Sarah Elise JewelrySarah Elise Jewelry is listed under Jewelry & Watches in New York.
Sarah Elise Jewelry (sarahelisejewelry.com) has 106 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing106 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Carlos
I do not recommend ordering internationally from this company. They do not offer free returns, which can make the process expensive and inconvenient. Be sure to check their return policy carefully before purchasing
Nasima B.
I ordered 2 x diamond bracelets for gifts. They put both in one box when I made a note to give 2 boxes. I should have ordered separately to get the boxes for both bracelets. It’s a shame I have to now gift a bracelet to someone which is diamond and gold in a plastic packet. You would think a box would be provided I get better packaging from cheap places that aren’t even gold. What a shame. I’m not happy.
Torin A.
I was looking for a unique piece of jewelry and I found it at Sarah Elise Jewelry. The Ring is absolutely stunning and I've received so many compliments on it. I highly recommend this shop to anyone looking for something special.
Response from Sarah Elise JewelryFeb 12, 2026
Hi, Thank you so much for your kind words! We are thrilled to hear that you found the unique piece you were looking for and that it has been bringing you so many compliments. Knowing that our jewelry makes our customers feel special is exactly why we do what we do. Thank you for recommending our shop; it truly means a lot to our family business! All the best Sarah Elise
Emily R.
I've been looking for a classic diamond necklace for years and I finally found it at Sarah Elise Jewelry. The diamond station mecklace is exactly what I was looking for. It's elegant, timeless, and perfect for any occasion.
Nicole N.
Very happy with my order :)
Teri M.
Very disappointed in the quality of the ring I received. Very thin and junky looking. When I tried to reach out to the company I was also met with complete disregard and was told that my interest in returning the item was past their 14 day window. Buyer beware that any company that has only a 14 day return window probably does so for a reason. They should stand behind their workmanship; their disinterest guaranteed that I will not be purchasing in the future.
Stephanie Z.
I paid $223.20 used a discount code on an item normally priced at $310.00 for a small 18k charm clasp. The item arrived, I couldn't believe how easy it opened by barely pressing it, it didn't lock into place. I did not feel comfortable putting any charm on this holder, since it was obvious it would open too easily. I called the company, the girl told me to return it and could have cared less about my concerns. Shows a lot about the quality of this company
Mia R.
Terrible customer service, they are rude and do nothing to resolve issues with their jewelry. I Don't recommend shopping with them
