Afusat
Very poor
Very poor, after returning my order of 26:50 dollar and I pause for 3dollars for return, small pet select refund me 10dollars out of 26.50 I will never buy form this company again

Small Pet Select delivers the freshest hay, as well as food, bedding, snacks, and more for rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, and other small animals. We also carry hard-to-find items for dogs and cats!
Small Pet Select (smallpetselect.com) has 1,126 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 29 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
Afusat
Very poor, after returning my order of 26:50 dollar and I pause for 3dollars for return, small pet select refund me 10dollars out of 26.50 I will never buy form this company again
Lina
Won't allow you to cancel a subscriptions
Response from Small Pet SelectMay 6, 2026
Hi Lina, Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re truly sorry for the confusion caused by the timing of your cancelation request. Since our fulfillment team begins processing and packing orders very early in the morning to ensure fast delivery, your order had already been filled by the time we received your request after 10:30 AM. As a result, the shipment was sent out exactly as originally placed. To help our customers stay ahead of their shipments, we send out both email and SMS notifications 5 days before any subscription is set to process. This gives everyone a window to log in and pause, cancel, or adjust their upcoming order before the fulfillment team gets to work. We see that our support team replied to you via email to provide pre-paid return labels and to confirm that all your subscriptions have been canceled as requested. We’re committed and hope the return process goes smoothly for you. Small Pet Select
GC
I tried to use my reward but it didn't show up in the total but when I go back to "Rewards", it shows up as being used. Kind of feel like I got scammed.
Sophie
Somehow UPS lost my order and Small Pet Select requested an investigation from UPS. I was charged for my order, but Small Pet Select proposition was to wait for the investigation result. I disagree with the Small Pet Select decision regarding my order and I will be requesting refund.
Diana
This company is no different than Kelloggs is for children. Processed slop that left my pigs instantly excreting gritty, nasty LIMESTONE (ie, rocks) that they add in for calcium. It made my pig with interstitial cystitis bleed. Thank God it wasn't a bladder stone. I am so angry because they have literally no way of contacting them. They do not respond, never answer the phone, and don't care if you lose money. Their products are already over the top expensive, and then factor in that they make sure you have to buy a big box of pellets so you waste more money. Never again. I spent a lot of money here too. I bought three boxes of their "treat" mixes (nothing more than hay with a few herbs sprinkled across the top. Barely anything in there), their square biscuit treats, and a huge box of hay. Credit where credit is due - the hay was green and fresh, albeit with a lot more stem than actual hay (second cutting). The pigs ate that. I have no idea why they couldn't just use the hay for the pellets. It's what they eat. The pellets are brown, hard, and over time start to smell like rock and iron instead of food. I am apalled.
Biki B.
I ordered the 10 lb flaked oyster shell and paid about $31 with shipping. I only received 5 lb. I never received an order confirmation or order number. I tried calling (busy signal) and emailing, but the email bounced back. The first email I received from the company was a request to leave a review. I opened a partial dispute with my credit card for the missing items. Disappointing experience.
Response from Small Pet SelectFeb 11, 2026
Hi Biljana, Thank you for taking the time to share this. I’m sorry this has felt like such a disappointing experience. I was able to locate your order using the details from your review. We replied to your email on February 5 at 8:04 AM with the following message: “Thanks for bringing this to our attention. I apologize that you did not receive the tracking info and were sent the wrong size. Your order had to be fulfilled by our other warehouse due to an out-of-stock item at your usual warehouse so the original tracking number was canceled and a new one was generated by the issuing warehouse. Would you be so kind as to send us a photo of the item you received? Our quality assurance team would greatly appreciate it. Rest easy knowing that I'll make sure that the replacement will be shipped out as soon as possible I look fur-ward to your response so we can quickly send out your replacement..” At this time, we have not received a response to that request, and we do not have any record of missed calls or additional emails from you. We also sent a shipment confirmation on January 30, 2026 at 11:40 AM EST with the subject line “Confirmed Shipment.” If you did not see it, it may have landed in a spam or promotions folder. We’re ready to resolve the missing 5 lbs right away. I will resend our original response to your email on file. Please check your email provider's security filters or whitelist our email, so it reaches you 🤞🏻 Please feel free to reply directly to our support email [email protected] so we can take care of this for you and your flock. Small Pet Select
Denise R.
I was a loyal and great customer for a long time then they sent me the worst garbage hay that was dry hard ,yellow , (LESS then first cut quality )it was the worst so I complained to get my money back they refused and sent me was a replacement box of hay that was still under 1st cut quality but allittle better but still dry garbage that my guinea pigs still refused to eat ,complained to them and they dismissed me ! I paid almost $60 expecting 2nd cutting quality hay ! So Im out that money and stuck with all this garbage hay that is not good enough to eat especially when your guinea pigs are used to the second cutting quality so Im out that money , very disappointing how greedy this company and they treat their loyal clients!!! *response to your reply, I was willing to send all the hay back and your company admitted that it wasnt very good quality and Noone offered me any in store credit or I would've taken that but if they knew that the quality was just as bad, why would they send me another batch of garbage hay , not very good customer service or resolution! And the dispute was an accident for the pellets, Im not sure how that happened , but I had every right to dispute the bad hay that was sent twice , you didnt have to deal with all the stress of my guinea pigs not eating and trying to find quality hay online that isn't pet store quality , it was a nightmare when you have 3 guinea pigs are not happy , our pets are our family and when they're used to certain quality, how are you going to give them less !
Response from Small Pet SelectJan 8, 2026
Hi Denise, thank you for your feedback. We would like to clarify the details of this experience from October 21. When you expressed dissatisfaction with your hay, we offered you a choice between store credit or a replacement. You chose the replacement, and we proactively sent a free 20lb 2nd cut box on Oct 30, 2025. It was successfully delivered via UPS. While we always strive for the best quality, we are concerned that you have since filed multiple chargebacks—including one for a completely unrelated order of guinea pig pellets (Order #1423734) that had no reported quality issues or communication. We act in good faith by providing replacements when a customer chooses that resolution. However, we cannot fulfill demands for full refunds on multiple orders after a chosen replacement has already been delivered. We remain committed to our quality standards and the resolutions we provide.
Mrs M C.
I had been buying all my guinea pigs hay and pellets from Small Pet Select this year. It is very expensive, however I was willing to pay for the quality. My guinea pigs favourite hay was the orchard hay. It was lovely and green, and just like dried blades of grass. They ate all I gave them everyday. And the plus for me was it didn't make my throat sore, or nose run like most hay. So, because the pigs loved it, and went through so much, I decided to buy a big box (22.5kg) as it would actually save me money. Unfortunately the quality was not the same as usual, it was hard, if bent it cracked (more like timmy hay), and it was also extremely dusty. You can't touch it without having a handful of dust. The guinea pigs wouldn't touch it. I contacted SPS and said the quality was not up to the usual standard. I was told well it was hay, a natural product, so I can't expect it to be the same each time..... and dust is normal. This wasn't a small amount of dust, it is excessive. And when I have spent nearly £100 on a box of hay, I do expect it to be perfect! I was told if I wanted to send it back I had to take it to a depot..... it weighs 22.5kg, I'm 60, disabled and don't drive! I told them that, and a different person said they could send me 4kg out as an apology if wanted. Not good enough, so sorry, my pigs will go back to meadow hay and Heygates Rabbits Choice pellets.