Joseph W.
Geek Squad Protection Failed After Catastrophic Phone Defect
I bought Geek Squad Protection for $69.99 with a $240 Motorola Edge phone on November 25, 2025. On December 2, the phone experienced a battery failure that caused flames to shoot out of the side. The phone, case, and screen protector were destroyed. I returned it the same day and, despite having the protection plan, was charged $45 for a replacement phone. Less than three weeks later, the replacement device failed and would not charge past 10 percent. At that point, the support process broke down. The store could not locate my protection plan and sent me to Geek Squad. Geek Squad confirmed the plan and sent me back to the store, which then stated they do not replace Android batteries and instructed me to file a repair or replacement claim. I filed the claim. The insurer, Assurant, told me the model was discontinued and could not be replaced. The only option offered was a “buyout,” which required me to pay $218 upfront so they could then reimburse me. Multiple calls to Assurant ended with the automated phone system disconnecting the call. The protection plan ended up costing more than the phone itself while failing to deliver a functional device. Based on this experience, I cannot recommend Geek Squad Protection.

