January B.
Disappointed with Jon McKeever
verall, I am very disappointed with Jonathan McKeever and my experience in his trading room. In my experience, the room often lacks focus on actual trading education. Discussions frequently drift away from actionable market analysis, and it feels like members' questions are often ignored or left unanswered. As someone paying a premium membership fee, I expected much more engagement, transparency, and commitment to helping traders improve. I also found the trading approach to be overly aggressive for many traders, and I would have liked to see more discussion of losing trades and the lessons learned from them. Consistently reviewing both winning and losing trades is an important part of teaching risk management, and I didn't feel enough emphasis was placed on that. For the amount being charged, I don't believe the overall value met my expectations. On the other hand, Melissa is an exceptional trader and educator. Her patience, discipline, and ability to explain complex concepts in a simple, structured way are outstanding. She genuinely takes the time to teach, answer questions, and ensure that members understand the material. Her level of knowledge and teaching ability is exceptional. While Melissa learned from Jonathan, I believe her teaching style sets a much higher standard. Jonathan could benefit from adopting more of Melissa's patience, discipline, transparency, and willingness to engage with members. Overall, this review reflects my personal experience. Unfortunately, I was left disappointed and did not feel the trading room provided the value or support I expected for the price.
Response from Simpler TradingJul 22, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your honest feedback. I'm sorry to hear your experience with Jon's room didn't meet your expectations. Every trader has a different risk tolerance and trading style, and Jonathan is definitely a more aggressive trader. We understand that approach isn't the right fit for everyone, and it's important to find an educator whose style aligns with your own goals and comfort level. I'm also glad to hear how much you've enjoyed learning from Melissa. If her teaching style is a better fit for you, we'd be happy to help you switch to the room where she primarily trades. Just give our support team a call at 512-266-8659, and we'll be happy to assist you.