from the big things to the little things, just Outstanding! I can hardly even put it into words that’s how good it was. I felt safe, secure, it was fun, and I’m not a big electronic person, in general, but this was so much fun and the experience of talking to someone who not only knew their products, but they know jewelry and are jewelry experts and enthusiast's at that, was Amazing! I felt like they were more excited than I was that I got jewelry that fit me, my personality, that I felt comfortable asking about opinions, options, about everything and anything. I felt Important! I felt pampered and it was at a time when I really needed it-they delivered it all! And still do because they are on my favorites list and I indulge! You’d be a fool not to, that’s the nicest way I can put it-lol!
When receiving messages back and forth, it felt like I was talking to a family member, who was very important to them and they always give me all of the information and attention. All options that fit, literally and jewelry that fit me and my lifestyle as well as my personality.
Now on to the quality of the jewelry. It is Outstanding and Beautiful jewelry and the Craftsmanship, that flare of Vintage Sheikh, handmade with love down to every last detail. The jewelry is comfortable. They made sure of that. One of the rings I got was too big and they immediately replaced it and even let me keep the one I already got so I wouldn’t have to go through the nightmare of the shipping process back to them. And if anything happens or goes wrong, they make it right, immediately and keep you updated and posted on everything. And it was them who offered to replace the ring when I told them it was too big. I was happy and fine about it and could just gift it or find a way to fit it and I didn’t complain, but I was immediately contacted by them to fix the problem, Susan Jewelry made me feel appreciated by them, never disturbed or rushed and the jewelry in real life exceeded my expectations by SO much, again, it’s hard to put it into words. The jewelry is heavy, in a good way, durable, not flimsy. The gemstone in one of my rings I got, that had a gemstone, was so shiny and luminous and the color of that gemstone shined even in dark lighting and in brighter lighting, it’s just Insanely Gorgeous, bright, catches the light and shines so bright whether you turn it side to side or not. It is so much better than I could have ever expected. From one ring to the other they are upscaled, strong with that vintage touch and feel and with the Amazing Craftsmanship you’re getting. This jewelry is like art coming to life. I can’t stop looking at each piece I started to get. So, listen, if you order one piece of jewelry from Susan Jewelry you get it, you feel it’s sturdiness, you feel the comfortable fit, and if you go through any kind of Customer Service, you WILL be ordering more pieces, so keep your Debit/Credit cards handy because you would be a fool to miss out on such quality jewelry.
And the pricing is ridiculous, it’s so affordable. When I wear my rings out I always get compliments and immediately they want to know where to find the Susan Jewelry site online. My Family and Friends are hooked as well. The only thing they complain about is that they want more and more pieces to their growing collection, as I do as well. From wonderful Customer Service, being tailored to you, how Beautiful the pieces are and how well made they are, the touch of Love you feel in every curve, shine, reflection off the lights, even dim lights when you get the pieces with gemstones, the silky but sturdy feel of the material itself, it’s an experience from start to finish and my Family, Friends and I are addicted to buying one piece after the other.
If you do decide to want to go to their site, you will not be disappointed. And I am a real person, I have so much passion about Susan Jewelry, I could not, not leave this review. I’ll send some pics on my hands as well when I have more space to put it.
-Ann
Susan’s Jewelry
Response from Susan JewelryMay 9, 2026
Ann, we are completely speechless! 🥹💛
This is without a doubt the most beautiful, heartfelt review we have ever received and we read every single word with the biggest smiles and the fullest hearts. Thank you from the absolute bottom of our souls for taking the time to share this it means more than you will ever know.
You described exactly what we pour into everything we do the love, the care, the attention to every little detail, and the deep desire to make every single customer feel special, heard, and pampered. Knowing that you felt all of that so deeply is the greatest reward we could ever receive. 💕
And the fact that your family and friends are now hooked too that is everything! You have become part of our family and that is exactly how we want every customer to feel. 🌸
We promise to keep delivering that same love and dedication in every piece and every interaction. You deserve nothing less. Thank you for being such a passionate, loyal and extraordinary part of the Susan Jewelry family Ann we adore you! 🌟
We cannot wait to see those photos on your hands! 💍✨